
The story in 5 beats
- The inspector
Admiral Quinn, an old friend of Picard's, comes aboard with Remmick, who starts interrogating the crew on classified orders.
- One place, four candidates
Wesley takes the entrance tests against three others, among them a Benzite and a Vulcan. He helps the Benzite, Mordock, through a hard problem.
- A stolen shuttle
Jake, a teenager who failed the exam, takes a shuttlecraft and runs. It breaks down, and Picard has to talk him out of the atmosphere.
The psych testSpoiler · tap to reveal
An explosion, two men trapped, and only time to save one. Wesley chooses, and finds out what the test was really about.
Next yearSpoiler · tap to reveal
Mordock gets the place. Remmick finds nothing. Quinn offers Picard a promotion, and Picard has a confession for Wesley.
Why it still matters
Two stories run side by side. Down on Relva VII, Wesley competes with three other bright candidates for a single Academy place. On the ship, Admiral Quinn arrives with Lieutenant Commander Remmick of the Inspector General's office, who has orders to find out what's wrong with the Enterprise and won't say why. Remmick reads the crew's logs, quotes their past missions back at them and asks every question in the least friendly way possible.
It's a first-season episode with a lot of seeds in it. It's the first time we see a shuttlecraft, the first Vulcan with lines on the show, and the start of a storyline that pays off later in the season. Watch Remmick's interviews for the call-backs to earlier episodes, and watch Wil Wheaton, who gives one of his better performances of the season.
What the tests were really testing
The psych test is staged. Wesley hears an explosion and finds two men trapped in a burning room. One is too frightened to move, and Wesley can't talk him out, so he leaves him and drags the other to safety. The fire was fake. The examiners wanted to see whether he could make a hard choice in a situation like the one that killed his father, and saving either man would have passed. Mordock wins the place anyway, and Wesley is told to try again next year. Back on board, Picard admits he failed the entrance exam the first time too.
Remmick finishes his investigation having found nothing wrong, and even says he'd like to serve on the Enterprise one day. Then Quinn explains why he sent him. He suspects something unknown has gotten inside Starfleet, and he wants Picard close by, offering him a promotion to admiral and a post overseeing the Academy. Picard considers it and says no. The episode leaves the conspiracy hanging on purpose. It comes back in "Conspiracy," with Quinn and Remmick both returning.
Behind the scenes
- Sandy Fries wrote the script. Hannah Louise Shearer did an uncredited rewrite and left the conspiracy details open for the follow-up, "Conspiracy."
- Mike Vejar directed. It was his only TNG episode; he later directed for Deep Space Nine, Voyager and Enterprise.
- Only about a quarter of the shuttlecraft interior was built, and the set grew bit by bit in season two. Construction mistakes meant the full-size shuttle didn't match the miniature.
- T'Shanik is the series' first speaking Vulcan, which stood out because Gene Roddenberry's series bible had said there should be no Vulcan stories.
- Remmick's interrogation brings up "Where No One Has Gone Before," "The Battle," "Angel One" and "Justice."
- A cut scene had the crew throwing Wesley an early 16th birthday party.
- Robert Schenkkan, who plays Remmick, is a playwright. He went on to win the 1992 Pulitzer Prize for Drama for The Kentucky Cycle and a Tony for All the Way.
The thread
Tests that measure character rather than knowledge, and the institutions that set them.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Picked up later
DNA strand
The State Knows Best
Starfleet is usually the good guys, and this episode lets it feel a little sinister. An investigator with sealed orders reads everyone's private logs, and an exam reaches into a boy's worst memory to see how he reacts. Both are justified by the institution's needs, and neither person on the receiving end gets a say.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Novel
Ender's Game — Orson Scott Card
If Wesley's psych test made you uneasy, Card's battle school takes the idea of testing gifted children much further.
Watch · Film
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan
Opens with the Kobayashi Maru, Starfleet's most famous test of character, and another exam that's really about how you lose.