The Twilight Zone / Season 2 / Episode 14

The Whole Truth

A used-car dealer who has never told a customer the truth buys a battered Model A from an old man. Whoever owns it can't tell a lie.

  • First aired Jan 20, 1961 · CBS
  • Directed by James Sheldon
  • Written by Rod Serling
  • Starring Jack Carson
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Whole Truth"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Whole Truth"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
The Twilight Zone, "The Whole Truth" (CBS, 1961). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The pitch

    Harvey Hunnicut, fast-talking used-car man, is working his lot the only way he knows: with a lie for every customer.

  2. A very special car

    An old man sells him a beat-up Model A. There's a catch: whoever owns it has to tell the truth.

  3. Honesty, all day

    Harvey tells a young couple his cars are junk, confesses his poker nights to his wife, and admits to Irv that he never gives raises.

  4. Honest Luther

    A politician, Honest Luther Grimbley, nearly buys the car, until he admits he couldn't keep his job without lying.

  5. The perfect buyerSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Harvey pitches it to a party from the Soviet embassy as propaganda. The buyer is a very famous face, and Harvey reaches for the phone.

Why it still matters

Harvey Hunnicut runs a used-car lot and talks like one. Jack Carson plays him at full volume, all patter and wink, and Serling's opening narration sets him up as an expert in con jobs. Then an elderly man sells him a Ford Model A with something very special about it: as long as Harvey owns it, every word out of his mouth is true. His cars are lemons, and now he has to say so.

It's one of the show's broad comedies, built on every used-car-salesman joke you can think of, and it doesn't pretend to be more. Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club called it no great half hour of television, but gave it credit for never forcing in a redemptive moment: Harvey never becomes a better man, he just looks for a way to unload the car.

It also looks different from almost any other episode. It was one of six second-season shows recorded on videotape at CBS Television City to save money, and it has the flat, stagey look of live TV, which rather suits a car lot full of sales talk.

Spoilers from here on. Harvey finds the one customer who can afford the truth.

Get me Jack Kennedy

Harvey can't sell the car to anyone who has to lie for a living, which rules out most of the town. So he sells it to a visiting party from the Soviet embassy, pitching it truthfully as a fine piece of propaganda: proof of how bad American cars are. The last scene makes it plain that the buyer is the Soviet premier, Nikita Khrushchev, and a delighted Harvey asks to be put through to "Jack Kennedy" to tell him about it.

The episode aired the same day Kennedy took office, and Harvey's last line is one of the rare times the series names a sitting president. Serling's closing narration calls the Model A an instrument of truth and imagines what it might do to history, from the Battle of the Marne to the Dodgers at Chavez Ravine. Handlen found the Khrushchev turn goofy and unexplained, though it's the part people remember.

Behind the scenes

  • It was one of six second-season episodes recorded on videotape at CBS Television City to cut costs, then transferred to 16mm film for syndication.
  • The tape experiment saved only about $30,000 across all six episodes, and the results looked stage-bound, like a live drama on Playhouse 90. It was never repeated.
  • It first aired on January 20, 1961, the day John F. Kennedy was inaugurated.
  • When The Twilight Zone Radio Dramas adapted it, the Soviet premier was replaced by a Middle Eastern emir.
  • The A.V. Club gave it a B-minus and singled out Jack Carson for handling both the sharp dialogue and the slapstick. Carson died a couple of years later.

The thread

The show's lighter side: a magic object, and a man who thinks he can work an angle on it.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

The Twilight Zone Radio DramasA radio version that swaps the Soviet premier for a Middle Eastern emir

DNA strand

Sci-Fi Played for Laughs

The fantasy is one small rule, and the comedy comes from watching a professional liar crash into it again and again. Serling has no plans to redeem Harvey; what interests him is where a man like that would find a buyer.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"A Penny for Your Thoughts""The Man in the Bottle"Liar LiarExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Liar Liar

The same one-rule premise stretched to feature length, with Jim Carrey's whole body fighting the truth.

Watch · Twilight Zone

"A Penny for Your Thoughts"

The flip side: instead of telling the truth, a mild bank clerk has to hear it from everyone around him.

Watch · Twilight Zone

"The Man in the Bottle"

Another ordinary man handed something magic, and another lesson in reading the fine print.

Read · Short story

"The Monkey's Paw" — W. W. Jacobs

If you enjoyed a cursed object passed from owner to owner, this is the grim granddaddy of them all.

Sources