Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 5 / Episode 5

Disaster

Something hits the Enterprise, the power dies, and the crew is scattered in small groups that can't reach each other. Troi has the bridge. Picard has three children and a stuck turbolift.

  • First aired Oct 21, 1991 · Syndication
  • Directed by Gabrielle Beaumont
  • Teleplay by Ronald D. Moore, from a story by Ron Jarvis and Philip A. Scorza
  • Guest starring Rosalind Chao, Michelle Forbes and Erika Flores
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Disaster"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Disaster"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Disaster" (Syndication, 1991). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Dead in space

    The Enterprise strikes a quantum filament. Power fails across the ship, and the decks lose contact with each other.

  2. Troi has the bridge

    Troi is the senior officer left on the bridge, with O'Brien and Ro, and the warp core's containment field is failing.

  3. Picard and the kids

    Picard is giving three science fair winners a tour when the turbolift drops. He breaks his ankle and has to keep them calm.

  4. Ten Forward

    Riker and Data head for Engineering through the Jefferies tubes. Back in Ten Forward, Keiko goes into labor, and Worf is the nearest thing to a doctor.

  5. Ro's way outSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Ro wants to separate the saucer and leave Engineering's survivors behind. Troi says no and gambles on Riker and Data getting through.

Why it still matters

It's a 1970s disaster movie on the Enterprise, and it knows it. Ronald D. Moore loved those films and asked to write it. The writers broke the story by pitching pairings of characters trapped together, and kept the ones that would put people in the wrong place: the counselor in command, the captain who can't stand children babysitting three of them, Worf facing a medical emergency he has only trained for.

Every group gets a problem built around its weak spot, which is why it holds up so well, and the cast gets to play against type. Moore said he was proud of the balance: it isn't a "Picard saves the day" episode, and Data doesn't talk his way out of it.

It's also Ro Laren's second episode, and she gets to be the blunt voice on a bridge that badly needs one. Moore called her "a breath of fresh air." Time later counted the episode among the top ten moments in all of Star Trek, films included.

Spoilers from here on. From here on, how each group gets out.

Everybody gets out

Troi sides with O'Brien over Ro and has power diverted to a panel in Engineering. Riker and Data, blocked by a high-voltage discharge in the tubes, get past it only after Data sacrifices his body to disrupt it. Riker carries his head the rest of the way, Data uses his own positronic brain to restore basic control, and the containment field holds. Ro apologizes for pushing to separate; Troi tells her she could easily have been right.

In the cargo bay, Crusher and La Forge stop a plasma fire by venting the bay to space, hanging on to a ladder until they can restore the air. In the turbolift, Picard hands out honorary ranks and leads the children up the shaft to safety. By the end he likes them enough to promise another tour.

And in Ten Forward, Worf delivers Keiko's baby. It's tense, but mother and daughter are fine: this is the birth of Molly O'Brien.

Behind the scenes

  • Ronald D. Moore wrote the teleplay from a story credited to Ron Jarvis and Philip A. Scorza, and Gabrielle Beaumont directed.
  • Moore originally wanted Crusher and La Forge in spacesuits. He had read that exposure to vacuum is less instantly deadly than most science fiction shows it, pointed to a scene in 2001: A Space Odyssey, and had to convince the show's science adviser, Naren Shankar.
  • The first version had Picard and the children climbing the shaft in the rain, an idea dropped because it cost too much.
  • Because Troi isn't a line officer, the writers had to work out whether the crew should call her "ma'am" or "sir." Moore said nobody on the show had yet had to answer to a superior female officer, and pointed to Saavik being called "Mister" in Star Trek II.
  • Molly O'Brien is born in this episode, in Ten Forward, and Troi's time in command leads her to pursue the rank of commander in later seasons.
  • Mike Stoklasa of Red Letter Media put it in his top five TNG episodes, calling it The Poseidon Adventure in space.

The thread

The disaster movies it was built from, a film Moore used to win an argument, and where the story picked up next.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Where it led

DNA strand

Trapped With Strangers

Nobody here is a stranger exactly, but the episode locks people together who never share a scene: the captain and three children, the counselor and two officers who disagree with each other, the Klingon and the woman in labor. The fun is watching each group find out what it's made of.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:The Poseidon AdventureApollo 13Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

The Poseidon Adventure

The film Mike Stoklasa reached for when he described this episode, and the kind of 1970s disaster movie Moore loved.

Watch · Film

Apollo 13

Another crippled spacecraft, where getting home depends on fixes made from whatever is at hand.

Watch · Star Trek: TNG S5

"The Game" (1991)

The very next episode, where the O'Briens' new daughter gets her name.

Read · Novel

The Martian by Andy Weir

A survival story told one improvised fix at a time. If the cargo bay scene was your favorite, the whole book runs on that feeling.

Sources