
The story in 5 beats
- The probe
Data is sent to Barkon IV to recover radioactive pieces of a crashed probe. Something goes wrong, and he walks into a village with no memory.
- Jayden
The magistrate Garvin and his daughter Gia take him in. Garvin sells the shiny fragments, and villagers start wearing them as jewelry.
- The exam
Troi passes every part of the bridge officer's test except a holodeck simulation of a crippled Enterprise. She keeps failing it.
The cureSpoiler · tap to reveal
Data works out that the metal is poisoning the town and makes an antidote. Some villagers see his mechanical insides and decide he's a monster.
The orderSpoiler · tap to reveal
Troi finally passes by sending a holographic Geordi to his death to save the ship. Data is struck down by the mob and buried by Gia and her father.
Why it still matters
The two stories never meet, though both ask who you are once the usual props are gone. On Barkon IV, a world roughly at Renaissance level, Data loses his memory while recovering pieces of a crashed probe. A magistrate and his daughter take him in, the local healer decides he's an "ice-man" from the mountains, and the girl names him Jayden. He has no idea he's an android, or that the shiny metal he brought with him is making the town sick.
Meanwhile Troi, who has thought about command since she was stuck in charge in "Disaster," studies for the bridge officer's exam. She aces everything except one holodeck scenario that Riker supervises, and she keeps failing it the same way.
Brent Spiner gets to play Data as a gentle, curious stranger, and Kimberly Cullum's Gia is a good foil. The Troi plot is the quieter half, and it's the one critics have singled out.
Two hard lessons
Data, with Talur the healer's help, begs the villagers to throw the fragments away. They attack him instead, exposing the machinery under his skin. He makes the antidote anyway, treats Garvin and Gia, and puts the rest in the village well. The mob comes back and strikes him down. Garvin and Gia bury him in the forest along with the fragments. Riker and Crusher arrive posing as Jayden's friends, Riker tells Gia his real name, and Data is beamed home and repaired. He remembers nothing of his time as Jayden, and guesses a power surge from the probe overloaded his positronic brain.
Troi's answer is the one she didn't want to see: a commander sometimes has to order someone to die. She sends the holographic Geordi into the area where the repair will kill him, saves the ship and passes. She's promoted to commander. Put side by side, Data saves people who are afraid of him and gets nothing back, while Troi learns that caring about her crew sometimes means spending one of them.
Behind the scenes
- Picard barely appears. The episode was filmed in December 1993, while Patrick Stewart was in London performing A Christmas Carol on stage.
- Christopher Hatton came up with the story, Ronald D. Moore wrote the teleplay, and Winrich Kolbe directed.
- Barkon IV gets its own details: the villagers count money in doraks and measure in seltons, and they believe ice-men live in the Vellorian mountains.
- Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club called Troi's command test one of the character's best storylines, though he felt the two plots never quite join up.
- Jamahl Epsicokhan of Jammer's Reviews was less taken, calling it "inoffensive but relentlessly nondescript."
- In 2020 Tom's Guide listed it as having some of Deanna Troi's best moments.
The thread
The made man among frightened villagers, and the test with no good answer.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Memory & Identity
Strip Data of his memory and what's left is still recognizably Data: curious, polite, and unable to leave a problem alone. The episode makes a quiet case that character runs deeper than memory, even in a machine.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Edward Scissorhands (1990)
If Data in the village got to you, here's another kind, odd made man trying to fit in with neighbors who can't decide what he is.
Read · Novel
Frankenstein by Mary Shelley
The original story of a created being who learns about people by watching them, and finds out how they treat what they don't understand.
Watch · Film
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (1982)
For Troi's half: the Kobayashi Maru is Starfleet's most famous impossible test, and the film asks what it's really for.
Watch · TNG S5
"Disaster" (1991)
Where Troi first sat in the big chair, out of her depth. It's worth seeing how far she's come.
Sources
- “Thine Own Self,” Wikipedia
- “Star Trek: The Next Generation season 7,” Wikipedia
- “Thine Own Self: Episode Trivia,” TrekCore
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "Lower Decks"/"Thine Own Self",” The A.V. Club, 2011
- Jamahl Epsicokhan, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "Thine Own Self",” Jammer's Reviews