The Twilight Zone / Season 3 / Episode 11

Still Valley

Virginia, 1863. A Confederate scout walks down into a village full of Union soldiers and finds every one of them standing still as a statue. An old man in a doorway says he did it.

  • First aired Nov 24, 1961 · CBS
  • Directed by James Sheldon
  • Teleplay by Rod Serling, from the story by Manly Wade Wellman
  • Starring Gary Merrill and Vaughn Taylor
Still from The Twilight Zone, "Still Valley"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "Still Valley"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
The Twilight Zone, "Still Valley" (CBS, 1961). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Silence

    Paradine and another scout watch Union troops move into a town below. Then the sound stops. Paradine goes down alone to see why.

  2. Statues

    Every Union soldier in the street is frozen in place. The only person moving is an old man named Teague.

  3. A demonstration

    To prove it's his doing, Teague freezes Paradine too. He has a book of spells, he's dying, and he wants Paradine to have it.

  4. The fine printSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Paradine's lieutenant wants the book used. Then Paradine reads what the magic requires: praising the Devil and renouncing God.

  5. Hallowed groundSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Paradine throws the book into the campfire. His unit marches on toward a town called Gettysburg.

Why it still matters

This is the Twilight Zone's Civil War temptation story, and the image at its center is a great one: a company of Union troops frozen in place in a little Virginia town. Sergeant Joseph Paradine, played by Gary Merrill as a grizzled man of real honor, walks among them trying to work out whether he's gone mad.

The man responsible is Teague, an old self-described witch-man, and Vaughn Taylor plays him calmly enough that his offer almost sounds reasonable. The South is losing. Teague has a book that could stop the whole Union army. All Paradine has to do is use it.

Fair warning: it's talky, and The A.V. Club found it mostly setup with a few minutes of real story at the end. Still, it asks a sharp question for a show airing during the war's centennial: what a man would give up to win, and what the win would be worth afterward.

Spoilers from here on. Paradine's choice, and where it sends him.

Victory, at a price

Back with his unit, Paradine reports to his lieutenant, who urges him to use the book. A sergeant who can freeze soldiers could stop the whole Union army. Paradine starts to work the spell, and then reads what it asks of him. To use it, he has to call on the Devil and turn his back on God.

He throws the book into the fire. If the Confederacy has to die, he says, he wants it buried in hallowed ground. Serling's closing narration sends the unit on to Gettysburg, a battle fought, he notes, without the help of the Devil. The audience in 1961 knew how that one ended, which is the quiet sting of the last line.

Behind the scenes

  • Serling adapted it from Manly Wade Wellman's short story "The Valley Was Still," first published in Weird Tales in August 1939.
  • Wellman's ending is far bloodier. Paradine nearly signs the book in his own blood, then kills Teague with his saber, and the armies fight a big battle in the valley, after which nobody believes his story.
  • In the story, Paradine weighs the bargain by thinking of Faust, Gilles de Retz and Macbeth, and asks himself what a victory won through evil would become in the end.
  • Season three had two Civil War episodes, "The Passersby" and this one, airing a few weeks apart during the war's centennial.
  • Wellman was born in 1903 in Portuguese West Africa, now Angola, and came to America at six. He's best remembered for his John the Balladeer stories.

The thread

An old pulp story about the Devil's bargain, retold by Serling as a Civil War parable.

Came before

"The Valley Was Still" — Manly Wade WellmanWeird Tales · short story · 1939 · the source
The Faust legendfolklore · the bargain Paradine has in mind in Wellman's story

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Be Careful What You Wish For

Paradine is offered exactly what he wants most, a way to win, and the catch is spiritual. The magic plainly works, so what he has to decide is whether a victory bought that way would still be his cause.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Man in the Bottle""A Nice Place to Visit"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Read · Short story

"The Valley Was Still" — Manly Wade Wellman

The original goes further and gets much darker, and reading it shows how much Serling softened Paradine's choice for television.

Watch · Twilight Zone S3

"The Passersby"

The same season, the same war, and a much stranger road: a Confederate sergeant and a widow watch a line of travelers pass her burned-out house.

Watch · Twilight Zone S2

"Back There"

If you liked watching a man hold history in his hands and wonder whether to change it, this one sends its hero to the night of Lincoln's assassination.

Sources