
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The driver
Chris drives for a rideshare app and waits outside the London offices of Smithereen, picking up fares from the building.
- Wrong hostage
He takes a passenger at gunpoint. Jaden turns out to be an intern who has only just started, which is not what Chris had in mind.
- A field outside town
With police on his tail, Chris swerves to miss some kids on bikes and stalls in a field. Armed officers surround the car.
- Billy Bauer
Chris wants the founder, who is away on a silent retreat. Smithereen's staff learn more about Chris, faster, than the police can.
The callSpoiler · tap to reveal
Billy calls. Chris tells him why he's there, and makes one last request.
Why it still matters
There's no futuristic gadget in "Smithereens." Charlie Brooker wanted it that way, as a reminder that Black Mirror was never only science fiction. Everything in it exists: the rideshare app, the social network called Smithereen that everyone is glued to, the company that knows more about a hostage-taker than the police do. The episode is a standoff in a car in a field, and almost all of it plays out on phones.
It began with a ride Brooker took, when the driver pulled over without warning to get a bottle of water and left him unsure where they were. The other spark was grief, and what it's like to mourn someone whose life is still sitting there on a social media account. Both ideas run through Chris, a driver who has been planning something for weeks.
Andrew Scott plays him, and he is the reason the episode works. Critics who found the story thin still praised his "astonishing control and range," in The Telegraph's phrase, and he was nominated for an Emmy. Watch how much he lets you see, and when.
What Chris needed to say
Three years earlier, Chris's fiancée died when his car hit another driver's. The other man was drunk and got the blame. What nobody knew is that Chris had looked down at a Smithereen notification just before. He wanted the person who built the app to hear it. Billy listens and, to his credit, admits the thing was designed to be as addictive as possible. Chris makes it clear he means to kill himself, and Billy begs him to let him help.
Chris's last request is for someone else: Hayley, the woman from his grief group, who has been trying to guess her dead daughter's password. He asks Billy to give it to her. Then he tries to let Jaden go, Jaden grabs for the gun to stop him, and the snipers fire into the car. The episode cuts to people all over the world getting the news on their phones, glancing at it, and getting on with their day. Brooker deliberately never shows what was in the daughter's account; giving a reason for a suicide, he said, would be "extremely superficial and cheap."
Behind the scenes
- Billy Bauer was written as a Silicon Valley founder who sees himself as a "switched on, liberal, hippy kind of guy," not a cartoon villain. Brooker drew on a ten-day retreat taken by Twitter's Jack Dorsey.
- Topher Grace expected Billy to be more villainous and wanted him bald. He ended up with a man bun. His scenes were filmed in Spain.
- At Scott's request, most scenes were shot in story order, so he could reveal Chris slowly.
- Most of it was filmed in London and Kent, including Harrietsham, Maidstone and a field near Gravesend.
- Ryuichi Sakamoto composed the score, and the 19-track soundtrack album came out two days after the episode.
- James Hawes had directed "Hated in the Nation" for series three. Spot trending topics on screen that mention SaitoGemu from "Playtest" and TCKR from "San Junipero."
The thread
A strange taxi ride and a tech founder's retreat, the series' first hostage crisis, and other standoffs played out in public.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Technology Outpaces Ethics
Nobody here meant harm. Billy built something people would love, and it worked so well that a man looked down at it at the wrong moment. The episode's sharpest idea is that the company can find out everything about Chris in minutes, and still has no way to answer for him.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Dog Day Afternoon (1975)
If the standoff in the field held you, this is the classic version: a man with a gun, a reason nobody expects, and a crowd watching it all.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Hated in the Nation"
Same director, and another police procedural where social media is the real crime scene.
Read · Nonfiction
Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now: Jaron Lanier
Billy admits his app was built to be addictive. A Silicon Valley insider explains, in plain language, how that's done.


