
The story in 5 beats
- A private matter
Picard refuses to let Pulaski replace his artificial heart aboard ship and takes a shuttle to Starbase 515, with Wesley along for his exam.
- Make it go
The Pakled ship Mondor asks for help. Riker judges them harmless and sends Geordi over to fix their navigation system.
- The Nausicaan
On the shuttle, Picard opens up to Wesley about a fight in his youth, when a Nausicaan stabbed him in the back.
HostageSpoiler · tap to reveal
Once the repairs are done, the Pakleds stun Geordi with his own phaser and raise their shields. They want weapons.
Crimson forcefieldSpoiler · tap to reveal
Riker bluffs the Pakleds with a harmless light show while Geordi disables their weapons. At the starbase, the surgery goes wrong.
Why it still matters
This is the episode that told us Jean-Luc Picard has an artificial heart. It needs replacing, and rather than let Dr. Pulaski do it aboard ship, where the crew would know, he takes a shuttle to Starbase 515 for the operation. Wesley comes along to take his Starfleet Academy entrance exam, and over the long trip a famously private captain finally tells him how he lost the original.
The other half introduces the Pakleds, a species who come across as harmless and none too bright, asking for help repairing their ship, the Mondor. Riker sends Geordi over to fix it. Even Worf thinks sending him alone is a bad idea.
Critics mostly have it in for the Pakled plot and save their praise for the shuttle, where Patrick Stewart makes Picard's story land. The show came back to that story four seasons later, in "Tapestry."
Not as slow as they look
The Pakleds' breakdown was a ruse. Once Geordi has fixed their ship, main power fails, a Pakled stuns him with his own phaser, and the Mondor raises its shields. Data works out what's going on: they collect other people's technology, and now they want the Enterprise's. Troi warns Riker that Geordi is in danger, and Riker, still sure the Pakleds aren't a threat, hesitates.
The rescue is a bluff in the tradition of Kirk's corbomite. Riker and Worf get a plan to Geordi in code the Pakleds can't follow. The Enterprise puts on a spectacular but harmless display, a "crimson forcefield" made of hydrogen, while Geordi disables the Pakleds' weapons. Convinced they've been beaten, they let him go.
Meanwhile Picard's operation runs into complications, and the starbase doctors realize he'll die without a specialist. Word reaches the Enterprise. He wakes to find that Pulaski finished the job, and she promises to keep his secret. Back on the bridge, the crew applauds, and he shuts them up fast. His line about his health, a garbled Mark Twain, is that rumors of his brush with death are greatly exaggerated.
Behind the scenes
- Robert L. McCullough wrote it from an outside pitch. The Pakleds Reginod and Grebnedlog are named for the pitch writer and his best friend, Doniger and Goldenberg, spelled backwards.
- Director Les Landau described the Pakleds as "ugly and slow," driven by "a need for things." Portly actors were cast to suggest Tweedledum and Tweedledee, and Michael Westmore's prosthetics led the crew to nickname them the "Shar Peis."
- The plan was a new set for the captain's yacht, but there was no budget for another standing set, so the shuttle set was reused. A script change has Picard say he's in shuttlebay two while standing over a large "3" on the floor.
- Writers Dennis Bailey and David Bischoff disliked the first five minutes so much that they pitched their own story. It became "Tin Man" in season three.
- Bailey's verdict: "none of the plot could have happened if all of the characters hadn't suddenly became morons that week." Keith R.A. DeCandido's Tor.com rewatch gave it a 2 out of 10, though Wired listed it among TNG's best in 2012.
- It's the last appearance of Lycia Naff's Ensign Sonya Gomez, introduced the week before in "Q Who."
- The Pakleds never returned as main villains on TNG, but "Brothers" mentions that they rescued Lore, and they came back as real antagonists in Star Trek: Lower Decks.
The thread
A captain with a secret, and a crew of con artists who are easy to underestimate.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
First Contact & Invaders
The Federation's habit of helping anyone who asks is the weak spot here. The Pakleds look too simple to be a threat, and that's exactly how they get a hostage. It's a small, sly twist on first contact: the danger is in how the Enterprise sees them.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · TNG S6
"Tapestry"
If Picard's story on the shuttle was the best part, this is the episode that goes back and lets you see it.
Watch · Star Trek
"The Corbomite Maneuver"
The original Starfleet bluff, played with a straight face and a lot more tension.
Watch · Star Trek: Lower Decks
"No Small Parts"
Decades later, Lower Decks turned the Pakleds into a genuine threat.
Read · Classic
Through the Looking-Glass — Lewis Carroll
Tweedledum and Tweedledee, the pair the Pakleds were cast to resemble. Carroll's version is better company.
Sources
- “Samaritan Snare,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Samaritan Snare",” Reactor
- James Hunt, “Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Samaritan Snare,” Den of Geek, 2013
- “Tin Man (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Tapestry",” Reactor
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Badass Pakleds: Star Trek: Lower Decks, "No Small Parts",” Reactor, 2020