
The story in 5 beats
- Keep out
A buoy warns the Enterprise away from the Melkotians, and every crew member hears the warning in their own language. Kirk has orders to make contact and goes anyway.
- Tombstone, 1881
The landing party is sentenced to death and lands in a fragment of the Old West. Their phasers are now six-shooters, and the Enterprise doesn't answer.
- Wrong side of history
The townspeople think Kirk is Ike Clanton and his crew are the Clantons' friends. Everyone knows how that afternoon ends for the Clantons.
ChekovSpoiler · tap to reveal
Chekov, cast as Billy Claiborne, catches the eye of a local woman named Sylvia. A jealous Morgan Earp shoots him dead.
The corralSpoiler · tap to reveal
Spock's tranquilizer grenade fails. Suddenly the landing party is standing at the corral, with the Earps and Doc Holliday walking toward them.
Why it still matters
Season three's budget cuts gave the original series some of its weakest hours, and here, for once, one of its most striking. There wasn't money for a proper Western street, so Tombstone is a set of floating doorways and false fronts under a red sky, a town built out of half-remembered movie scenery. It looks like a dream, which suits the story, and SlashFilm compares the effect to the bare stage of Lars von Trier's Dogville.
Inside that dream is a smart premise. The aliens borrow their punishment from Kirk's own history: a famous killing that Earth has told and retold until it's practically folklore. The landing party knows exactly how the story ends, and they spend the hour trying to rewrite it.
It has done well with critics: The A.V. Club listed it among the original series' ten "must see" episodes in 2012, and The Hollywood Reporter ranked it 20th of the original series in 2016. Walter Koenig named it the episode he enjoyed making most.
The bullets aren't real
After the grenade fails, Spock concludes that this world doesn't obey the laws of reality. It was drawn from Kirk's own memory, and the bullets can only hurt them if they believe they will. Kirk has Spock use a mind-meld to give the landing party total certainty. When the Earps and Holliday open fire, the bullets pass straight through.
Kirk then knocks Wyatt Earp down and has him at his mercy, and throws the gun away. They're back on the bridge, Chekov alive after all (his mind, as it turns out, was on Sylvia). The Melkotians, curious about a man who wouldn't kill when he had every reason to, invite the Enterprise in.
Behind the scenes
- "Lee Cronin" was Gene L. Coon, the show's former producer. Reactor's rewatch notes that all his third-season scripts went out under that name.
- The working title was "The Last Gunfight", which James Blish kept for his prose adaptation in Star Trek 3.
- The stylized town was a budget decision: there wasn't money for a full Western set. SlashFilm puts the third season's budget at $175,000 an episode, down from $185,000 in season two.
- Walter Koenig called it the episode he most enjoyed doing, and said the forced "abstract manner" "gave it some class and some style."
- It was DeForest Kelley's third time in the O.K. Corral story. He had played Ike Clanton on You Are There and Morgan Earp in the 1957 film Gunfight at the O.K. Corral.
- It was the last episode to air in the show's 10 p.m. Friday slot on NBC, and it went out the day before the 87th anniversary of the real gunfight.
The thread
A real shootout, a Hollywood version DeForest Kelley had already been in, and a dream Western that looks like nothing else on the show.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Is Any of This Real?
The town is a stage set, the guns are props and the danger is entirely real until someone decides it isn't. That question becomes the solution, since survival depends on believing, completely, that none of it is happening.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek
"Shore Leave"
Another planet that makes the crew's own thoughts real, played this time for fun before it turns dangerous.
Watch · The Twilight Zone
"Showdown with Rance McGrew"
If you liked the Old West turning up where it shouldn't, this is the comic version: a TV cowboy face to face with the real thing.
Watch · Film
Gunfight at the O.K. Corral (1957)
The Hollywood version of the same afternoon, with DeForest Kelley on the Earps' side for a change.
Read · Short story
"The Last Gunfight" — James Blish
The episode retold in prose under its original title, for anyone who wants to spend a little longer in that strange town.