
The story in 5 beats
- Barclay
Reg Barclay can't get anything right in engineering. Geordi and Riker want him gone. Picard tells Geordi to give him a chance and bans the nickname "Broccoli."
- His own Enterprise
On the holodeck, Barclay runs a version of the ship where he can stand up to the senior officers and they're cut down to size.
- Small failures
Systems all over the ship start failing for no reason, one after another. Meanwhile Barclay's attempt at counseling with Troi goes badly wrong.
The goddess of empathySpoiler · tap to reveal
Searching for Barclay, Riker, Geordi and Troi walk into his programs and meet themselves: a very short, bumbling Riker and a Troi worshipped as the goddess of empathy.
Barclay's catchSpoiler · tap to reveal
The warp drive jams on and the ship keeps speeding up. Barclay spots the pattern behind the failures and helps save the Enterprise.
Why it still matters
The Enterprise-D was a ship full of confident, gifted people, and this episode is about one who isn't. Reg Barclay is anxious, shows up late and has been nicknamed "Broccoli" behind his back. Geordi and Riker want him transferred. Picard tells Geordi to make him a project instead.
It's also very funny. Barclay copes by building his own Enterprise on the holodeck, where he is bold and admired, and when the senior officers finally stumble into his programs they meet the versions of themselves he has made up. Dwight Schultz, best known as Murdock on The A-Team, plays Barclay so sympathetically that the joke never turns cruel.
Writer Sally Caves said Barclay was a satirical portrait of Trekkies and their attachment to fictional characters. Director Cliff Bole said he didn't see it that way. Fans have argued about it since, and some who first took him as a joke at their expense, like StarTrek.com's Jordan Hoffman, came round to him.
Computer, end program
The failures trace back to the start of the episode, when a container of biological samples leaked and had to be destroyed. A contaminant from it, invisible to sensors, was being carried around the ship by crew members, and Barclay is the one who notices that a member of the engineering team had been present at each failure. Once the matter/antimatter injectors are cleared, the ship comes to a stop and heads for a starbase to be decontaminated, and Geordi gives Barclay the credit for saving it.
In the last scene, Barclay walks back into his holodeck program and says goodbye to his imaginary crew. Then he deletes all of his programs, except one. He's better, and he isn't cured, which is why the ending works.
Behind the scenes
- Dwight Schultz got the part through Whoopi Goldberg. They had worked together on The Long Walk Home, and she pushed the producers to find a role for him.
- Barclay came back four more times on TNG, including "Ship in a Bottle," then in Star Trek: First Contact and six episodes of Voyager.
- Many fans took the episode as satire aimed at them. Cliff Bole said he "certainly didn't approach it that way," and Michael Piller denied it too.
- Charley Lang makes his first appearance as Duffy, one of Geordi's engineers.
- It drew a 9.8 Nielsen rating, down from 10.2 for "Tin Man" the week before.
The thread
Daydreamers who live better lives in their heads, holodecks that hold up a mirror, and the Barclay stories that followed.
Came before
Shares DNA with
ClipOfficial trailer · Netflix · 0:44Barclay's later appearances
DNA strand
Is Any of This Real?
The episode opens on a scene that isn't real, and the audience doesn't know it yet. From then on the question is how much of Barclay's life happens in his head, and whether that's a problem or the thing keeping him going. The holodeck is a perfect fake, and he knows it, which makes it harder to give up.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Black Mirror S4
"USS Callister" (2017)
An overlooked man builds a starship simulation starring the people from work. Barclay's fantasy, taken somewhere much darker.
Read · Short story
"The Secret Life of Walter Mitty", James Thurber
A mild man drifts into heroic daydreams every time real life gets too much. A few pages long, and Barclay would recognize every one of them.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S6
"Ship in a Bottle" (1993)
Barclay is back, and so is a holodeck problem. A good next step if you want to see how he grew.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S1
"The Big Goodbye" (1988)
Picard escapes into a 1940s detective story on the holodeck. The same urge as Barclay's, from a captain who never needed to hide.
Sources
- “Hollow Pursuits,” Wikipedia
- “Reginald Barclay,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Hollow Pursuits",” Reactor (Tor.com)
- James Hunt, “Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Hollow Pursuits,” Den of Geek, 2014
- Jordan Hoffman, “One Trek Mind #50: Rethinking Reg Barclay,” StarTrek.com
- “Tin Man (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia