
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Space Cruiser E-89
Ross, Mason and Carter survey a planet for colonization. The scanner shows something metal on the ground.
- The wreck
They land beside a crashed ship identical to theirs. Inside are three dead men in their uniforms, with their faces.
- Orders
Ross decides they've seen their own future and grounds the crew. When Mason and Carter object, he pulls rank.
Home againSpoiler · tap to reveal
Mason walks into his house and finds his wife and daughter, both of whom died years ago. Carter has his own visitor.
One more landingSpoiler · tap to reveal
Ross blames telepathic aliens, lifts off, then insists on going back down. The wreck is still waiting.
Why it still matters
Richard Matheson took one of the oldest sea stories there is, the Flying Dutchman, and moved it to a space cruiser. Captain Ross and lieutenants Mason and Carter are scouting a planet for colonists when the scanner picks up a wreck. It looks exactly like their ship. Inside are three bodies, and they're wearing the crew's faces.
What follows is mostly an argument. Ross, who goes by the book, builds one theory after another to explain what they saw. His two officers start to feel pulled toward something else. Jack Klugman plays Ross as a man who would rather be wrong about the universe than wrong about himself, and the A.V. Club's Emily St. James called his captain "a bull of a man."
It's also one of the hour-long fourth season's best uses of the extra time. The first half is a puzzle, and the second half slows down and lets each man's life back home into the story. Watch for the ship itself: the hovering cruiser is the C-57D model left over from MGM's Forbidden Planet.
Who's holding them there
The crew died in the crash. The bodies in the wreck are theirs, and the visions are real: Mason's wife and daughter and Carter's loved one are waiting for them on the other side. Mason and Carter come to accept it. Ross won't. He decides the dead family members are illusions planted by telepathic natives who want to keep Earth off their planet, and he's sure that lifting off will break the spell.
So they land again, find the wreck again and go through the same hours again, while Ross keeps giving orders. St. James saw his refusal as the heart of the episode, since he has no one waiting for him. Matheson turns the repetition on the viewer too: by the second landing we're braced for a third, which gives us a taste of the loop Ross won't let go of.
Behind the scenes
- Matheson's story first ran in Fantastic Story Magazine in March 1953, and was collected in Shock! in 1961. In the story the three men decide together to stay put. Making Ross the one who forces it, and adding the afterlife visits, were new for television.
- The cruiser model and the crew uniforms were borrowed from Forbidden Planet. The scanner screen and the dusty, fiery launch and landing were an expensive effect producer Herbert Hirschman wanted, built by MGM's effects department with miniatures and painted backdrops.
- The music is stock: Jerry Goldsmith's score from "Back There" and Bernard Herrmann's from "Walking Distance."
- Because the season was longer, Robert Pittack shot it, alternating episodes with the show's regular cameraman, George T. Clemens.
- The road to Carter's house is the same one used in "Valley of the Shadow," three weeks earlier.
- It was the third of Klugman's four Twilight Zone leads, a record he shares with Burgess Meredith. In a 1998 Television Academy interview he said he didn't care for this one.
The thread
Ghost ships, unfinished business, and one man who won't sign off.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
The Cruel Twist
Most viewers guess the twist early, and Matheson seems fine with that. The cruelty lies in who refuses to accept it. The truth is offered to all three men, and the one in charge keeps saying no, so all of them stay.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Carnival of Souls (1962)
Made the year before on a tiny budget, it has the same feeling of someone being called somewhere and refusing to look.
Watch · Twilight Zone S2
"The Odyssey of Flight 33"
Another crew lost somewhere it shouldn't be, trying to fly its way home, though this time the problem is when.
Watch · Film
Forbidden Planet (1956)
Where the ship and the uniforms came from, and a much bigger story about what a far planet does to the people who land on it.
Read · Story collection
Shock! by Richard Matheson
The 1961 collection that holds the original "Death Ship." Compare how the crew decides, and how much quieter the ending is.
