
The story in 5 beats
- The duckblind
The Enterprise comes to resupply scientists hidden on Mintaka III. Their holographic camouflage fails, and a Mintakan named Liko sees inside.
- A failed memory wipe
Liko is badly hurt in a fall. Dr. Crusher beams him aboard, heals him and tries to erase his memory, but it doesn't take.
- The Overseer
Back home, Liko tells the village he has met a supreme being like the one they call the Overseer, and that its name is Picard.
Riker and Troi in disguiseSpoiler · tap to reveal
Riker and Troi go down as Mintakans to find a missing scientist. Riker gets him out, but the villagers capture Troi.
Proof of mortalitySpoiler · tap to reveal
Picard brings Nuria aboard to show her he is only a man. To settle it for the village, he has to go down and face Liko himself.
Why it still matters
This is the Prime Directive episode for people who like the Prime Directive. Federation scientists are secretly watching the Mintakans, a proto-Vulcan people, from behind a holographic blind. When the blind fails, the damage is done in seconds, and the rest of the episode is spent trying to stop a religion before it starts.
Picard's horror at being worshipped drives the story. His scenes with Nuria, the village leader, played by Kathryn Leigh Scott of Dark Shadows, are the best thing in it, especially the one where he explains why advanced technology can look like magic. The A.V. Club gave it an A, and Den of Geek's verdict was "WATCH. That's an order."
It has a loud dissenter too. Keith DeCandido hated it, said the Prime Directive is applied "to the point of absurdity," and found Picard short on compassion for a grieving man. Both readings are worth having in your head while you watch.
The god who bleeds
Nuria is persuaded on the ship. She sees one of the scientists die despite everything the crew can do, and she looks out of a window at space. The village is harder. Liko, whose wife died in a flood, wants the Overseer to bring her back, and when Picard says he can't, Liko aims his bow at him. His daughter Oji spoils the shot, and the arrow wounds Picard in the shoulder, which convinces the village where the speeches couldn't.
The Federation takes its outpost away and leaves the Mintakans alone, and Nuria gives Picard a tapestry as a gift. Den of Geek's James Hunt noted that the Prime Directive "has not been particularly upheld," though the crew limited the damage. DeCandido thought Picard owed Liko more kindness than a lecture.
Behind the scenes
- It was the last episode under Michael Wagner's brief run as head writer. Michael Piller took over from the next episode on.
- Ray Wise plays Liko, just before his role in Twin Peaks.
- The planet scenes were shot at Vasquez Rocks, a location used many times on the original series, its spinoffs and the 2009 Star Trek film.
- The title comes from Juvenal's Satires: "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?" Alan Moore used the same phrase for Watchmen.
- Nuria's tapestry stays in Picard's quarters for the rest of the series and turns up in most of the Next Generation films.
- Red Letter Media's Rich Evans has named it his favorite Next Generation episode.
- The first broadcast drew a Nielsen rating of 9.6.
The thread
Picard and the Prime Directive, before and after the day a village made him a god.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Came back later
DNA strand
First Contact & Invaders
Most first-contact stories are about meeting aliens. This one is about being the aliens: the advanced visitors who arrive by accident, are taken for gods and have to talk their way back down to mortal. The Mintakans handle it better than most humans would.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Short story
"The Man Who Would Be King" by Rudyard Kipling
If Picard's refusal to be worshipped interested you, here are two men who make the opposite choice.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S4
"The Drumhead" (1991)
A tense courtroom episode in which this one comes back to haunt Picard.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S2
"Pen Pals" (1989)
The show's other big Prime Directive argument, with Data on the wrong side of the rules.
Read · Graphic novel
Watchmen by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons
It borrows the same line from Juvenal and asks the same question of its own guardians.
Sources
- “Who Watches the Watchers,” Wikipedia
- “Star Trek: The Next Generation season 3,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Who Watches the Watchers?",” Reactor (Tor.com), 2011
- James Hunt, “Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Who Watches The Watchers?,” Den of Geek, 2014
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: Third Season Overview,” Reactor (Tor.com), 2012