
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Happy birthday, Rachel
Lonely, grieving Rachel gets an Ashley Too doll, and it becomes her best friend. Her sister Jack thinks it's creepy.
- The talent show
Rachel dances to Ashley's hit "On a Roll" at the school talent contest, fumbles the ending, and Jack hides the doll.
- Ashley's other life
The real Ashley wants to make darker music and stops taking her pills. Her aunt Catherine has other plans for her.
The limiterSpoiler · tap to reveal
Six months later, the doll wakes up glitching. Jack plugs it into their father's diagnostic software and removes a limiter. Ashley Too has a lot to say.
Road tripSpoiler · tap to reveal
Two sisters and a doll with opinions go on a rescue mission, then race across town to a concert nobody should be giving.
Why it still matters
This is the Black Mirror episode with a car chase and a pest-control disguise, and it knows it. Rachel is new in town, grieving her mother, and has no friends, so for her fifteenth birthday she gets Ashley Too, a chirpy robot doll of pop star Ashley O that talks to her like a friend. Her older sister Jack hates it. Meanwhile, the real Ashley is stuck inside a career run by her aunt and manager, Catherine, and the songs she wants to write aren't the ones that sell.
Miley Cyrus plays Ashley, and the casting is the whole point. Brooker and Annabel Jones thought she'd be perfect and didn't expect a yes; she turned out to be a fan and agreed within a couple of days. She said the script's picture of the music business, especially its "overt exploitation of artists," rang true. Critics were split on the episode and almost unanimous about her.
Brooker's starting points were an old sitcom idea about a punk band whose manager profits from their deaths, and the hologram tours of dead stars like Whitney Houston and Amy Winehouse, which he found "ghoulish." He said the target was fakery, not pop music itself. Ashley's hits are Nine Inch Nails songs rewritten to sound "insanely positive," with Trent Reznor's blessing, and they're catchier than they have any right to be.
Two Ashleys
Catherine has drugged Ashley into a coma and is using a machine to pull new songs out of her brainwaves. The doll, freed from its limiter, explains that it holds a copy of Ashley's entire mind, kept in check by the limiter. Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too sneak into Catherine's house, Jack posing as a pest controller. The doll tries to unplug Ashley's life support so the real Ashley can die, but the machine was what was keeping her under, and she wakes up.
Catherine is about to launch Ashley Eternal, a hologram replacement, in front of a live crowd. With police behind them, Jack drives straight through the venue's back entrance, and the real Ashley walks out on stage. Over the credits she plays a small club with Jack on bass, playing "Head Like a Hole," and two disappointed fans walk out. It's Black Mirror doing a kids' adventure, which some critics loved and others called corny. For once, the copy-of-a-person idea the show usually plays for horror ends in a rescue.
Behind the scenes
- An earlier version had Catherine revealed as not human at the end, either by pulling off her face or vanishing "in a puff of smoke." In the finished cut she just looks at the camera.
- Though it's set in America, it was shot in Cape Town, South Africa, for budget reasons, six days a week over five weeks in late 2018.
- On the day she filmed Ashley waking from the coma, Cyrus had lost her home in a California wildfire. She drew on it between takes.
- Two crew members puppeteered the Ashley Too doll, and some shots were done with green-screen sticks and the doll added later.
- Madison Davenport learned to play bass in a fortnight for the closing "Head Like a Hole." The scene was shot in a few hours on Cyrus's last day.
- "On a Roll" was released as a single and reached number 18 in New Zealand and 65 in the UK. Billboard ranked it 28th in its best songs of 2019.
- Easter eggs: Ashley is treated at St. Juniper's, the hospital from "Black Museum," and Catherine uses the Smithereen app.
The thread
A punk-band sitcom that never got made, the hologram tours that spooked Brooker, and the band whose songs got turned inside out.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Alternate Selves
There are three Ashleys: the star, the doll and the hologram, and only one of them is allowed to say what she thinks. The fun is that the copy turns out to be more honest than the product it was built to sell.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Be Right Back"
If the doll that knows too much got under your skin, this is the quiet, sad version: a copy of a person built from what they left behind online.
Watch · Film
Josie and the Pussycats (2001)
Another bright, silly, sharper-than-it-looks satire of the people who package pop stars.
Read · Novel
Klara and the Sun: Kazuo Ishiguro
An artificial friend bought for a lonely teenage girl, told from the friend's side. Gentler than Ashley Too, and it will stay with you longer.


