Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 2 / Episode 14

The Icarus Factor

Riker is offered a ship of his own. The man sent to brief him on it is the father he hasn't seen in fifteen years. Meanwhile Worf is in a foul mood, and nobody aboard knows why.

  • First aired Apr 24, 1989 · Syndication
  • Directed by Robert Iscove
  • Story by David Assael
  • Teleplay by David Assael and Robert L. McCullough
  • Guest starring Mitchell Ryan
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The Icarus Factor"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The Icarus Factor"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 2
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The Icarus Factor" (Syndication, 1989). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The Aries

    At Starbase Montgomery, Starfleet offers Riker command of the Aries. Picard tells him a small ship of his own would still be his.

  2. Dad's here

    The adviser sent to brief Riker is his father, Kyle. Will keeps him at arm's length, and Pulaski reveals that she and Kyle were once close.

  3. What's wrong with Worf?

    Wesley, Geordi and Data work out that Worf is coming up on the tenth anniversary of his Age of Ascension, with no Klingons to share it.

  4. Anbo-jyutsuSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Father and son settle things with padded, blindfolded staff fighting. Will catches Kyle in an illegal move and realizes he cheated to beat him as a boy.

  5. Staying putSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Worf runs a holodeck gauntlet of pain sticks with his crewmates watching. Riker, reconciled with Kyle, turns the Aries down.

Why it still matters

This is the episode that gives Will Riker a past. Starfleet offers him command of the Aries for a long mission to Vega Omicron, and Picard gives him until the end of a twelve-hour starbase stop to decide. Then the civilian adviser arrives to brief him, and it's Kyle Riker, his estranged father. Pulaski turns out to know Kyle rather well, which makes things more awkward for everyone.

The B-story is the one fans remember fondly. Worf is snapping at people, and Wesley recruits Geordi and Data to find out why. The answer is a Klingon anniversary he has no way of marking on a ship full of humans, and the crew's solution is one of early TNG's warmer moments for its Klingon.

Critics have not been kind to the main plot, and the fight scene at its center gets a lot of ribbing. Still, this is where Kyle Riker comes from, and it puts Riker's habit of saying no to promotions on the table, a question the show came back to in "The Best of Both Worlds."

Spoilers from here on. Riker's choice, and the secret behind his father's winning streak.

The old man cheated

The anbo-jyutsu match is where it all comes out. Mid-bout, Will accuses his father of an illegal move, and then it clicks: Kyle only ever beat him as a kid by cheating. Kyle admits it. He says he did it to keep his son interested in the sport, which is about as honest a summary of their relationship as the episode offers. They talk it through, Kyle tells Will he loves him, and they reconcile.

Riker then turns down the Aries. James Hunt, revisiting the episode for Den of Geek, said he changes his mind without a convincing explanation, and it doesn't help that viewers knew a regular in the opening credits wasn't going anywhere. Keith R.A. DeCandido's rewatch for Tor.com put it more bluntly, and gave the episode a 3 out of 10.

Worf gets the better ending. His crewmates set up the Age of Ascension ritual on the holodeck, and he walks the gauntlet of Klingon warriors and their pain sticks, reciting his vows as he goes, then thanks the people who made it happen. Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club, who called the rest of the episode pretty dreadful, made an exception for this part.

Behind the scenes

  • The title comes from the Greek myth of the inventor Daedalus and his son Icarus.
  • Robert L. McCullough was handed an outline of a father-son story to rewrite. He wanted a confrontation and then a reconciliation, and drew on karate philosophy for the fight.
  • Jonathan Frakes liked the script and was glad to be at the center of it. Patrick Stewart, according to McCullough, objected loudly at the cast read-through.
  • Kyle Riker is played by Mitchell Ryan, who had been one of the last two actors in the running to play Captain Picard.
  • John Tesh, then a co-host of Entertainment Tonight, plays one of the holodeck Klingons, uncredited. He had volunteered for any part on the show, and playing a Klingon was a long-held dream.
  • The script spells it "Anbo-jyutsu," but both Rikers say "Anbo-jitsu." The banners around the arena are in Japanese.
  • Riker keeps saying no. He turned down the Drake in "The Arsenal of Freedom," turns down the Melbourne in "The Best of Both Worlds," and only takes his own ship, the Titan, after Star Trek Nemesis.

The thread

A father, a son, and the old question of whether Riker will ever leave the Enterprise.

Came before

Daedalus and IcarusGreek myth · the father-and-son story the title borrows

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

Deny Thy FatherJeff Mariotte · Star Trek novel · Kyle Riker gets a book of his own
A Time to Love and A Time to HateRobert Greenberger · Star Trek novels · Kyle Riker returns

DNA strand

Memory & Identity

Both halves of the episode are about who you are when the people who shaped you aren't around. Riker has built a career partly in reaction to his father, and Worf has built a life among humans with no one to mark the Klingon milestones with him.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Heart of Glory""The Best of Both Worlds"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · TNG S1

"The Arsenal of Freedom"

Riker's first chance at a command of his own, and the first time he passes it up.

Watch · TNG S1

"Heart of Glory"

If Worf's ritual was the best part for you, this is where the show first asked what being Klingon on the Enterprise costs him.

Watch · TNG S3 and S4

"The Best of Both Worlds"

Riker's career question comes back with far higher stakes, and a much better script around it.

Read · Star Trek novel

Deny Thy Father — Jeff Mariotte

For anyone who wanted more of Kyle Riker than one starbase visit and a staff fight.

Sources