
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The wedding
Kirk is marrying two of his crew when Outpost 4 reports an attack. Its commander dies on screen, and the attacker is never seen.
- The face
The Enterprise intercepts a signal from the enemy ship's bridge. The Romulans look like Vulcans, and Stiles starts watching Spock.
- Cat and mouse
The cloaked ship runs for home and the Enterprise follows, each captain trying to outguess the other. Both go silent and wait.
Playing deadSpoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk makes the Enterprise look crippled to draw the Romulans in. When a coolant leak fells Stiles, it's Spock who fires the phasers.
Another realitySpoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk offers to rescue the Romulan crew. Their commander refuses, tells Kirk they might have been friends, and destroys his own ship.
Why it still matters
Kirk is in the middle of performing a wedding in the ship's chapel when the alert sounds. The outposts guarding the Neutral Zone between Earth and the Romulan Star Empire are going silent one by one, and something nobody can see is burning them away. No one in the Federation has ever seen a Romulan. When the Enterprise finally gets a look at the enemy's bridge, everyone turns to Spock.
Paul Schneider's script is a submarine movie in space, and it says so proudly: two commanders in a long game of hide and seek, each guessing the other's next move, both crews sweating it out in silence. What lifts it is the other side of the screen. Mark Lenard's Romulan commander is a tired, intelligent soldier who doesn't much like the war he's fighting, and the episode spends real time on his bridge. The two captains never meet, and by the end they understand each other better than anyone else in the story does.
It's also the episode where Star Trek first takes on bigotry directly, through a navigator, Lt. Stiles, whose family died fighting Romulans and who decides Spock can't be trusted. Business Insider ranked it the best original series episode in 2016.
Two captains of a kind
The hunt ends in a feint. The Romulans have planted a nuclear device among debris, which Kirk detonates at close range. Then he makes the Enterprise look disabled and waits. Decius, an ambitious officer, pushes the Romulan commander to come in for the kill, and when the Romulan ship decloaks, the Enterprise is ready. A coolant leak knocks out Stiles and Tomlinson, and Spock, the man Stiles suspected, fires the shot that cripples the enemy.
Kirk offers to take the survivors aboard. The commander declines. Before he triggers the self-destruct he tells Kirk, "You and I are of a kind. In a different reality, I could have called you friend." The only Enterprise crewman lost is Tomlinson, the groom from the opening scene, and the episode ends with Kirk going to comfort his fiancée, Angela Martine, the bride from that unfinished wedding.
Behind the scenes
- Schneider's script was openly modeled on submarine films. The Star Trek Compendium calls it a science fiction version of The Enemy Below (1957), and the tactic of launching debris and bodies to fake a kill comes from Run Silent, Run Deep (1958). Director Vincent McEveety had seen The Enemy Below but only noticed the likeness later: "Obviously, it's the same story."
- The episode introduced the Romulans and the cloaking device.
- Wah Chang designed and built the Romulan warship but never received an on-screen credit for his Star Trek work.
- Lawrence Montaigne, who plays Decius, came back as the Vulcan Stonn in "Amok Time."
- On September 16, 2006, it became the first Star Trek episode broadcast in its digitally remastered version.
- Kirk's wedding ceremony was reused by Picard in The Next Generation's "Data's Day."
- Bryan Fuller called it a favorite and a touchstone for Star Trek: Discovery. The Washington Post ranked it the third-best Star Trek episode in 2016.
The thread
The submarine films it borrowed from, and the enemy it introduced to Star Trek for good.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Us vs. Them
The Romulans arrive looking like Vulcans, and the episode uses that to put Spock on trial in his own crew's eyes. Kirk's answer to Stiles, to leave his bigotry in his quarters, is the show's position, and the Romulan commander's last words make the same point from the other side.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
The Enemy Below (1957)
If you loved the long silences and the respect between the two captains, here's the film the episode was built on.
Watch · Strange New Worlds
"A Quality of Mercy" (2022)
A later captain gets a look at this same encounter and a chance to handle it differently. Best watched with this one fresh in your mind.
Read · Novel
The Hunt for Red October — Tom Clancy
More submarine cat-and-mouse, with a commander on the other side whose thinking the hero has to understand before he can act.


