Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 2 / Episode 18

Up the Long Ladder

An ancient SOS leads the Enterprise to a farming colony about to be fried by solar flares. The colonists bring their livestock aboard. Then it turns out there's a second colony, and it has a secret.

  • First aired May 22, 1989 · Syndication
  • Directed by Winrich Kolbe
  • Written by Melinda M. Snodgrass
  • Guest starring Barrie Ingham, Jon De Vries and Rosalyn Landor
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Up the Long Ladder"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Up the Long Ladder"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Up the Long Ladder" (Syndication, 1989). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. An old SOS

    A distress call from the Mariposa leads the Enterprise to Bringloid V, where solar flares threaten a rustic colony.

  2. Livestock aboard

    The Bringloidi come aboard. Odell discovers the fire-suppression system, and Riker discovers Brenna.

  3. Worf's secret

    Worf collapses on the bridge with a Klingon childhood illness. Pulaski treats him and keeps quiet about it.

  4. The other colonySpoiler · tap to reveal

    Half a light year away, the Mariposans are polite, advanced and all clones. Their cloning is failing, and they want the crew's DNA.

  5. MergeSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Riker destroys the copies made of him and Pulaski. The answer is to merge the two colonies, though neither side thinks much of the other.

Why it still matters

The Enterprise picks up a centuries-old distress call from the S.S. Mariposa, a colony ship from the early 22nd century. On Bringloid V, solar flares are about to make life impossible for the Bringloidi, some 200 colonists who chose a pre-industrial farming life. Their leader, Danilo Odell, and his hot-tempered daughter Brenna come aboard with everything they own, animals included, and the 24th century is not ready for them.

Fans know it as the one with the Space Irish, and that's the problem most critics have with it. The Bringloidi are broad Irish caricatures, and reviewers from Tor.com to Den of Geek have called the portrayal painfully stereotypical, even when they admit they laughed.

There's more going on under the accents. Melinda M. Snodgrass meant it as a story about immigration, and the second half turns into a real science fiction question about what a society owes its own future. The Worf and Pulaski subplot, about a Klingon childhood illness, is the part even its critics like.

Spoilers from here on. What the Mariposans are hiding, and the answer Picard and Pulaski come up with.

Send in the clones

The Mariposans, led by Prime Minister Wilson Granger, look like the sophisticated half of the family. Pulaski soon finds that every one of them is a clone. Their ship crashed, only five scientists survived, and without enough people for a viable gene pool they turned to cloning. Copies of copies have led to "replicative fading," and the colony is dying. They ask the crew for DNA, Riker refuses, and they take it anyway.

Riker finds clones of himself and Pulaski growing in the labs and destroys them. Pulaski points out that more clones would only delay the end. What the Mariposans need is new people, and the Enterprise is carrying about 200 of them. The two colonies, who think very little of each other, end up agreeing to merge.

Worf, meanwhile, thanks Pulaski for keeping his illness quiet by inviting her to a Klingon tea ceremony. He warns her the tea is deadly to humans. She takes an antidote and drinks it with him.

Behind the scenes

  • Snodgrass said the story was meant as a comment on immigration and her dislike of xenophobia: "what makes America vibrant is the fact we have all these cultures." Co-executive producer Maurice Hurley suggested making the colonists agrarian Irish.
  • The working title was "Send in the Clones." The final title comes from an Irish anti-Protestant rhyme.
  • A starship manifest on a background screen sends the HMS New Zealand on a diplomatic mission to Alderaan. The same list includes a U.S.S. Buckaroo Banzai and a Captain Gene Roddenberry. Nobody could read it on a 1989 TV, and for the Blu-ray remaster Alderaan was changed to Aldebaran.
  • Reviews are rough. Keith R.A. DeCandido's Tor.com rewatch gave it 4 out of 10 and called the Bringloidi "the worst Irish stereotypes." Jamahl Epsicokhan gave it 1.5 out of 4 and called it "a colossal mess of a show," and Rob Bricken named it his pick for the worst episode of the series.
  • Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club gave it a C, praising the Worf and Pulaski scenes and arguing that neither storyline was developed enough to fill an episode, so the two were grafted together. Ars Technica listed it among TNG's worst in 2014 but also praised the Worf subplot.
  • William Leisner's Starfleet Corps of Engineers story Out of the Cocoon goes back to Mariposa eleven years later and finds the two cultures have not blended smoothly.

The thread

Two halves of one lost ship, one too stuck in the past and one with no future of its own.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Orphan BlackGraeme Manson and John Fawcett · TV series · 2013–2017 · identical clones, and the people who made them

Left its mark on

Out of the CocoonWilliam Leisner · Starfleet Corps of Engineers · Mariposa eleven years on

DNA strand

Technology Outpaces Ethics

The Mariposans solved survival with a lab and never asked what happens when copies of copies start to fade. By the time the Enterprise arrives, they're prepared to take what they need from strangers without asking. The episode's fix is to make them face the messy, human option they skipped.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:Orphan BlackExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · TV series

Orphan Black

If the cloning half of the episode was the part you wanted more of, this gives you five seasons of it, with Tatiana Maslany as Sarah Manning, one of several identical clones.

Watch · TNG S2

"The Icarus Factor"

Four weeks earlier, Worf's crewmates help him with another Klingon rite he can't easily mark aboard a human ship.

Read · Star Trek fiction

Out of the Cocoon — William Leisner

For anyone wondering how that merger went: Leisner checks in on Mariposa eleven years later.

Sources