
The story in 5 beats
- A session with Brooks
Troi counsels Ensign Janet Brooks, who is grieving her husband. Then a strange sensor echo hits, and Troi collapses in pain.
- Mind-blind
Her empathy is gone. At the same time, the ship is caught by two-dimensional beings and can't break free.
- Resignation
Troi turns on Crusher, Riker and Picard, insists she's fine, then resigns as counselor. Guinan tries to get through to her.
A cosmic stringSpoiler · tap to reveal
Data and Riker find the creatures are heading for a cosmic string, towing the Enterprise to a place that will tear it apart.
A moth to a flameSpoiler · tap to reveal
Troi works out what draws them. Data fakes a string with the deflector, the ship breaks free and her empathy comes back.
Why it still matters
Deanna Troi spends most episodes helping other people through the worst day of their lives. This one gives her the worst day. Her Betazoid sense of other people's feelings, the thing she has had all her life, switches off, and she compares it to going blind. She works through denial and fury in public, snaps at her friends and hands Picard her resignation, sure she can't do her job without it.
Meanwhile the ship is stuck. Sensors pick up phantom echoes, then the Enterprise is caught in a swarm of two-dimensional lifeforms, flat creatures that show up only when viewed face-on, and they are pulling it somewhere it doesn't want to go.
It was Hilary J. Bader's first writing credit. Reviewers have never been kind to it, but Syfy later picked it out for handing Troi a crisis of her own instead of advice to give, and Marina Sirtis heard from viewers with disabilities after it aired.
Never gone
The flat creatures are on their way to a fragment of cosmic string, and the Enterprise, caught in their pull, is going with them. Contact would destroy the ship. Picard suspects Troi's loss and the ship's trap are linked and asks her to try to reach the creatures anyway, without her gift. She suggests they're drawn to the string like moths to a flame.
So Data gives them another flame, simulating the string's vibration with the deflector, and the swarm swerves long enough for the Enterprise to escape. Troi's empathy comes back as soon as they're clear. It had never left: the creatures' feelings were so strong they drowned out everything else, the way a crowd's roar drowns out a voice.
Behind the scenes
- This was Hilary J. Bader's first writing credit. She had started as a writing intern in the show's third season and went on to write for Deep Space Nine and Voyager, plus Batman: The Animated Series and Xena: Warrior Princess.
- Bader named the T'illi Beta system, where the Enterprise is headed, after her grandmother, Tillie Bader.
- Michael Piller said in an interview that the writers considered making Troi's loss of empathy permanent.
- It's the first mention of the Breen, a species Data says can't be sensed empathically. They weren't seen on screen until Deep Space Nine.
- Kim Braden, who plays the grieving Ensign Brooks, later appeared as Picard's wife in his fantasy of a family in Star Trek Generations.
- Keith R.A. DeCandido notes that Marina Sirtis got a lot of kudos from people with disabilities after the episode aired.
The thread
Flat beings in a round universe, and a counselor learning what her patients feel.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Where it led
DNA strand
Memory & Identity
Take away the one thing that makes Troi who she is and the episode asks what's left. Her answer, by the end, is more than she feared: she solves the problem with the training she'd stopped trusting.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S3
"Tin Man" (1990)
The mirror image of this story: a Betazoid whose empathy is so strong he can't bear to be near people.
Watch · Film
Sound of Metal (2019)
If Troi's anger at losing a sense rang true, this film stays with that feeling for two hours and doesn't look away.
Read · Novel
Flatland by Edwin A. Abbott
For a look at life from the flat creatures' side: a square narrates life in two dimensions, and then meets a sphere.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S2
"Loud as a Whisper" (1989)
A famous mediator who can't hear has to find a new way to make himself understood in the middle of a peace talk.