Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 6 / Episode 21

Frame of Mind

Riker is rehearsing a play about a man in an asylum. Then he wakes up in a real one, where the doctors tell him the Enterprise is the delusion.

  • First aired the week of May 3, 1993 · Syndication
  • Directed by James L. Conway
  • Written by Brannon Braga
  • Guest starring David Selburg, Susanna Thompson and Andrew Prine
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Frame of Mind"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Frame of Mind"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Frame of Mind" (Syndication, 1993). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Rehearsal nerves

    Riker rehearses Crusher's production of Frame of Mind, playing an asylum patient opposite Data's doctor, and can't shake the feeling that people are talking about him.

  2. Undercover

    Picard sends him undercover to Tilonus IV, disguised as a merchant, to recover a missing Federation research team. Worf nicks his temple in a knife lesson.

  3. Ward 47

    Riker wakes in a cell at the Tilonus Institute for Mental Disorders. Dr. Syrus tells him the starship is a delusion, and that he killed a man.

  4. ShatteringSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The two realities keep breaking into each other. Riker turns a phaser on himself to find out which one is real, then sets it to overload.

  5. The operating tableSpoiler · tap to reveal

    He wakes on an alien operating table, grabs his communicator and beams out. Later he takes the stage set apart, alone.

Why it still matters

Riker is rehearsing a play Dr. Crusher is staging, cast as an asylum patient opposite Data's calm doctor, when he starts to feel the crew staring at him. Before long the stage set and a real cell are hard to tell apart, and so are the Enterprise and the hospital. It's the show's most sustained hour of disorientation.

It's Jonathan Frakes's show. Riker usually gets the easy confidence and the trombone; here he gets fear, rage and a long speech on what sanity is. Keith R.A. DeCandido's rewatch called it a bravura performance that deserved Emmy attention, and The A.V. Club thought it his best work on the series to that point.

James L. Conway's direction keeps undercutting whatever looks solid. You settle into a scene for a minute, and then something small is off: a face in the audience, a wound that won't stop bleeding, a crewmate who looks at Riker a beat too long.

Spoilers from here on. Which reality was the real one, and why the play kept showing up.

Neither one was real

Riker was captured on the mission. The Tilonians, with Suna at the console, had him on an operating table with a device in his head, using a neurosomatic technique to pull Federation information out of his mind. The asylum and the Enterprise scenes both came out of that probe. His mind fought back with what it had to hand: the mission he'd been briefed on and the play he'd been rehearsing for weeks.

That's why the asylum looks like Crusher's stage set, and why turning the phaser on himself only drops him into another layer. When Riker finally pounds through the walls of the set, he comes to on the table, disarms the guard, grabs his merchant's necklace communicator and calls for transport. DeCandido's reading is that only the last few scenes really happen, ending with Riker asking for the set and taking it down himself.

Behind the scenes

  • Braga was short on story ideas when he came up with it, StarTrek.com says, and started from the question "What if Riker wakes up in an insane asylum?"
  • Braga cited Roman Polanski's Repulsion as an influence, and wanted to give Riker, who he felt had been underused, an episode of his own.
  • The episode also draws on Tom Stoppard's play Every Good Boy Deserves Favour, set in a Soviet psychiatric hospital.
  • Conway hadn't directed TNG since "The Neutral Zone" in season one. He remembered it as "a great script because most of it, as we learned at the end, was in Jonathan Frakes' imagination."
  • Jaya was the second of Susanna Thompson's four Star Trek roles, after a Romulan in "The Next Phase". She later played Lenara Kahn on Deep Space Nine and the Borg Queen on Voyager.
  • David Selburg, who plays Dr. Syrus, had been Whalen in "The Big Goodbye". Andrew Prine, the administrator Suna, later turned up on Deep Space Nine as Legate Turrel.

The thread

Sane men in madhouses, and people who can't trust the walls around them.

Came before

Every Good Boy Deserves FavourTom Stoppard · play · a sane man locked in a psychiatric hospital, which the episode draws on

Shares DNA with

Shutter IslandDennis Lehane · novel · 2003 · a hospital for the criminally insane where nothing quite adds up

DNA strand

Is Any of This Real?

Most "is this real?" stories give the hero one false world to see through. Riker gets two, each insisting the other is the hallucination, with the play he's rehearsing leaking into both. Because we're inside his head from the first scene, we doubt the Enterprise right along with him.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:Jacob's LadderShutter IslandExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Repulsion (1965)

The film Braga had in mind. If the cracking walls and the faces that watch a little too long got to you, Polanski keeps it up for a whole feature in a London flat.

Read · Play

Every Good Boy Deserves Favour by Tom Stoppard

Two men share a cell in a Soviet psychiatric hospital, one sane and one not. If Riker's speech on sanity was the part you replayed, this is one of the works the episode drew on.

Read · Novel

Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane

A U.S. marshal visits an island hospital and comes to suspect the staff know something he doesn't. The same queasy footing, kept up for a whole novel.

Watch · TNG S4

"First Contact" (1991)

Riker's earlier undercover job on an alien world, played for curiosity and a few laughs.

Sources