
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- June 25, 1876
A cavalry scout, a sergeant and a trooper ride ahead of Custer's column and run into trouble.
- June 25, 1964
Three Guardsmen in an M3 Stuart tank on war games near the battlefield. Their route keeps tracing Custer's.
- War cries
They hear battle cries and horses, see riderless mounts and an empty camp. Connors thinks they've slipped back in time.
On footSpoiler · tap to reveal
On the second day they leave the tank. McCluskey comes back from a cluster of tepees with an arrow in his back.
Over the ridgeSpoiler · tap to reveal
Below them a battle is raging. The three men go down to join it and are never seen again.
Why it still matters
It's June 25, 1964, eighty-eight years to the day since Custer's 7th Cavalry rode to the Little Bighorn. Sergeant Connors and two buddies are crewing a light tank in a National Guard exercise near the battlefield, and their route keeps matching Custer's. They hear war cries and find hoofprints and riderless horses. Connors, who knows the history, starts to suspect where, or when, they are, and his captain over the radio wants none of it.
Serling, a former Army paratrooper, writes soldiers well, and the cast are Western regulars who look at home out there: Ron Foster, Randy Boone and a young Warren Oates, back after "The Purple Testament." Greg Morris, later of Mission: Impossible, plays the lieutenant. The whole thing was shot outdoors on grassy California hills standing in for Montana, which gives it a wide-open look most of the show's stage-bound half hours don't have.
Critics are split. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen called it the best of its week's pair and also a half-formed piece of work.
Names on the monument
From the ridge, Connors, McCluskey and Langsford look down on the Little Bighorn as it's happening. Connors has the line that sums them up: stop it, or join it. They run down the hill with their rifles and vanish. Captain Dennet and Lieutenant Woodard go looking, find the abandoned tank and then the battlefield monument, where three new names are carved among Custer's dead. Dennet won't accept what it means, though he does remark that they could have used the tank. Serling closes on the names, filed under P for phantom in the Twilight Zone's historical ledger.
The episode never says which side they meant to fight on. The names on the memorial suggest Custer's, but nobody says so. Robert Schmidt of the blog Newspaper Rock argues the producers left it vague on purpose, at a time when views of Custer were changing. He also points out that no Native American is ever seen on screen, only the effects of their passing, as the A.V. Club put it. You can read that as a budget limit, a dodge, or an unusually honest admission that this is a story about white soldiers and the myth they wanted to be part of.
Behind the scenes
- The tank is an M3 Stuart light tank, and the story runs on two dates: June 25, 1876, and June 25, 1964, the 88th anniversary of the battle.
- It was shot almost entirely outdoors, on grassy hills that stand in for Montana. George T. Clemens was director of photography and Bert Granet produced.
- It was Alan Crosland Jr.'s third of four Twilight Zone episodes. He also directed "The Old Man in the Cave."
- Warren Oates had appeared in "The Purple Testament," another Serling war story. Greg Morris went on to Mission: Impossible.
- Serling's own Army service was as a paratrooper with the 11th Airborne Division.
- Dennis Etchison adapted it for The Twilight Zone Radio Dramas in 2004, with Richard Grieco.
The thread
Custer on screen, soldiers lost in time, and the battles Serling kept going back to.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Time Loops & Timelines
The past leaks into the present through sounds and hoofprints until the men can't tell which day they're in, and then it takes them. History stays as it was, with room made for three more names.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Twilight Zone S3
"A Quality of Mercy"
Another Serling war story with a supernatural turn, and a lot more to say about who the enemy is.
Watch · Film
Little Big Man (1970)
If the episode's silence about which side was right bothered you, Arthur Penn's film takes Custer's legend apart from the other side of the ridge.
Read · History
Son of the Morning Star by Evan S. Connell
The real battle, the men on both sides and how the legend grew. The best follow-up for anyone who wanted to see what the Guardsmen saw.
Watch · Film
The Final Countdown (1980)
The same what-if, scaled up: a modern warship finds itself near a battle everyone already knows the ending of.
Sources
- “The 7th Is Made Up of Phantoms,” Wikipedia
- “The Twilight Zone (1959 TV series) season 5,” Wikipedia
- Zack Handlen, “The Twilight Zone: "The 7th Is Made Up Of Phantoms"/"A Short Drink From A Certain Fountain",” The A.V. Club, 2014
- Brian Durant, “The 7th is Made Up of Phantoms,” The Twilight Zone Vortex, 2024
- “The Twilight Zone: Season 5, Episode Ten, The 7th Is Made Up of Phantoms,” Great Books Guy
- Robert Schmidt, “Battle of Little Bighorn in Twilight Zone,” Newspaper Rock, 2015
