Star Trek / Season 3 / Episode 12

The Empath

Kirk, Spock and McCoy go looking for a missing research team on a world whose sun is about to explode. They end up in a dark room with a woman who can't speak, and two aliens who want to see what they're made of.

  • Aired Dec 6, 1968 · NBC
  • Directed by John Erman
  • Written by Joyce Muskat
  • Guest starring Kathryn Hays
Still from Star Trek, "The Empath"
Still from Star Trek, "The Empath"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek, "The Empath" (NBC, 1968). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. A star about to blow

    The Enterprise comes to Minara II to collect a research team before its sun goes nova. The station is empty.

  2. Gem

    The landing party is pulled underground, where they meet a mute woman McCoy names Gem. Two aliens, Lal and Thann, appear and hurt Kirk.

  3. She heals

    Gem takes Kirk's injuries onto herself and they heal. She's an empath, and the Vians are watching her closely.

  4. The testSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The Vians torture Kirk while Gem watches. Then McCoy drugs Kirk and Spock so he can be the next subject himself.

  5. Would she die for him?Spoiler · tap to reveal

    McCoy lies near death behind a force field. Gem hesitates, then reaches for him, and McCoy pushes her away.

Why it still matters

This is the bare-stage episode. The underground set is almost nothing: black walls, black floor, black ceiling, a few pools of light. Director John Erman had made a similar stripped-down interrogation story for The Outer Limits, and he uses the darkness to make the whole thing feel like a play performed for an audience of two.

Joyce Muskat was a young Star Trek fan fresh out of UC Berkeley, working as a newspaper reporter, when she wrote it; it's her only screen credit. DeForest Kelley counted it among his favourites, and it's the best McCoy has to do in the third season. Kathryn Hays plays Gem without a word of dialogue.

It has a split reputation. Some fans like it for putting Kirk, Spock and McCoy at the centre together. Keith R.A. DeCandido at Reactor called it "a tiresome slog," The A.V. Club gave it a C-, and the BBC kept it off British screens until the 1990s. Whatever you make of it, it's a strange, uncomfortable hour.

Spoilers from here on. What the Vians were testing, and who passed.

A test of compassion

Minara's sun is going nova, and the Vians can save only one of the system's peoples. They're testing Gem's species to see if it's worth saving, and the measure is whether she will risk her own life for someone else. The missing scientists, Linke and Ozaba, died of fear during earlier tests, and the Vians have prepared cases with Kirk's, Spock's and McCoy's names on them.

McCoy's sacrifice is the turning point. He sedates his friends so they can't volunteer, takes the Vians' torture, and then refuses Gem's help because he doesn't want her to die for him. Kirk tells the Vians that Gem has already proved what they wanted to know, and that they're the ones who have lost their compassion. The Vians heal McCoy, agree to save Gem's people and vanish with her. Back on the ship, Scotty calls her a "pearl of great price."

Behind the scenes

  • Muskat's script began as "The Answerer," drawing on When Worlds Collide and an ancient Egyptian custom of having someone speak for a person being judged. Story consultant Arthur Singer retitled it. She wasn't in the Writers Guild, which saved the production money in a lean season.
  • John Erman was hired because he had directed a similar minimalist interrogation story, "Nightmare," for The Outer Limits. It's his only Star Trek episode.
  • The underground scenes were shot on Paramount's Marathon stage 1, with black walls, floor and ceiling to suggest endless space. Filming ran July 25 to August 2, 1968.
  • George Duning's score uses a Yamaha electric organ; Duning said it was among the first uses of the instrument in a Hollywood score.
  • It was the season's second most-watched episode after "Spock's Brain," with a 34 percent share, but NBC didn't repeat it in the summer of 1969.
  • The BBC banned it with three other episodes, and it wasn't shown in Britain until the 1990s.

The thread

Bare-stage interrogations, judges from beyond, and a doctor who goes first.

Came before

"Nightmare"The Outer Limits · 1963 · John Erman's earlier minimal interrogation story, and the reason he got this job

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

"The Healing Arts"Star Trek: Voyager short story · returns to the Vians and names them the Anjurwan

DNA strand

Trapped With Strangers

Three officers, a mute stranger and two watchers in a black room with no way out. Everything that matters here happens between the people trapped together, and the episode's question is which of them will put someone else first.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Arena""Nightmare"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Star Trek S1

"Arena" (1967)

If the Vians' test was what you kept thinking about, here's an earlier one: Kirk set against an alien by beings who want to see what humans will do.

Watch · The Outer Limits

"Nightmare" (1963)

John Erman's earlier hour of prisoners and interrogators, and the episode that got him hired for this one.

Watch · Star Trek S1

"The Devil in the Dark" (1967)

Another hour about compassion for a being who can't speak for itself, with McCoy facing a patient unlike any he's seen.

Sources