
The story in 5 beats
- The exercise
Kolrami arrives to judge a mock battle. Riker gets the Hathaway, a derelict with a few dilithium shards and no antimatter.
- Strategema
Riker challenges Kolrami at his own game and loses almost at once. When Pulaski pushes Data to play him, Data loses too, and takes it hard.
- Data steps down
Sure he's malfunctioning, Data relieves himself of duty. Picard tells him it's possible to commit no mistakes and still lose.
Junkyard tricksSpoiler · tap to reveal
Wesley smuggles antimatter aboard in a school project. Worf fakes a Romulan warship on the Enterprise's sensors. The Hathaway lands the first hits.
Real gunsSpoiler · tap to reveal
A Ferengi ship arrives for real, with the Enterprise's weapons stuck in exercise mode. Later, Data plays Kolrami again.
Why it still matters
After "Q Who," Starfleet wants to know whether its ships can fight. It sends Sirna Kolrami, a Zakdorn strategist and grandmaster of a game called Strategema, to run an exercise: the Enterprise against the Hathaway, an 80-year-old ship with no antimatter and a crew of about 40 under Riker. Kolrami doesn't like Riker, who challenges him to Strategema anyway, just to say he played a grandmaster.
The war game is fun, and Riker's scrappy crew (Worf, La Forge, Wesley) improvising with junk is the most likable the show had been all season. The heart of the episode is Data, though. Pulaski goads him into playing Kolrami, he loses, and he concludes he must be malfunctioning. Watching an android sulk, and Picard talk him out of it, is the best scene in the hour.
Roy Brocksmith plays Kolrami as a smug little emperor, and he's a big reason to watch. Keith DeCandido gave the episode 7 out of 10 on Tor.com and said it would have made a nice season finale.
How you beat a grandmaster
The Ferengi marauder catches the Enterprise with its phasers locked in simulation mode, and its commander, Bractor, demands the Hathaway. Picard and Riker fake its destruction: the Enterprise fires torpedoes at the Hathaway just as it uses its one stolen burst of warp to jump clear. Then Worf runs his sensor trick on the Ferengi, who see another Federation ship coming and leave.
Data's rematch is the better ending. He plays for a stalemate, passing up chances to advance, until Kolrami gets so frustrated that he quits. Data calls it a draw, and Pulaski keeps prodding until he admits he won. It's a neat answer to Picard's line: Data stopped trying to be perfect and played the opponent.
Behind the scenes
- David Kemper wrote it. He later became a co-executive producer on Farscape.
- Armin Shimerman plays Bractor, the second of the three Ferengi he would play. The third was Quark on Deep Space Nine.
- Glenn Morshower, later Secret Service agent Aaron Pierce on 24, plays Ensign Burke, who gets promoted to lieutenant by a fluffed line in Picard's dialogue.
- The Hathaway's effects shots use the Constellation-class starship model first seen in "The Battle."
- It's the first mention of the Borg since "Q Who," and the bosun's whistle from the original series makes a return.
- About 9.4 percent of American households watched the first broadcast, by Nielsen's count.
The thread
Starfleet games out a war it fears, and Data learns the difference between losing and failing.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Where they went next
DNA strand
Do Machines Dream?
Data's crisis is a human one dressed in machine terms. He assumes losing means something in him is broken, because a machine that works shouldn't lose. Picard's answer, that you can make no mistakes and still lose, is about people, and Data takes it in by changing how he plays instead of trying to repair himself.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S2
"Q Who" (1989)
If the talk of the Borg made you curious, this is the encounter that has Starfleet running drills.
Watch · Film
WarGames (1983)
Our pick for another story where a war game and the real thing get uncomfortably close, with a computer at the board.
Read · Novel
Ender's Game — Orson Scott Card
If the war game was your favorite part: a gifted kid at a military school built around mock battles.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S2
"The Measure of a Man" (1989)
More Data, and more people deciding what he is. It's from earlier the same season, and one of the best the show ever made.