The Twilight Zone / Season 3 / Episode 15

A Quality of Mercy

August 1945, the Philippines. A green lieutenant orders his worn-out platoon to wipe out a cave full of wounded Japanese soldiers. Then he picks up his binoculars.

  • First aired Dec 29, 1961 · CBS
  • Directed by Buzz Kulik
  • Teleplay by Rod Serling, based on an idea by Sam Rolfe
  • Starring Dean Stockwell and Albert Salmi
Still from The Twilight Zone, "A Quality of Mercy"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "A Quality of Mercy"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
The Twilight Zone, "A Quality of Mercy" (CBS, 1961). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The cave

    August 1945. A spent American platoon has a few sick and wounded Japanese soldiers pinned in a cave, and no reason left to go in after them.

  2. Lt. Katell

    A new lieutenant takes command and orders a frontal attack anyway. The sergeant tells him it will only get men killed.

  3. The binoculars

    Katell drops his binoculars and reaches for them. When he looks up, the men around him are no longer his platoon.

  4. Corregidor, 1942Spoiler · tap to reveal

    He's now Lt. Yamuri, three years earlier, and his captain wants to attack wounded Americans trapped in a cave.

  5. HiroshimaSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Back in 1945, the radio brings news of the atomic bomb. The platoon is told to fall back and wait.

Why it still matters

Rod Serling fought in the Philippines as a paratrooper, and when he writes about soldiers he isn't guessing. Here he takes an idea from Sam Rolfe and builds a half hour around one hard question: what does the man giving the order think the enemy is? Lt. Katell, fresh out of training, has an answer ready. Sgt. Causarano and his exhausted men, who have done the actual fighting, don't want to hear it.

Dean Stockwell makes Katell's eagerness believable, and Albert Salmi's sergeant is the episode's tired conscience. Keep an eye out for a young Leonard Nimoy in a small part as one of the GIs, years before Star Trek.

Fair warning: one stretch of the episode relies on makeup-and-accent casting. Modern critics, including SlashFilm and The A.V. Club, single it out as the part that has aged worst, and they're right. The script's argument for mercy is still worth hearing.

Spoilers from here on. Here's where Katell lands, and how the war catches up with him.

On the other side of the cave

In the Twilight Zone, Katell becomes Lt. Yamuri on Corregidor in May 1942, with the war going Japan's way. Now it's Americans who are sick and wounded in a cave, and Yamuri's captain who wants them finished off. Katell, in Yamuri's uniform, hears himself making the arguments his own sergeant made an hour earlier. He loses, and is relieved of command for refusing the order.

He looks through the binoculars again and he's back in 1945, just as the radioman reports that an atomic bomb has been dropped on Japan. The attack is called off. Causarano shrugs the whole thing away, and Katell, shaken, says he hopes this kind of thing doesn't happen again. Serling closes with Portia's speech from The Merchant of Venice, the source of the title, and says it applies to any group of soldiers and any nation on the face of the Earth.

Behind the scenes

  • Serling's teleplay is based on an idea by Sam Rolfe, a screenwriter who co-created Have Gun – Will Travel and later worked on the first season of The Man from U.N.C.L.E.
  • Serling served in the Philippines in World War II as a paratrooper with the U.S. Army's 11th Airborne Division. He had already drawn on that war in "The Purple Testament."
  • The jungle was built on a sound stage at Hal Roach Studios in Culver City, instead of the series' usual MGM lot.
  • Producer Buck Houghton and Serling cast Dean Stockwell after he had been considered for "The Purple Testament" and couldn't fit it into his schedule.
  • Leonard Nimoy plays Hansen, one of the GIs. He was still picking up small TV parts in 1961.
  • In Serling's on-air preview he called it "The Quality of Mercy"; the broadcast title is "A Quality of Mercy." It was later adapted for The Twilight Zone Radio Dramas, with Robert Knepper.

The thread

Soldiers made to see the war from the other trench, from Shakespeare's courtroom to Iwo Jima.

Came before

The Merchant of VeniceWilliam Shakespeare · play · Portia's "quality of mercy" speech gives the episode its title and closing words

Shares DNA with

Quantum LeapDonald P. Bellisario · TV series · 1989 · Stockwell again, in a show built on waking up in someone else's life

Left its mark on

The Twilight Zone Radio DramasAudio adaptation · with Robert Knepper

DNA strand

Us vs. Them

The whole episode is one move: take a man who has decided the enemy isn't quite human and put him in the enemy's boots. Serling writes the Japanese captain exactly as Katell was an hour earlier, and the cave looks the same from either side of the line.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Purple Testament"Letters from Iwo JimaExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Twilight Zone S1

"The Purple Testament" (1960)

Serling's other Philippines war story, about a lieutenant who can see which of his men are going to die. It has the same jungle mood and an even sadder premise.

Watch · Film

Letters from Iwo Jima (2006)

If Katell's trip across the lines stayed with you, this is the full-length version: the same war, seen entirely from inside the Japanese garrison.

Read · Novel

All Quiet on the Western Front — Erich Maria Remarque

The classic novel about an ordinary soldier realizing the enemy across the wire is just as tired and scared as he is.

Watch · TV series

Quantum Leap (1989)

A whole series built on waking up in a stranger's life and seeing their side of things, with Dean Stockwell in the co-starring role.

Sources