The Twilight Zone / Season 5 / Episode 21

Spur of the Moment

Anne Henderson is eighteen, engaged and out riding when a woman in black on a black horse screams her name and chases her home.

  • First aired Feb 21, 1964 · CBS
  • Directed by Elliot Silverstein
  • Written by Richard Matheson
  • Starring Diana Hyland
Still from The Twilight Zone, "Spur of the Moment"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "Spur of the Moment"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 2
The Twilight Zone, "Spur of the Moment" (CBS, 1964). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The woman on the ridge

    June 13, 1939. Anne Henderson, out riding, is chased toward home by a woman in black who screams her name.

  2. The engagement

    Her parents and her fiancé Robert, a stiff investment banker, calm her down and talk about the wedding.

  3. David

    Her former fiancé David bursts in and begs her to call it off. Her father sees him out at gunpoint.

  4. Twenty-five years laterSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The estate is close to ruin, and Anne, now middle-aged, is drinking. She knows who the woman on the ridge was.

  5. Come backSpoiler · tap to reveal

    She rides out again to warn her younger self. She can't catch her, and the girl can't hear.

Why it still matters

It's June 1939, and Anne Henderson has everything: horses, an estate and a fiancé, Robert, a sensible investment banker her parents adore. Then, on a ridge above the fields, a woman in black on a black horse screams her name and gallops after her. Anne makes it home shaken, and soon her former fiancé David forces his way into the house and begs her not to marry Robert.

Underneath the gallop, it's a romance about a choice, played as a ghost story. Anne has two men to choose between and a stranger on a ridge who seems to have a stake in which one she picks.

Matheson wasn't happy with the result: he felt Elliot Silverstein's close-ups in the opening ride showed too much, too early. Watch the first few minutes closely and see whether you agree, though Paste's ranking argues that guessing early is part of the point.

Spoilers from here on. Matheson thought the opening gave it away. Here's the rest.

Who the woman in black is

The rider is Anne herself, twenty-five years older. On the night of the engagement party she didn't marry Robert. She ran off with David, on the spur of the moment, and David turned out to be a disaster who ran the family's fortune into the ground. The older Anne is bitter, drinking and losing the house, and somehow she has found the ridge where she can see the girl she used to be.

So she rides after her, shouting "Anne, wait, come back!" The younger Anne only hears a screaming stranger and runs, and that scream is what sends her home on the day she makes the choice. Serling's closing narration files the warning away, stamped "Not Accepted." The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen noted the show's rule that people can travel in time but almost never change anything for the better, and Matheson goes a step further by making the attempt part of what happens.

Behind the scenes

  • According to The Twilight Zone Companion, Matheson cited J. B. Priestley's writing about time as an inspiration, and was disappointed that the opening close-ups gave the twist away.
  • Diana Hyland plays Anne at eighteen and at forty-three, under heavy makeup for the older Anne.
  • Hyland later played John Travolta's mother in The Boy in the Plastic Bubble, and the two were together until her death in 1977.
  • Marsha Hunt, who plays Anne's mother, was married to screenwriter Robert Presnell Jr., who wrote the Season 1 episode "The Chaser."

The thread

Warnings from your own future, from Priestley's stage to the multiverse.

Came before

Time and the ConwaysJ. B. Priestley · play · 1937 · an earlier family drama that jumps ahead years to show what became of them

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Time Loops & Timelines

Matheson's question is what changing the past would look like from the outside, and his answer is a stranger on a hill, screaming. The warning and the mistake turn out to be the same afternoon.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Judgment Night""Back There""Walking Distance"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Twilight Zone S1

"Walking Distance" (1959)

A tired man meets his younger self on a summer evening and finds out what he can and can't tell him. Serling's gentlest take on the same wish.

Watch · Twilight Zone S2

"Back There" (1961)

If you liked the idea that the past pushes back, this one sends a man to Washington on a famous night with a warning nobody wants.

Watch · Film

Sliding Doors (1998)

One woman, one small moment and two lives running side by side. The same question as Anne's, asked with both answers on screen.

Read · Play

Time and the Conways — J. B. Priestley

Priestley's best-known time play: a hopeful family party, then a jump forward to see how it all turned out.

Sources