
The story in 5 beats
- Fired on
A Cardassian ship attacks the Enterprise near the border. Its commander, Gul Macet, says a Federation ship destroyed one of their stations.
- Maxwell's Phoenix
Starfleet confirms it: Captain Benjamin Maxwell and the USS Phoenix. Picard is sent to find him, with Macet aboard as an observer.
- O'Brien's war
O'Brien served under Maxwell on the Rutledge during the Cardassian war, and admits he still hasn't let go of it.
Six hundred and fiftySpoiler · tap to reveal
The Phoenix destroys a Cardassian warship and a supply ship before the Enterprise can catch it. Over 650 Cardassians die.
The Minstrel BoySpoiler · tap to reveal
O'Brien beams onto the Phoenix, talks to his old captain, and they sing an old Irish song. Maxwell gives up his command.
Why it still matters
This is the episode that introduces the Cardassians, and it does it as if they had always been there. The Federation fought a war with them, the treaty is barely a year old, and nobody on screen trusts it. Within a few years they would be at the center of Deep Space Nine, and Marc Alaimo, who plays the Cardassian Gul Macet here, would become that show's great villain, Gul Dukat.
It's also the first episode to give Colm Meaney's O'Brien a big part. The transporter chief turns out to have fought the Cardassians and to still carry it. His old captain, Benjamin Maxwell, is the one now firing on them, and Bob Gunton plays Maxwell as a good officer who has come apart. Ryan Britt at Inverse points out that Gunton was a Vietnam veteran.
Almost all of the fighting happens off screen. What you watch are conversations in rooms: Picard and Macet circling each other, O'Brien apologizing to a Cardassian in Ten-Forward, and Picard putting one blunt question after another to Maxwell.
He was right, and it doesn't matter
Maxwell insists the Cardassians are rearming: the science station is a military base and the freighters carry weapons. He can't prove it, Picard takes his reasons apart, and Maxwell agrees to head home. Then the Phoenix turns toward another freighter whose shields block Federation scans. Picard readies the Enterprise's weapons, and O'Brien asks to go over, using a transporter trick to get through the Phoenix's shields.
In Maxwell's ready room the two men talk about the Rutledge and sing "The Minstrel Boy" together, and O'Brien gets through to him that he can't fight this war alone. Maxwell hands over command and waits on the Enterprise for Starfleet. The sting comes in the last scene. Picard tells Macet that Maxwell's suspicions had merit: the station has a military purpose, and the freighters' shields were built to beat Federation scans. He chose the peace anyway, and he warns Macet the Federation will be watching.
Behind the scenes
- Robert Blackman designed the Cardassian uniforms and Michael Westmore developed their makeup. The brown uniforms seen here appear only in this episode; Deep Space Nine switched to gray.
- Macet was Marc Alaimo's third role on the show, after an Antican in "Lonely Among Us" and a Romulan in "The Neutral Zone." He went on to play Gul Dukat on Deep Space Nine.
- "The Minstrel Boy," the Thomas Moore song O'Brien and Maxwell sing, returns as the music for one of O'Brien's last scenes in Deep Space Nine's finale, "What You Leave Behind."
- Bob Gunton plays Maxwell. Keith R.A. DeCandido's Reactor rewatch says he makes Maxwell "far less of a caricature than he might be in the hands of a lesser talent," and gave the episode 7 out of 10.
- The Setlik III massacre, mentioned here, comes back in Deep Space Nine, where O'Brien is called "the hero of Setlik III."
- TrekMovie.com has recommended it as Saint Patrick's Day viewing for its Irish content.
The thread
Star Trek's earlier obsessed captains, the stories it sits beside, and the series it built the ground for.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Where it led
DNA strand
Us vs. Them
The war is officially over, and both sides are still fighting it in their heads. The episode lets you understand Maxwell's hatred, O'Brien's and Macet's, and then asks what a peace is worth if nobody believes in it.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek
"Balance of Terror" (1966)
If the uneasy border got to you, this is the original version: Kirk, the Romulans and a crewman whose hatred puts everyone at risk.
Watch · Star Trek: DS9
"Duet" (1993)
The Cardassians a few years on, and another tense, mostly two-person conversation about guilt after a war.
Read · Novel
Moby-Dick by Herman Melville
Maxwell has a lot of Ahab in him. Melville's captain is the long version of a man who has made one enemy the point of his life.