The Twilight Zone / Season 5 / Episode 32

Mr. Garrity and the Graves

A peddler rides into a Western town and offers to raise its dead from Boot Hill. The trouble is that the town remembers exactly how those people died.

  • First aired May 8, 1964 · CBS
  • Directed by Ted Post
  • Teleplay by Rod Serling, from a story by Mike Korologos
  • Starring John Dehner and J. Pat O'Malley
Still from The Twilight Zone, "Mr. Garrity and the Graves"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "Mr. Garrity and the Graves"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 2
The Twilight Zone, "Mr. Garrity and the Graves" (CBS, 1964). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. A stranger in Happiness

    Jared Garrity arrives in the saloon and announces that he can raise the dead from Boot Hill.

  2. The dog

    A traveler's wagon runs down a dog in the street. Garrity brings it back to life, and the town stops laughing.

  3. Old grudges

    Over drinks, Garrity mentions who's buried up there and who put them there. The saloon gets very quiet.

  4. Paying to keep them buriedSpoiler · tap to reveal

    One by one, the townsfolk pay Garrity to leave their loved ones exactly where they are.

  5. Boot Hill, after darkSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Garrity and his partner ride off laughing that nobody can raise the dead. Up on the hill, the graves open anyway.

Why it still matters

This is a Western played as a tall tale, and it started as one. In 1873, so the story goes, a stranger turned up in the silver-mining town of Alta, Utah, and offered to bring back the dead. Nobody has documented it, but a sportswriter named Mike Korologos wrote it up for The Salt Lake Tribune in 1963, the Alta ski area reprinted the piece, and Rod Serling read it on a visit to the resort. He moved the story to a town called Happiness, Arizona, around 1890.

The comedy is all in the townsfolk. Everyone says they miss their departed, right up until Garrity politely reminds them how those departed got to Boot Hill. Nearly all of them were murdered, and plenty of the murderers are standing in the saloon. John Dehner plays Garrity as a gentleman salesman with a soft voice and excellent timing, and he lets the town talk itself out of grief one nervous customer at a time.

Spoilers from here on. The con works perfectly, and that's only half the joke.

Who was conning whom

Garrity is a fraud. His assistant Ace drove the wagon and played the first "resurrected" man, and the dog had simply learned to play dead. Once the town has paid him to leave every grave alone, the two of them ride off with the money, joking that the dead can't really come back.

Then the dead come back after all. A revived man looks forward to getting back to his drinking, a revived outlaw has business with the sheriff, and Zelda Gooberman has plans for her husband's arm. Garrity never knows. Serling's closing narration calls him a make-believe con man and a sad misjudger of his own talents: a man who had the real gift and sold it as a trick.

Behind the scenes

  • Korologos had read about the Alta stranger in the American Guide Series years earlier. In the legend, the townsfolk raised $2,500 to make the man leave without trying.
  • Korologos told an interviewer that Serling offered him $500 for the story, which he was thrilled to get. It's his only Twilight Zone credit.
  • The working title was "Mr. Graniety and the Graves."
  • Many scenes were shot at night, and Dehner later recalled trouble keeping the light generators running.
  • Dehner was a Twilight Zone regular of sorts: in Season 1 he played Captain Allenby, the supply-ship captain in "The Lonely."
  • The script, Script 152 in the Rod Serling Archives at Ithaca College, was published in volume 6 of As Timeless as Infinity, Tony Albarella's collection of Serling's Twilight Zone scripts.

The thread

A frontier tall tale about the dead coming home, and the long tradition of being careful what you ask the grave for.

Came before

The Alta resurrection legendAlta, Utah · local legend · 1873 · a robed stranger, a mining town and $2,500 to go away

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Be Careful What You Wish For

Everyone in Happiness wishes their dead were back, until someone offers. The episode is really about how fast grief turns into a business arrangement once the wish might come true, and Serling plays it for laughs.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Monkey's Paw"Pet SemataryExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Read · Short story

"The Monkey's Paw" — W. W. Jacobs

The same bargain with no jokes at all. If Happiness made you smile, this one won't.

Watch · Twilight Zone S1

"The Lonely"

More John Dehner, this time as a quiet captain with a hard job to do. A good chance to see his range.

Read · Novel

Pet Sematary — Stephen King

What happens when somebody actually brings the dead back, with King taking the idea all the way down.

Sources