Star Trek / Season 1 / Episode 1

The Man Trap

The first Star Trek anyone ever saw. A routine medical check on a lonely archaeologist and his wife turns deadly, and McCoy's old flame isn't quite how he remembers her.

  • Aired Sep 8, 1966 · NBC
  • Directed by Marc Daniels
  • Written by George Clayton Johnson
  • Guest starring Jeanne Bal and Alfred Ryder
Still from Star Trek, "The Man Trap"
Still from Star Trek, "The Man Trap"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 3
Star Trek, "The Man Trap" (NBC, 1966). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. House call on M-113

    Kirk, McCoy and a crewman beam down to give the archaeologist Robert Crater and his wife Nancy their medical checkups. Nancy was once McCoy's sweetheart.

  2. Not the same Nancy

    Nancy doesn't look the same to everyone. Crewman Darnell sees a woman he once met on Wrigley's Pleasure Planet.

  3. No salt left

    Darnell turns up dead with a strange mottled face. McCoy and Spock find that every bit of salt has been drained from his body.

  4. Someone aboardSpoiler · tap to reveal

    "Nancy" is the last of a shape-shifting species that feeds on salt, and now it has come aboard the Enterprise wearing a crewman's face.

  5. McCoy's choiceSpoiler · tap to reveal

    It takes McCoy's own form, then Nancy's, and finally attacks Kirk. McCoy has to shoot a creature that looks like the woman he loved.

Why it still matters

On September 8, 1966, NBC introduced America to Star Trek with a monster story on a dusty planet called M-113. Robert H. Justman later wrote that it was picked because it was scarier and easier to sell than the others, and it won its time slot that night. William Shatner thought it was the weakest of the bunch.

It plays more like horror than the Star Trek most people remember, and that's the fun of it. George Clayton Johnson, who had written for The Twilight Zone and would co-write Logan's Run, built it around a creature that looks like whoever you most want to see. McCoy gets the spotlight, Spock gets into a fistfight, and the ending lands on a captain feeling guilty about what it took to survive.

Watch for the small stuff that became the show: Sulu fussing over his plants, Uhura flirting with Spock on the bridge, Uhura in the red uniform she'd wear from then on, and a crew that already feels lived in.

Spoilers from here on. What happened to the real Nancy, and why Crater kept quiet.

The last of its kind

The real Nancy Crater died a year before the Enterprise arrived. The thing wearing her face is the last survivor of a shape-shifting people who once lived on M-113, and it lives on salt. Crater has been feeding it and keeping its secret out of affection for his "Nancy". When it's finally out in the open, he compares it to the buffalo: the last of its kind.

Aboard the ship it kills crewmen, poses as McCoy, and finally corners Kirk in McCoy's quarters and starts to feed. McCoy hesitates, unable to shoot Nancy, until Kirk screams. Even then the creature pleads in her voice, and McCoy asks forgiveness before he fires again. As the ship leaves orbit, Kirk tells Spock he was thinking about the buffalo.

Behind the scenes

  • It was the sixth episode produced but the first to air. NBC's final choice came down to this one and "The Naked Time". It won its time slot with a 25.2 rating in the first half-hour.
  • Johnson's first draft was called "Damsel with a Dulcimer". NBC felt hallucinations were overused after "The Cage", so the apparitions were cut back, and Gene Roddenberry rewrote the script in June 1966. Johnson felt the rewrite downgraded his story.
  • Johnson suggested making the creature a shape-shifter, an idea he had already used in his Twilight Zone episode "The Four of Us Are Dying". He also compared it to the American bison, the last of its kind.
  • Wah Chang designed the creature, and Sandra Gimpel, who had played a Talosian in "The Cage", wore it. On set it was the "salt sucker". Fans call it the salt vampire.
  • Marc Daniels brought it in on schedule and under budget. Justman later called him the savior of the series.
  • It first aired in Canada, on CTV, on September 6, 1966, two days before NBC. In Britain it went out thirteenth, in 1969.

The thread

A vampire story with salt in place of blood, written by a *Twilight Zone* veteran, and a monster that kept coming back.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

"The Unreal McCoy"James Blish · short story · 1967 · the prose adaptation in the first Star Trek book
"Ephraim and Dot"Star Trek: Short Treks · another cameo for the creature

DNA strand

First Contact & Invaders

The first alien most viewers met on Star Trek was a hungry one, and it got in by looking like someone you trust. What keeps the episode from being a plain monster hunt is Crater's argument that it's the last of its kind, and Kirk's unease once it's gone.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Devil in the Dark""The Four of Us Are Dying"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · The Twilight Zone

"The Four of Us Are Dying"

Johnson's earlier shape-shifter story, about a man who can take any face he likes. You can see this episode's creature taking shape.

Watch · Star Trek

"The Devil in the Dark"

If the buffalo line stuck with you, here's the show coming back to a lone creature killing people and asking the question properly.

Watch · Film

The Thing (1982)

An isolated crew and a creature that can look like any of them. It takes the paranoia this episode only flirts with and lets nobody trust anybody.

Read · Novella

Who Goes There? by John W. Campbell

The 1938 story behind The Thing: scientists at a remote base and a visitor that can become any of them.

Sources