
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The mountain road
After a party, Rob drives drunk and hits a cyclist. Mia helps him get rid of the body in a lake.
- Fifteen years later
Mia is an architect with a husband and a young son. Then Rob turns up at her hotel, sober now, and wanting to make amends.
- An accident outside
Across town, a self-driving pizza truck knocks down a pedestrian. Shazia, an insurance investigator, starts collecting witnesses' memories.
The RecallerSpoiler · tap to reveal
One witness leads to another, and the trail ends at Mia's door. Shazia only wants to see the accident. The machine shows her more than that.
No witnessesSpoiler · tap to reveal
Mia keeps killing to stay hidden, and never stops to ask who else might have been watching.
Why it still matters
Back in series one, "The Entire History of You" gave people an implant that let them replay their own memories. "Crocodile" grew out of the obvious follow-up, which is what happens once your memories stop being private. Annabel Jones said they built it as a cat-and-mouse drama about how far someone with a secret will go to keep it, and the writers had Nordic noir in mind. It plays like a crime thriller with one science-fiction gadget in it.
The gadget is the Recaller, a boxy little device that projects a witness's memories onto a screen. Brooker pictured it as an arcade Space Invaders cabinet; production designer Joel Collins compared it to a slide viewer. Shazia, the investigator who carries it, is patient and chatty and very good at her job, and watching her work is half the fun. Smells and songs jog the memory, so she brings along a bottle of beer and plays music, and the half-remembered scenes sharpen on screen.
It's also gorgeous, shot across a snowbound Iceland by John Hillcoat, who called it a "pitch-black comedy of errors." Architectural Digest rated its look the best of series four. Critics split hard on where the story goes, though nearly all of them agreed on Andrea Riseborough.
The witness nobody counted
Rob's plan was to send an anonymous letter to the dead cyclist's widow. Mia couldn't risk it, and she killed him in her hotel room. That's what was in her head when Shazia arrived. Once the Recaller shows Shazia both deaths, Mia knocks her out, ties her up, and uses the machine on her in turn. It tells her Shazia's husband knows where she went. So Mia kills Shazia, then drives to the couple's home and kills her husband. On her way out she sees their baby, and she kills the baby too, so there will be no one left who saw her.
Then comes the joke: the baby was born blind and could never have been a witness. The police find the family's guinea pig, which watched everything, put the Recaller on it, and turn up at the end of Mia's son's school production of Bugsy Malone. The guinea pig was meant as dark comedy in the style of Fargo. Plenty of critics didn't laugh: they called the blind baby needlessly cruel and the whole thing over the top. The structure works anyway. Each murder makes the next one necessary, and once memories can be played back, there's always one more witness.
Behind the scenes
- The title comes from an earlier draft. Brooker compared its story to a virtual-reality jungle river ride where an unlucky player meets a crocodile right away. The script changed a lot; the name stayed.
- The first draft had a male lead and was set in Scotland. Riseborough auditioned for the investigator and asked whether the lead could be a woman. Brooker said a panicking male murderer was practically a trope, so the switch felt refreshing.
- Netflix suggested Iceland as a "stunning backdrop," and Brooker's team agreed straight away. Scenes were shot at Harpa, Reykjavík's concert hall.
- Filming hit Iceland's heaviest snowfall in forty years. To cover the continuity problem, a line was added about the snow starting, and Brooker said nobody noticed.
- Riseborough hurt her ribs at her first rehearsal. Kiran Sonia Sawar found Shazia's death so hard to film that she didn't watch it in the finished episode.
- The other gadgets, including the pizza truck, were redesigned to share the Recaller's boxy look. A month after release, Toyota announced a self-driving pizza vehicle with Pizza Hut, and commentators compared it to this one.
The thread
The series one episode it grew out of, the crime stories it borrows a tone from, and the other films about playing back what someone saw.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Technology Outpaces Ethics
The Recaller exists to settle insurance claims, which is what makes it frightening. Someone built a handy tool for working out a pizza company's liability, and it happens to turn every witness into a risk.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Fargo (1996)
If the guinea pig made you laugh despite yourself, this is where that tone comes from: snow, a crime that keeps getting worse, and a kind cop who notices everything.
Watch · Black Mirror
"The Entire History of You"
The episode this one grew out of. Same idea, memories you can replay, aimed at a marriage instead of a murder.
Read · Novel
The Talented Mr. Ripley: Patricia Highsmith
Another ordinary-seeming person who keeps covering one crime with the next, written so you half want them to get away with it.


