
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The actor
Dr. Leighton calls the Enterprise to Planet Q on a pretext. He wants Kirk to see Anton Karidian and hear his voice.
- Tarsus IV
Leighton thinks Karidian is Kodos the Executioner. Kirk doubts it until he looks into the actor's past, and then Leighton is found dead.
- Witnesses
Spock finds that seven of the nine people who could identify Kodos have died, each time with Karidian's troupe nearby. Kirk is one of the last two.
HamletSpoiler · tap to reveal
Riley, poisoned but alive, takes a phaser to the troupe's shipboard performance. Kirk stops him backstage.
The real killerSpoiler · tap to reveal
Lenore has been killing the witnesses to protect her father. She fires at Kirk, and Karidian steps into the shot.
Why it still matters
Years ago, on the colony Tarsus IV, a famine hit and the governor, a man called Kodos, decided who would live. About half of the colony's 8,000 people were executed. Kodos was believed dead. Now an old friend of Kirk's is sure he has found him: Anton Karidian, the star of a traveling Shakespeare troupe. Kirk was on Tarsus IV as a boy. He is one of the few people left alive who saw Kodos's face.
There are no aliens and almost no effects here. It's a mystery and a moral drama, played by a cast that clearly loved the material. Arnold Moss gives Karidian a stage actor's grandeur and an old man's weariness, and Barbara Anderson as his daughter Lenore is the performance people talk about afterward. Shatner is at his best too, playing a captain who wants to be certain before he destroys a man, and is less certain of his own motives by the minute.
The script holds Karidian back for most of the first half and lets the dread build in conversations, which is why it plays more like a stage play than a space adventure. Ronald D. Moore has called it "deeply underrated."
The daughter's secret
Karidian is Kodos, but he isn't the murderer. When Kirk confronts him, he defends what Kodos did without admitting he was Kodos, and a voice analysis points strongly to a match. Kirk still hesitates, and the episode makes his hesitation the point: the man in front of him is old and tired, and has spent years hiding in other people's words. The killings of the witnesses, Leighton included, and the attempts on Riley and Kirk, were the work of his daughter Lenore, who learned the secret and decided to protect him.
Kirk stops Riley's revenge backstage during Hamlet. Then Lenore confesses and, when Kirk moves to arrest them both, fires a phaser at him. Kodos steps in front of it and dies. Lenore's mind breaks. In the last scene she talks about her father as if he were still on stage, playing to cheering audiences. The title comes from Hamlet's plan to trap a guilty king by staging a play: "the play's the thing / Wherein I'll catch the conscience of the king." Here a play does catch the king, and his daughter pays for it.
Behind the scenes
- The title comes from the closing lines of Act II of Hamlet. The troupe performs Macbeth on the planet and Hamlet on board the Enterprise.
- The ship's theater was the engineering set, redressed and hung with pieces of the gymnasium set.
- This was Grace Lee Whitney's last appearance as Yeoman Janice Rand on the series. She shot it after being told she was fired, and didn't play Rand again until Star Trek: The Motion Picture.
- An early draft gave the other Tarsus IV survivor a new character, Lt. Robert Daiken. The final script used Kevin Riley from "The Naked Time" instead, which Reactor's rewatch calls a masterstroke.
- The name Kodos inspired Kodos the alien, one of the pair of recurring invaders on The Simpsons.
The thread
Shakespeare's guilty kings, and the question of what to do with a monster who has grown old.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
The State Knows Best
Kodos took a famine and turned it into a selection program, deciding on his own authority who deserved to survive. Karidian still defends the logic. The episode sets that cold arithmetic against the grief of the people it left behind, and it doesn't let Kirk's anger off the hook either.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Marathon Man (1976)
If you liked the slow dread of a hunted past catching up with an old man, this thriller does it with a dentist's drill.
Watch · Series
Station Eleven (2021)
A traveling Shakespeare troupe crosses a world after catastrophe, and the series thinks hard about why people keep performing old plays.
Read · Novel
Station Eleven — Emily St. John Mandel
The novel behind the series: a theater company crossing a broken country, carrying Shakespeare with them.


