The Twilight Zone / Season 2 / Episode 16

A Penny for Your Thoughts

A timid bank clerk tosses a coin for his morning paper, and it lands on its edge. For the rest of the day he can hear what everyone around him is thinking.

  • First aired Feb 3, 1961 · CBS
  • Directed by James Sheldon
  • Written by George Clayton Johnson
  • Starring Dick York and June Dayton
Still from The Twilight Zone, "A Penny for Your Thoughts"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "A Penny for Your Thoughts"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
The Twilight Zone, "A Penny for Your Thoughts" (CBS, 1961). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. On its edge

    Hector Poole flips a coin to pay for his newspaper. It lands standing straight up on the newsstand.

  2. Voices

    At the bank, he starts hearing people's private thoughts as clearly as speech. Some of them are about him.

  3. The loan applicant

    A businessman, Mr. Sykes, wants a big loan. Hector hears what he really plans to do with the money and says so out loud.

  4. Old Mr. SmithersSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Hector overhears a veteran clerk planning to rob the bank, reports him with Helen's help, and is fired when Smithers turns out to be innocent.

  5. Heads, he winsSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Hector uses one more overheard thought to win his job back with a promotion. On the way home he knocks the coin over.

Why it still matters

Hector B. Poole is the kind of bank clerk who apologizes to the furniture. Dick York plays him with a nervous, eager sweetness, and Serling's opening narration ("Flip a coin and keep flipping it") is jovial from the first line, so you know which Twilight Zone you're in. When Hector's coin lands on its edge at the newsstand, he starts hearing thoughts: his boss's, the customers', and those of the coworker who has a soft spot for him.

It's a gentle comedy with good jokes. The best is a single gag where Hector leans close to a pretty blonde to read her mind and finds nothing playing at all. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen thought the premise very, very silly and the first half slow, but he called the ending about as unambiguously happy as the series ever managed. Peter Martin at ScreenAnarchy called it a delightful, if minor, fantasy in which the little guy wins.

George Clayton Johnson wrote it, his first script written directly for the show. Watch York's eyes: he later became Darrin Stevens on Bewitched, and the comic timing is already there.

Spoilers from here on. No catch this time, or almost none.

A human coin, on edge

The one thought Hector gets wrong is the one that matters most. Old Mr. Smithers is innocent: the robbery Hector heard only ever happened inside Smithers' head, and the report gets Hector fired. Then news arrives that Sykes, the customer Hector refused, has been arrested, so he was right about him all along. A much less timid Hector uses what he has heard about his boss Mr. Bagby's affair to get his job back with a promotion, and gets Smithers a trip to Bermuda.

On the way home he bumps the newsstand, the coin falls flat, and the voices stop, which hardly matters now. He walks off with Helen, hopeful, and Serling's closing narration calls him a human coin, on edge for a brief time. It's one of the rare episodes where the magic leaves its owner better off than it found him.

Behind the scenes

  • George Clayton Johnson wrote it. Two season-one episodes had been adapted from his short stories, and this was the first of four he wrote directly for the screen.
  • It was Dick York's second Twilight Zone, after "The Purple Testament" in season one. He later played Darrin Stevens for 156 episodes of Bewitched.
  • York was the second future Bewitched star in two weeks: Agnes Moorehead had carried "The Invaders" the week before.
  • Hayden Rorke, who plays the loan applicant Sykes, later played a suspicious doctor on I Dream of Jeannie.
  • The A.V. Club gave it a B; ScreenAnarchy also gave it a B, praising the "crazy dance" in York's eyes.

The thread

Mind-reading as a comedy of manners: what happens when the polite surface comes off.

Came before

Shares DNA with

"Earshot"Buffy the Vampire Slayer · TV episode · Buffy can suddenly hear everyone's thoughts, a comparison The A.V. Club draws

DNA strand

Sci-Fi Played for Laughs

The power is pure fantasy, and the episode doesn't explain it beyond a coin on its edge. The fun is in the gap between what people say and what they think, and in watching a timid man discover that everyone else is bluffing too.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Whole Truth""Earshot"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Buffy the Vampire Slayer

"Earshot"

Hearing every thought in the room, played for laughs first and then for something sharper.

Watch · Twilight Zone

"The Whole Truth"

The same season's other honesty comedy, louder and broader, with a used-car man stuck telling the truth.

Watch · Twilight Zone

"The Purple Testament"

Dick York's first episode, a war story with a far grimmer kind of second sight at its center.

Read · Novel

The Demolished Man — Alfred Bester

A whole society where mind readers are part of everyday business, and a man trying to keep one thought to himself.

Sources