
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The film
The crew finish a romantic film. Lister cries. Rimmer scoffs that nobody gives up their dreams for a woman they'll never see again.
- The Enlightenment
Holly finds a holographic ship crewed by the Space Corps elite. Rimmer goes aboard and can feel and taste things again.
- Nirvanah
Rimmer falls for Commander Nirvanah Crane and asks to join. The crew is full, so he'll have to beat an officer in a test to take their place.
The mind patchSpoiler · tap to reveal
Kryten fits Rimmer with a patch to boost his IQ. It fails mid-test and he gives up, until his rival withdraws. He says goodbye to the crew.
Her placeSpoiler · tap to reveal
The officer who stepped aside was Nirvanah. Rimmer resigns his commission so she can have it back, and goes home.
Why it still matters
The episode opens with the crew finishing a romantic film. Lister is in tears. Rimmer sneers that no man would ever give up his dreams for a woman he'd never see again. Then Holly finds the Enlightenment, a ship made entirely of light and invisible to sensors, crewed by holograms of the Space Corps' finest. Rimmer is beamed aboard and gets everything he has ever wanted at once: rank, respect, a body that can feel things, and a ship's rule that crew must have sex twice a day.
It's the most romantic Red Dwarf ever got, and the most serious, sympathetic Rimmer since the first two series. Jane Horrocks plays Commander Nirvanah Crane, the officer who sees something in him, and the romance is played straight enough that you believe it. To stay, though, Rimmer has to win a place on a crew that's already full, and someone else's hologram gets switched off if he does.
Fans voted it the weakest of Series V, and one reviewer said it felt like a rejected Star Trek episode. That's fair as far as it goes, but it also gives Rimmer one of his best speeches, which is worth the whole half-hour.
The man who wouldn't give up his dreams
Rimmer's mind patch fails partway through the contest and he walks out, beaten. Then his rival withdraws, and the place is his. He says goodbye to Lister, the Cat and Kryten with a speech that starts out as the usual Rimmer, "I probably wouldn't have chosen you as friends," and turns into something close to real feeling.
Aboard the Enlightenment, he finds out that the rival who stepped aside was Nirvanah, who gave up her own place so he could be happy. So the cynic from the opening scene does the exact thing he said no man would do: he resigns, goes back to Red Dwarf and lets her be reinstated, giving up the dream for a woman he'll never see again.
Behind the scenes
- Series V started with a new director. Ed Bye left to direct Ruby Wax's show The Full Wax, and Juliet May, who had no sci-fi experience and later directed Miranda, took over. She left before the series was finished.
- It was the third Series V episode recorded, on 15 November 1991 at Shepperton Studios, but it was chosen to air first; the planned opener, "Back to Reality," was judged a better finale.
- More than twelve minutes had to be cut to fit the running time, making it the longest Red Dwarf episode recorded up to then. The lost scenes are on the DVDs and in the script book Son of Soup.
- Jane Horrocks based Nirvanah Crane on Joanna Lumley, with whom she later starred in Absolutely Fabulous.
- Craig Charles was put out that Rimmer got a girlfriend while Lister's big moment was eating a cigarette in front of Commander Binks (Don Warrington). It wasn't in the script, and Charles said it tasted horrible.
- Fans rated it the worst episode of Series V, with 0.2% in a Red Dwarf Smegazine poll.
The thread
Old romances it argues with, other holograms who want a real life and a love story.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Love Beyond Limits
Love across a barrier usually means two people kept apart. Here the barrier is Rimmer himself, his cynicism and his hunger for a rank he never earned. "Holoship" sets up his sneer in the first scene and then makes him live the story he sneered at, which is why a sitcom romance with a dead man made of light still works.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Black Mirror
"San Junipero" (2016)
Another romance that only exists because of a computer, and another person deciding what they'll give up to stay in it.
Watch · Red Dwarf IV
"Dimension Jump" (1991)
Rimmer meets the dashing, admired officer he could have been. A good pair with this one, where he briefly gets to live that life.
Watch · Film
Casablanca (1942)
The romance every other screen romance is measured against. Watch it and imagine Rimmer heckling.
Read · Scripts
Son of Soup (1995)
The Grant Naylor script book with the scenes cut from this episode, including more of the holoship crew.
Read · Novel
The Remains of the Day (1989)
A man who chose his job over love and has to live with it. If Rimmer's choice moved you, this is the road he didn't take.

