
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Keep away
The Enterprise carries Ambassador Robert Fox to Eminiar VII to open relations. Eminiar warns them not to approach. Fox orders Kirk to go anyway.
- An attack without bombs
Kirk and Spock beam down during a Vendikar attack. Nothing explodes. Anan 7 explains that the war is fought entirely by computers.
CasualtiesSpoiler · tap to reveal
The computers have ruled the Enterprise destroyed in the attack. Under the treaty, its crew must report to be killed.
Holding the shipSpoiler · tap to reveal
Anan fakes Kirk's voice to order the crew down. Scotty spots the fake and raises the shields, and they hold when Eminiar opens fire.
General Order 24Spoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk breaks the machinery the war runs on and gives both planets a choice they've avoided for centuries.
Why it still matters
Most Star Trek planets of the week come down to a costume and a gimmick, and this one makes an argument. The Enterprise brings an ambassador to Eminiar VII, a world at war with its neighbour Vendikar, and finds a society that has made war tidy: no rubble and no panic in the streets. Somebody has figured out how to keep fighting forever without paying the usual price, and the price they pay instead is the episode's subject.
It's a very 1967 idea, written at the height of the Cold War, about what happens when war becomes a process run by machines and paperwork. Kirk is at his most stubborn and most persuasive, and Scotty gets one of his best early turns holding the ship while the captain is away. David Opatoshu plays Anan 7, the council leader, as a decent bureaucrat who has never been asked to look at what he runs.
Keith R.A. DeCandido, rewatching it for Tor.com, called Kirk's closing argument one of the captain's best speeches. The plot holes don't dent it.
War without the mess
Eminiar and Vendikar fight with simulated attacks. A computer works out who was hit, and under the treaty between them, everyone listed as a casualty walks calmly into a disintegration chamber. The people die, but the buildings, the culture and the cities survive. When the Enterprise is ruled "destroyed," Anan expects its crew to report like anyone else. Kirk is captured, Spock gets them out with a telepathic suggestion to a guard, and Ambassador Fox, who believed Anan's apology after the planet fired on the ship, nearly ends up in a chamber himself.
Kirk's answer is General Order 24, a standing order that the Enterprise destroy the planet in two hours. In the panic, he and Spock wreck the war computers. Anan protests that a real war will follow, with real devastation. Kirk is betting that Vendikar is just as horrified at that prospect, and that a war with consequences is one both sides will finally want to stop. His argument is that humans are killers by instinct but can decide, every day, not to kill today. Fox agrees to mediate the ceasefire.
Behind the scenes
- Robert Hamner wrote the story, and Gene L. Coon co-wrote the teleplay with him.
- This is the first time the show uses the full name "the United Federation of Planets." The word "Federation" had first turned up a few weeks earlier in "Arena."
- Ambassador Fox's name came back as a ship, the S.S. Robert Fox, in Star Trek Generations.
- General Order 24 is mentioned again in the third-season episode "Whom Gods Destroy."
- Robert Hewitt Wolfe titled his 1994 Deep Space Nine episode "Armageddon Game" as a nod to this one.
The thread
A Cold War nightmare about war turned into a bureaucratic routine, and the later stories that kept quoting it.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
The State Knows Best
Eminiar's government has made the most efficient deal imaginable with its citizens: you may be called to die on schedule, and in return the city stands. Everyone has accepted it because it works. The episode's quiet horror is how orderly it all is, with people walking into chambers like they're catching a bus.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
WarGames (1983)
Another war run by a computer, and another story about whether anyone can actually win one.
Watch · Star Trek
"Errand of Mercy"
Gene L. Coon again, a month later, with Kirk in a very different position on the question of war.
Read · Short story
"The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" — Ursula K. Le Guin
Four pages about a happy city and the price everyone in it has agreed not to think about.
Read · Novel
Ender's Game — Orson Scott Card
If the idea of war fought through simulations stuck with you, this novel takes it somewhere much more personal.

