The Twilight Zone / Season 3 / Episode 31

The Trade-Ins

In the future you can trade an old body for a young one, at $5,000 a body. John and Marie Holt, old and long married, have $5,000.

  • First aired Apr 20, 1962 · CBS
  • Directed by Elliot Silverstein
  • Written by Rod Serling
  • Starring Joseph Schildkraut and Alma Platt
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Trade-Ins"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Trade-Ins"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
The Twilight Zone, "The Trade-Ins" (CBS, 1962). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The showroom

    John and Marie Holt tour a clinic showroom, where young bodies stand on display and old customers can trade in.

  2. Enough for one

    Each body costs $5,000. They have $5,000 between them, and the company won't give credit.

  3. The poker game

    John tries to win the difference at cards and loses most of his stake. The man who beat him, Farraday, asks why he's playing.

  4. Young JohnSpoiler · tap to reveal

    With Marie urging him on, John goes through with it alone. He wakes up young, healthy and full of plans.

  5. The return clauseSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Marie can't hide how she feels. John makes a choice.

Why it still matters

Serling's future-shock stories usually look at what technology does to society. This one looks at what it does to a marriage. The clinic has a showroom full of young bodies, a friendly salesman and a one-week return policy. John Holt is old and in pain. His wife Marie is old too, and the money they've saved covers exactly one of them.

Nobody in it is a villain. The salesman, Mr. Vance, is kind, and the episode never asks you to root against anyone. The whole half hour rests on Joseph Schildkraut and Alma Platt, and the A.V. Club's Emily St. James, who gave it an A, called it a beautiful and heartfelt episode anchored by two terrific performances. Watch Schildkraut's face in the quiet scenes; the notes below explain what he was going through off camera that week.

Spoilers from here on. The ending is a choice, and a quiet one.

What the money couldn't buy

Farraday holds the winning hand, hears John's story, and lets him leave with his $5,000 anyway. John's pain has become unbearable, and at Marie's insistence he takes the young body, telling himself he'll earn the money for hers. When she sees him, she breaks down. She can't feel married to a man so much younger than she is, and he realizes she would grow old and die long before him.

So John uses the return clause and goes back into his old, aching body, choosing the pain over the distance between them. They walk out together toward whatever time they have left. Serling closes with Kahlil Gibran's The Prophet on love, which, as the Twilight Zone Vortex points out, he slightly misquotes. It's one of the gentlest endings the show ever did, and the twist is simply that he gives the miracle back.

Behind the scenes

  • Joseph Schildkraut's wife, Marie McKay, died during production. He came back to the set two days later and finished the episode before allowing himself to grieve.
  • Schildkraut had already appeared in the show earlier that season, in "Deaths-Head Revisited."
  • Edson Stroll, who plays the young John, recalled in Martin Grams Jr.'s book The Twilight Zone: Unlocking the Door to a Television Classic that the script was still being worked on during filming, and that Silverstein wanted to shut off the studio sound and fire a gun in the background to get a real reaction. Stroll only said the director wanted to, so whether he did is unclear.
  • Elliot Silverstein directed four episodes of the series, including "The Obsolete Man" and "The Passersby."
  • Several of the faces are familiar from elsewhere in the series: Stroll was also in "Eye of the Beholder," Theodore Marcuse (Farraday) in "To Serve Man" and Noah Keen (Mr. Vance) in "The Arrival."
  • It was filmed at MGM with stock music, and William Tuttle did the aging makeup.

The thread

Long life, young bodies and the person you'd be leaving behind.

Came before

The ProphetKahlil Gibran · book · 1923 · Serling quotes it in the closing narration

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Love Beyond Limits

Here the limit is age, and the technology offers to erase it for one of them. The episode measures love by what John is willing to give up, and the grand gesture turns out to be going back to being old.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"San Junipero""Long Live Walter Jameson"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Black Mirror

"San Junipero" (2016)

Another story about getting young again late in life, and about what it means to choose that with someone else.

Watch · Film

Seconds (1966)

The darker cousin of this episode: a secretive company offers a tired middle-aged man a new face and a new life.

Read · Book

The Prophet — Kahlil Gibran

If Serling's closing words stayed with you, the chapter on love is only a few pages long, and the line he borrowed reads better in full.

Watch · Twilight Zone S3

"Kick the Can" (1962)

The same season, a retirement home and the same longing to be young again, from a very different angle.

Sources