Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 5 / Episode 4

Silicon Avatar

The Crystalline Entity is back, stripping colonies bare, and the Enterprise takes on a scientist who has spent her life studying it. She has her own reasons, and she does not trust Data.

  • First aired Oct 14, 1991 · Syndication
  • Directed by Cliff Bole
  • Teleplay by Jeri Taylor, from a story by Lawrence V. Conley
  • Guest starring Ellen Geer and Susan Diol
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Silicon Avatar"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Silicon Avatar"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Silicon Avatar" (Syndication, 1991). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Melona IV

    Riker and Data are visiting the colony on Melona IV when the Entity strikes. The survivors hide in caves, but two colonists die.

  2. Dr. Marr

    The Enterprise hunts the Entity with Kila Marr, its leading expert. She makes it plain that she doesn't trust Data, Lore's brother.

  3. Renny

    Marr's son died at Omicron Theta. Data holds the colonists' memories, including his, and when he reads her the boy's journal, she weeps.

  4. A signal back

    Picard wants to talk to the Entity before harming it. The Enterprise sends graviton pulses, and the Entity answers in a pattern.

  5. The beamSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Marr secretly turns the pulses into a steady beam and locks the controls. The resonance shatters the Entity.

Why it still matters

The Crystalline Entity from "Datalore" returns, and this time the episode is less interested in the monster than in the woman hunting it. Dr. Kila Marr is a xenobiologist who knows more about the Entity than anyone, and she arrives sure that Data, whose brother once helped it, can't be trusted.

The writers knew what they were borrowing. According to Larry Nemecek's Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion, the Moby-Dick parallel was deliberate, and Picard himself brings up the sperm whale. Underneath is a question TNG keeps coming back to: whether something that kills is a monster, or just something nobody has managed to talk to yet.

Data is the reason to watch. He carries the memories of the colonists of Omicron Theta, the world where he was built, and the episode finds a sad use for that idea. The A.V. Club called its conclusions "refreshingly bleak."

Spoilers from here on. From here on, what Marr does and what Data tells her.

For Renny

Just as Picard thinks he has a first contact, Marr locks the program and turns the pulses into a continuous beam. The Entity shatters. She speaks to Data as if he were her son and tells him she did it for him. She has her revenge, and she has ended her career.

In her quarters she asks Data how long he will last. Built to function indefinitely, he says, and she takes comfort in the thought that her son lives on in him. She asks him to tell Renny what she did.

Data won't give her that. Renny loved her work as a scientist, he says, and her grief made her destroy the very thing that made the work matter. "Yes, I believe your son would be very sad now." That ending is the part The A.V. Club singled out for praise.

Behind the scenes

  • The story began as a freelance submission by Lawrence V. Conley, according to Nemecek's Companion. Jeri Taylor, who was against sequel episodes at the time, wrote the final teleplay: "Of all the characters to bring back, who'd have thought the Crystalline Entity?"
  • Director Cliff Bole said in Captain's Logs that he would have made Marr and the ending stronger, and that the episode had only about 40 minutes of picture time to work with. Michael Piller liked the premise but felt it could have hit harder.
  • Mark Clark's Star Trek FAQ 2.0 reads the episode as Moby-Dick, with the Entity as the whale and Marr as Ahab, and links it to the original series' "The Doomsday Machine."
  • Susan Diol, who plays the colonist Carmen Davila, later played Denara Pel on Star Trek: Voyager.
  • The Music of Star Trek credits Jay Chattaway's score with "memorable dramatic support."

The thread

The whale it was modeled on, the episode that introduced the Entity, and where the Entity turned up next.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Where it went next

Titan: Orion's HoundsChristopher L. Bennett · novel · Captain Riker meets crystalline entities again

DNA strand

Memory & Identity

Data carries the memories of a dead colony, and to a grieving mother that makes him either a monster's accomplice or the last place her son still exists. The episode lets her believe both, and lets Data refuse the role.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Datalore""The Measure of a Man"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Read · Novel

Moby-Dick by Herman Melville

If Marr's obsession was the part that stuck, go back to the original hunt, whose shape the episode borrowed on purpose.

Watch · Star Trek S2

"The Doomsday Machine" (1967)

A giant thing eating planets and a commander who has lost too much to it make this a good double bill with "Silicon Avatar."

Watch · Star Trek: TNG S1

"Datalore" (1988)

Where the Entity and Omicron Theta first come up, and the backstory behind Marr's distrust of Data.

Read · Novel

Titan: Orion's Hounds by Christopher L. Bennett

A later Star Trek novel in which Riker's own crew runs into crystalline entities, for anyone who wanted to know more about what these creatures are.

Sources