
The story in 5 beats
- The specialist
The Enterprise picks up Tam Elbrun, a gifted and troubled telepath, for a first-contact mission. Troi knew him as a patient, and Riker would rather he stayed home.
- A ship that's alive
The target, codenamed Tin Man, is a living ship orbiting a star that's about to blow, in Romulan-claimed space. The Romulans want it too.
- Quiet company
Overwhelmed by the crew's thoughts, Elbrun takes refuge with Data, the one mind aboard he can't hear.
Gomtuu wakesSpoiler · tap to reveal
A Romulan warbird disables the Enterprise. The living ship wakes, destroys the warbird and tells Elbrun its name: Gomtuu.
Two of a kindSpoiler · tap to reveal
Gomtuu wants to die in the supernova. Elbrun beams over with Data and decides to stay, and Gomtuu throws the other ships clear before the blast.
Why it still matters
Tam Elbrun is one of TNG's best one-off guests. He's a Betazoid whose telepathy never switches off, so every room full of people is a room full of noise. Deanna Troi knew him when he was a patient, and Riker knows him as the specialist from a first contact that cost 47 Starfleet lives. Harry Groener, later the Mayor on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, plays him as a man who badly needs everyone to stop thinking so loudly.
The other star is "Tin Man" itself, a huge living ship orbiting a star about to go supernova, in space the Romulans claim. What it is and what it wants is the mystery, and for a race against a Romulan warbird the episode answers it more gently than you'd expect.
Then there's Data. Elbrun can't hear a single thought from him, which makes him restful company, and the two outsiders get on better than anyone else aboard.
A home for a man who couldn't have one
Gomtuu is thousands of years old. Its crew died in a radiation accident long ago, and it has drifted alone ever since, with nothing left to live for, so it has come to the star to die. Elbrun understands it better than anyone could, having spent his life swamped by other minds and never belonging among them. Aboard the ship, its mind floods his at first, and then he finds he fits.
With the Romulans closing in, Picard lets Elbrun and Data beam over. Elbrun stays, and Gomtuu has a crew again. Instead of dying, it flings the Enterprise and the Romulans out of the system just before the star explodes, and goes on its way. Data comes home with the same realization from the other side: this ship is where he belongs.
Behind the scenes
- The writers adapted their own short story "Tin Woodman," a Nebula nominee in 1977, which they had expanded into a 1979 novel. They redeveloped it as a spec script after hearing the show only wanted bottle episodes.
- The pair decided to pitch after they both disliked the first five minutes of "Samaritan Snare." Once the script was bought, they were told it would go into production a week later.
- Groener's Elbrun was the first male Betazoid seen on the show. Gomtuu's look was inspired by the thermal pods in The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension.
- To show a chair forming inside Gomtuu, Robert Legato melted a wax chair and ran the footage backward. The ship's interior hum is sound editor James Wolvington's stomach, recorded through a stethoscope.
- It was Jay Chattaway's first Star Trek score.
- Captain DeSoto of the USS Hood, mentioned in the pilot as Riker's old commanding officer, appears in person here, played by Michael Cavanaugh.
- Director Robert Scheerer was disappointed with the result and felt he could have made a better episode. It drew a 10.2 Nielsen rating.
The thread
The writers' own novel, the Oz character who wanted a heart, and other stories of minds that only make sense to each other.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Seen again
DNA strand
First Contact & Invaders
Most first contacts on Trek are about getting the words right. This one is about the only person who can listen, and what listening costs him. The alien turns out to be as lonely as its contact man, and the meeting ends up as two outsiders finding each other.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek S3
"Is There in Truth No Beauty?" (1968)
Another telepath working with an alien mind no one else can reach, and another crew uneasy about the person in the middle.
Read · Novel
Tin Woodman, David Bischoff and Dennis Bailey
The book this episode came from. The crew and the ending had to change to fit Trek, so it's worth tracking down if Elbrun stayed with you.
Read · Novel
Solaris, Stanisław Lem
Scientists orbit a living ocean the size of a planet and spend years trying to make contact. A harder, stranger book about the same wish to be understood by something huge.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S2
"The Measure of a Man" (1989)
If Data's quiet scenes with Elbrun were the part you liked, this is the episode that puts the question of what Data is on trial.