
The story in 5 beats
- A rogue in need
The Enterprise finds a damaged cargo ship with one man aboard: Thadiun Okona, who needs repairs and is far more interested in the crew.
- Data's homework
Okona mocks Data for not understanding jokes. Data heads to the holodeck to study comedy with a holographic comic.
- Two angry fathers
Ships from two planets arrive. One leader says Okona got his daughter pregnant, the other says he stole a state treasure, the Jewel of Thesia, and both want him.
Okona confessesSpoiler · tap to reveal
Okona claims he's the father, and the claim shakes the truth loose. The real couple steps forward.
Take my Worf, pleaseSpoiler · tap to reveal
Data's stand-up show goes nowhere, but as Okona leaves he gets a laugh on the bridge without trying, then tries again on purpose.
Why it still matters
Nobody puts this on a list of the best Next Generation episodes, and it doesn't ask to be. It's a light hour about a flirt in a battered freighter who lands the Enterprise in the middle of a feud between two neighboring planets, with Picard as the reluctant referee. Patrick Stewart's reactions to the feuding families do a lot of the work.
The half people remember is Data. Okona teases him for not getting jokes, so Data goes to the holodeck and asks a holographic stand-up comic, played by Joe Piscopo, to teach him. Brent Spiner working through the material with total sincerity is the reason to watch, and under the shtick the episode wonders whether making people laugh has anything to do with being human.
Den of Geek's verdict was "basically skippable" for Trek lore but worth watching for the Data material alone, and that's about right. Look for Teri Hatcher, years before she played Lois Lane, as a transporter officer Okona flirts with.
The jewel and the baby
Okona didn't steal the Jewel of Thesia and he isn't the father. The jewel was a courting gift from Benzan to Yanar, two young people from the feuding sides who are in love, and Benzan is the father of Yanar's child. Okona had been helping the couple meet in secret. By claiming the baby as his own, he forces Benzan to own up, and the whole story comes out.
Before he goes, Okona tells Yanar not to give up on Benzan just because their parents can't get along. The two declare their love, and the fathers are left bickering about the wedding instead of a war. Okona's ship is fixed, and he flies off.
Data's story ends on a quieter note. In the holodeck the audience laughs at everything he does, even mid-joke, which tells him nothing. Guinan points out that getting a laugh isn't the final measure of being human. Then, as Okona departs, Data gets a real laugh from the bridge crew by accident, and follows it up with a string of deliberate bad jokes, "Take my Worf, please!" among them.
Behind the scenes
- William O. Campbell added the initial to his credit to avoid confusion with William Campbell, who had acted on the original series. He'd been a candidate for Riker, but the producers found him "too soft."
- Jerry Lewis was originally scheduled to play the Comic but had a conflict with Wiseguy. Joe Piscopo took the part and ad-libbed most of his lines.
- Teri Hatcher's role as transporter chief B.G. Robinson was mostly cut, and she asked not to be credited.
- Composer Ron Jones gave Okona a theme on French horns to evoke a classic swashbuckling hero. His offer to write background music for Ten Forward was turned down.
- Okona came back 33 years later in Star Trek: Lower Decks, as the DJ at a starbase party in "An Embarrassment of Dooplers."
The thread
Feuding families, a lovable rogue, and the start of Data's long project to understand a joke.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Sci-Fi Played for Laughs
Most of the comedy comes from an android taking comedy seriously: he studies it, rehearses it and is baffled when a hologram audience laughs at everything. The joke Data finally lands is one he didn't plan.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek: Lower Decks
"An Embarrassment of Dooplers"
If Okona's swagger was the fun part, he turns up decades later behind the turntables at a Starfleet party, which is about where you'd expect to find him.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG
"The Schizoid Man"
Two episodes later, more Data trying to understand people, and Brent Spiner gets to play someone else entirely.
Read · Play
Romeo and Juliet, William Shakespeare
Two families at war and two kids in love behind their backs. Okona makes a much more cheerful go-between.