
The story in 5 beats
- Surata IV
On a survey, Riker is stabbed by a thorn from a moving vine. It carries an organism that will reach his brain within hours.
- Memory therapy
Pulaski stimulates his brain so he relives past events. The early memories are pleasant, and they make the infection worse.
- Old flames
Romantic memories, including Minuet from the holodeck, feed the organism instead of fighting it.
Bad memoriesSpoiler · tap to reveal
Pulaski and Troi switch to painful ones: Tasha Yar's death, the loss of Troi's child. They help, but not enough.
Fight or flightSpoiler · tap to reveal
As a last resort they push him through fear and survival, faster and faster: Armus, the possessed Admiral Quinn, a Klingon ship.
Why it still matters
"Shades of Gray" is The Next Generation's only clip show, and the episode people name when asked for the show's worst. Keith DeCandido gave it zero out of ten on Tor.com and called it "just an awful, awful episode." Den of Geek's verdict: "Skip it. Skip it and never look back." Fans at the 2016 Star Trek 50th anniversary convention ranked only "Code of Honor" lower, and even its writer, Maurice Hurley, called it terrible.
Why it exists is the interesting part. Season 2 was cut to 22 episodes by the 1988 Writers Guild strike, and two ambitious episodes, "Elementary, Dear Data" and "Q Who," had eaten the money. Paramount wanted something cheap to close the season, so in a sense you're watching the bill for the Borg.
Watch the two episodes that paid for it instead. If you're doing a full run anyway, flashbacks fill about half the running time.
Cured by a montage
Pulaski speeds up the memories of fear and survival until the organism can't take it and dies off, and Riker wakes up fine.
The idea underneath, an organism that feeds on pleasure and retreats from pain, could have made a real episode about what a person's worst memories are for. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen named the problem: the clips are chosen for emotion, so most are moments rather than scenes and never build into anything. Thirty-four years later, Lower Decks tried a similar setup, a crew trapped in a cave swapping stories of old adventures, and Den of Geek argued that it worked where this one failed.
Behind the scenes
- Maurice Hurley, head writer for season 2, proposed a cheap clip show to save money. He later called the result "terrible, just terrible," and worse.
- Rob Bowman expected five days to shoot it, two fewer than usual. Under pressure from Paramount it was done in three, two of them on the sickbay set, and he never saw a final cut.
- Eric A. Stillwell picked the 21 clips. It was the only clip show the series ever made.
- The 1988 Writers Guild strike, 153 days long, cut season 2 to 22 episodes.
- Ron Jones wrote a three-note motif for the virus. Some of Dennis McCarthy's earlier cues were kept, and Jones reworked others.
- This was Hurley's last episode as head writer. He had been behind the firing of Gates McFadden, who was rehired after he left.
- About 9.8 million people watched the first broadcast, the show's biggest audience in two months.
The thread
How a season ran out of money, and the later episode that showed what the idea could have been.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Done better later
DNA strand
Dreams & Nightmares
The premise is a dream story: an unconscious man, his mind as the battlefield, good memories as poison and bad ones as medicine. It's a strong idea the episode never explores. Riker doesn't react to what he relives, so the dreams are just footage.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S2
"Q Who" (1989)
This is where the money went: the Borg's first appearance, and the best argument that the trade was worth it.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S2
"The Measure of a Man" (1989)
If you want to remember season 2 for its best rather than its worst, start here.
Watch · Star Trek: Lower Decks
"Caves" (2023)
The crew swaps stories of past adventures in a cave. A similar shape to this episode, and Den of Geek argues it succeeds where this one failed.
Read · Book
Captain's Logs — Edward Gross and Mark A. Altman
The 1993 book that much of what's known about this episode's making comes from, along with stories about far better ones.
Sources
- “Shades of Gray (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Shades of Gray",” Tor.com, 2011
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "Shades Of Grey",” The A.V. Club, 2010
- James Hunt, “Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Shades Of Gray,” Den of Geek, 2013
- Witney Seibold, “How The 1988 Writers Strike Led To The Worst Episode Of Star Trek: The Next Generation,” SlashFilm, 2023
- Joe George, “Star Trek Just Showed How TNG's Worst Episode Could Have Been One of Its Best,” Den of Geek, 2023
- “List of Star Trek: The Next Generation episodes,” Wikipedia