.jpg?width=960)
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- A ship that won't stop
Kirk chases an unregistered cargo ship and extends his shields around it to save it from an asteroid. The strain burns out all but one lithium crystal circuit.
- Captain Leo Walsh
Aboard come its captain and three dazzling women, Eve, Ruth and Magda. Every man on the ship is smitten except Spock.
- Harry Mudd
At a hearing, the computer catches "Walsh" lying. He's Harry Mudd, a criminal with a long record, and in the middle of all this the last crystal fails.
Rigel XIISpoiler · tap to reveal
The ship limps to a mining planet for new crystals. The miners want the women in trade, and Kirk can't hold orbit for long.
The Venus drugSpoiler · tap to reveal
Mudd's secret is a pill that makes the women beautiful for a while. Eve reaches for one more to win Childress back.
Why it still matters
This is the debut of Harcourt Fenton Mudd, Star Trek's first great rogue: an interstellar con man with a long criminal record and no shame at all. Roger C. Carmel plays him like a carnival barker who's sure he's the most charming man in any room, and the show liked him enough to bring him back. Zack Handlen at The A.V. Club called it the first openly comic episode of the series.
It's also a western in a spacesuit, and a pretty frank one for 1966. Mudd is shipping three brides to settlers on a mining world, and the crew go weak at the knees whenever the women walk past. Some of that has dated badly, and the episode doesn't always know which jokes are on whom. Under the leering, though, it asks a real question about beauty and what people want from each other.
It came close to being the second pilot: it was one of three stories in the running before NBC chose "Where No Man Has Gone Before".
The placebo
Chief miner Childress breaks his deal with Kirk, a party turns into a brawl over the women, and Eve runs out into a magnetic storm. Childress finds her, and by the time he wakes the drug has worn off and she looks plainer. Kirk explains: Mudd has been dosing the women with the Venus drug, which gives temporary beauty. He also points out that two of the other miners have already married Ruth and Magda.
Eve swallows what she thinks is another Venus pill and is radiant again. Then Kirk tells her it was a placebo. The confidence was hers all along, and Childress finds that he wants her whoever she is. He hands over the crystals, Eve chooses to stay on Rigel XII, and the Enterprise leaves with Mudd under arrest. Kirk offers to be a character witness at his trial. Mudd predicts they'll throw away the key.
Behind the scenes
- The idea grew from a 1964 concept of Gene Roddenberry's called "The Women".
- NBC reportedly passed on it for the second pilot because it didn't want to launch a series with what it saw as a story about a space pimp.
- It was filmed as the second regular episode, after "The Corbomite Maneuver", and Harvey Hart, in his only Star Trek job, ran a day over schedule because of slow camera setups.
- A long monologue in which Mudd tries to talk Uhura into taking the Venus drug was cut, according to Starlog, for being too wordy.
- Mudd's quarters were Kirk's quarters set with the furniture taken out.
- A third Mudd episode for season three, "Deep Mudd", was dropped because Roger C. Carmel was busy with film work.
The thread
Frontier brides and frontier con men, lifted from the western and dropped into orbit.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Be Careful What You Wish For
Everyone gets what they asked for: the miners get beautiful wives, the women get beauty in a pill, and Mudd gets paid, almost. The catch is that none of it was real, and the one thing that works in the end is a sugar pill and a bit of nerve.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek
"I, Mudd"
Harry Mudd's return, in season two. If Carmel was the best thing here, it's his episode.
Watch · Film
The Music Man (1962)
Another traveling con man selling a town a dream. Mudd would have admired his patter.
Read · Play
Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw
If the placebo twist got you thinking, Shaw had a sharper go at the same idea: how much of a person's charm is the costume, and who gets to decide.
Sources
- “Mudd's Women,” Wikipedia
- “Mudd's Women, 50 Years Later,” StarTrek.com
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek The Original Series Rewatch: "Mudd's Women",” Reactor (Tor.com)
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: "The Enemy Within" / "Mudd's Women",” The A.V. Club
- “50 Years Later: Where No Man Has Gone Before,” StarTrek.com
.jpg?width=330)

