
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The inquiry
Parke gives evidence about the death of Jo Powers, a controversial journalist with no shortage of enemies online.
- Something in the brain
Powers's autopsy finds a tiny drone bee lodged in her brain. A rapper dies the same way, mid-MRI.
- #DeathTo
Blue finds the pattern: a "Game of Consequences" in which whoever is most tagged with #DeathTo each day is killed.
The real listSpoiler · tap to reveal
The killer's real target list is everyone who used the hashtag.
Somewhere hotSpoiler · tap to reveal
Blue is believed dead. Then she texts Parke from abroad, closing in on the man responsible.
Why it still matters
At 89 minutes this is a full feature-length police thriller, built in the style of Scandinavian crime dramas like The Killing. Kelly Macdonald plays DCI Karin Parke, dry and unimpressed, and Faye Marsay is Blue Coulson, the trainee who actually understands the internet. The story is told in flashback from a public inquiry, which Brooker added to get through the setup quickly.
The ideas pile up nicely. Real bees have died out, and the government has replaced them with tiny autonomous drones. Online, people tag their hate figures of the day with #DeathTo. Brooker wrote it from experience: in 2004 a column of his about George W. Bush brought a flood of hate mail and threats, and he described being on the end of a pile-on as "an ominous ion cloud hanging over you." Watch how casually the people in the episode join in, and how sure each of them is that one post doesn't count.
Everyone who joined in
The killer is Garrett Scholes, who worked at Granular, the company that makes the drone bees. The government's funding came with a condition that the bees double as mass surveillance, and Scholes hacked his way into it. The hashtag game was bait. His hard drive turns out to be a trojan horse holding the phone IDs of everyone who used #DeathTo. When the police try to shut the network down, it fails, and the bees kill 387,036 people, including Nick Shelton, who had tweeted the hashtag himself to provoke Scholes.
At the inquiry Parke says Blue is believed to have taken her own life. The last scene shows Blue alive in a hot country, texting Parke that she has tracked Scholes down. An earlier cut showed Blue slipping a knife into her bag, which was dropped. The ending punishes a crowd for something each member thought was weightless, and leaves you to decide what to make of Scholes. The Verge felt the episode never settles what it's critiquing.
Behind the scenes
- Brooker's first idea was people voting for someone to be killed by a robot. The same idea was later used for series four's "Metalhead."
- He found it hard to write, because his police writing until then had mostly been the spoof A Touch of Cloth. The inquiry framing was his shortcut through the exposition.
- Scholes was inspired by Ted Kaczynski and Anders Behring Breivik. Jo Powers was read as a version of the columnist Katie Hopkins.
- Brooker drew on Jon Ronson's So You've Been Publicly Shamed, and on the hate mail sent to the comedian Stewart Lee.
- It was filmed in London at 32 locations over 23 days. The final scene was shot in Gran Canaria because there wasn't time to film in the tropics.
- The score is by Martin Phipps. The closing song is by Alev Lenz.
- At 89 minutes it's one of the longest Black Mirror episodes.
The thread
Nordic crime drama, a book about online shaming, and Brooker's own inbox in 2004.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Grew from the same seed
DNA strand
Technology Outpaces Ethics
The bees are a sensible fix for a real problem, and the hashtag is just people letting off steam. Things go wrong when someone who takes the words literally connects the two. Nobody set out to build a murder machine; two harmless systems were built with a door left open between them.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · TV series
The Killing
The Danish crime drama the episode was modelled on. If you liked Parke's slow, unglamorous police work, this is the full-length version.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Nosedive"
The same season's lighter take on everyone rating everyone else all day, in pastel instead of grey and just as pointed.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Shut Up and Dance"
Anonymous people online deciding who deserves to suffer, told at street level with a single frightened teenager.
Read · Book
So You've Been Publicly Shamed by Jon Ronson
One of the books Brooker drew on. Real people, real pile-ons, and what happened to them afterward.
