Red Dwarf / Series V / Episode 2

The Inquisitor

A Simulant who has lived to the end of time travels back through history, putting people on trial for wasting their lives. The Red Dwarf crew are next.

  • Aired Feb 27, 1992 · BBC2
  • Directed by Juliet May & Grant Naylor
  • Written by Rob Grant and Doug Naylor
  • Starring Chris Barrie, Craig Charles, Danny John-Jules and Robert Llewellyn
Still from Red Dwarf, "The Inquisitor"
Still from Red Dwarf, "The Inquisitor"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 3
Red Dwarf, "The Inquisitor" (BBC2, 1992). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The first erasure

    The episode opens with the Inquisitor at work on a man named Thomas Allman. Then he comes for Red Dwarf.

  2. Judge yourself

    Each crew member is put on trial by a copy of themselves and has to justify their existence, with their place in history at stake.

  3. DeletedSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Lister and Kryten fail. They're erased from history, their friends don't know who they are, and their replacements are already aboard.

  4. The gauntletSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Lister and Kryten get hold of the Inquisitor's time-bending gauntlet, with a little help from a future Kryten, and fight back.

  5. Self-judgementSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Kryten has secretly reprogrammed the gauntlet. When the Inquisitor tries to erase Lister, it erases him instead, and history snaps back.

Why it still matters

The Inquisitor is a self-repairing Simulant who survived until the end of time and found nothing there: no God, no afterlife. So he decided the only point of existence is to live a worthwhile life, and appointed himself the judge of who has. He travels through history, erasing the people who wasted their chance and replacing them with people who were never born and never got one.

That is a properly dark premise for a sitcom, and the episode knows it. The trick is in how the trials work. Each crew member is judged by a copy of themselves, so their fate depends on what they honestly think of their own lives. Some of them pass for reasons that are funny and slightly appalling, and some of them don't.

It's one of the most purely science-fiction episodes the show had made by then, with time travel, erased timelines and a villain who could have walked out of a summer action film. Grant and Naylor thought it could open Series V, then decided it was too heavy on the sci-fi to be the first thing new viewers saw.

Spoilers from here on. Who fails the test, and how the Inquisitor ends up judging himself.

Erased

Rimmer gets through because his standards for himself are so low that he meets them, and the Cat gets through because, by his own account, he has a great ass. Lister fails on his lack of motivation. Kryten fails because everything good he has done was done by his programming, so none of it counts. He also objects to the whole idea: he isn't human, neither is the Inquisitor, and it isn't their place to judge.

Once erased, Lister and Kryten are strangers on their own ship, sharing it with the people who were never conceived and now have their lives. The Inquisitor kills the replacements by mistake, and later Rimmer and the Cat, before Kryten freezes him. When the Inquisitor tries to wipe Lister out, the gauntlet Kryten had tampered with turns on its owner. He's erased, and the timeline puts everyone back where they belong.

Behind the scenes

  • It was the second Series V episode recorded, on 8 November 1991 at Shepperton Studios. New director Juliet May filmed "Demons & Angels" first because she was still working out how to do this script.
  • Grant and Naylor thought it would make a good series opener, but because it was so heavily science fiction they put the more accessible "Holoship" first.
  • Jack Docherty, credited as John Docherty, plays the Inquisitor. He was the third cast member of the sketch show Absolutely to guest on Red Dwarf, after Morwenna Banks and Gordon Kennedy.
  • Rimmer wears his old green Series III and IV costume so viewers can tell him apart from his alternate-timeline self, who wears the new red one.
  • The Thomas Allman sequence was originally written as Red Dwarf's first cold open, but it was placed after the opening titles.
  • In the 1992 Red Dwarf Smegazine readers' poll it came 20th of the 30 episodes made so far.

The thread

Earlier trials and erased lives, other killers who come back through time, and an old question about what makes a life worth living.

Came before

Shares DNA with

The End of EternityIsaac Asimov · novel · 1955 · people who edit history and delete lives from it

DNA strand

Time Loops & Timelines

Time travel stories usually ask what happens if you change one event. "The Inquisitor" asks what happens if you change one person, swapping them for someone who might have done better with the same life. Lister and Kryten get to walk around the result, which is the funniest and saddest part of the episode.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:The TerminatorIt's a Wonderful LifeExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Red Dwarf IV

"Justice" (1991)

The crew's first trial, by a machine that reads guilt instead of worth, and the first Simulant the show sent after them.

Watch · Film

It's a Wonderful Life (1946)

If the scenes of Lister on a ship where nobody knows him got to you, this is the classic version: a man shown the world without him in it.

Watch · Film

The Terminator (1984)

The big-budget cousin: a machine that crosses time to erase one person and simply will not stop.

Read · Novel

The End of Eternity (1955)

A secret organisation that rewrites history for humanity's own good, and an insider who starts to doubt who gets to decide.

Sources