Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 6 / Episode 24

Second Chances

Eight years after Riker barely escaped a research station, he goes back for its data and finds a bearded man living there alone. The man is also William Riker.

  • First aired the week of May 24, 1993 · Syndication
  • Directed by LeVar Burton
  • Teleplay by René Echevarria, from a story by Michael A. Medlock
  • Guest starring Dr. Mae Jemison
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Second Chances"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Second Chances"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Second Chances" (Syndication, 1993). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Nightbird

    Riker leads a jazz set in Ten Forward, and Troi asks for "Nightbird," a tune he has never mastered. Then a rare window opens to beam down to Nervala IV.

  2. The man in the ruins

    At the abandoned station, a ragged, bearded officer appears. He says he's Lieutenant Riker, and that he's been stranded there for eight years.

  3. Two of him

    Crusher confirms they're identical. Geordi works out that the Potemkin's transporter made a second beam, which bounced back to the planet with a second Riker in it.

  4. Imzadi

    The lieutenant picks up with Troi where he left off and asks her to leave the ship with him. The two Rikers clash over the mission and over a poker table.

  5. The catwalkSpoiler · tap to reveal

    On the last attempt a walkway collapses, and Commander Riker has to decide whether to save his double.

Why it still matters

Transporter duplicates were an old Star Trek trick by 1993, and Keith R.A. DeCandido admitted he dreaded rewatching this one. He came out calling it "far better than a transporter duplicate episode has any right to be." What lifts it is the man found on Nervala IV: eight years alone, still the eager lieutenant who was going to meet Deanna Troi on Risa, walking back into a life another version of himself has already lived.

Jonathan Frakes plays both men and keeps them distinct without leaning on tricks; the lieutenant is simply hungrier and more impulsive. The two of them can barely stand each other, and the crew's theories about why (Data thinks they've lost their sense of being unique; Worf thinks each sees in the other what he dislikes in himself) make for some of the episode's best scenes.

Under the doubles story is a Troi story. She's the one who was left behind when Riker's career came first, and now an earlier version of that choice is standing in front of her, asking again.

Spoilers from here on. Who survives the catwalk, and where each Riker ends up.

Two lives, one trombone

Picard backs the lieutenant's plan for the final retrieval over the commander's objections, and it works. On the way out the catwalk gives way. The lieutenant tells his double not to risk it; Commander Riker saves him anyway, and they both come home.

Picard finds the lieutenant a posting on the USS Gandhi, and he decides to go by his middle name, Thomas, so the two can be told apart. Troi chooses to stay on the Enterprise and thanks him for their time together. Will gives him the trombone as a parting gift, since it belongs to both of them, and admits, a little surprised, that they really are different people now.

Behind the scenes

  • It was LeVar Burton's first time directing Star Trek. He went on to direct "The Pegasus" in season seven and more than two dozen episodes of Deep Space Nine, Voyager and Enterprise.
  • Dr. Mae Jemison, the first Black woman in space, plays transporter chief Lt. Palmer, the first real astronaut to appear on Star Trek. Burton invited her after learning she was a fan. Nichelle Nichols visited the set while she was filming.
  • The pitch was nearly turned down. The writers kept it because it gave them a way to fill in Riker and Troi's past.
  • The writers floated killing off Commander Riker and keeping the lieutenant, with Data promoted to first officer.
  • Fans had long assumed, with Frakes's encouragement, that Riker's middle name was Thelonius. This episode made it Thomas.
  • It drew a 9.7 Nielsen rating, down from 10.6 for "Rightful Heir" the week before.

The thread

Meeting yourself, and finding out you don't much like him.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

"Defiant"Star Trek: Deep Space Nine · 1994 · Thomas Riker returns

DNA strand

Alternate Selves

Most double stories make one copy the evil twin. Both Rikers are decent men, which makes it harder: each is a living reminder of the choice the other made, and Troi has to weigh the man who left against the man who never got the chance to.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:Multiplicity"The Enemy Within"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Star Trek S1

"The Enemy Within" (1966)

The original transporter split, with Kirk instead of Riker. Fun to compare how differently the two shows used the same accident.

Read · Novella

The Double by Fyodor Dostoevsky

A clerk meets a man who is exactly him, only smoother and more successful. If the two Rikers' prickliness was the best part, this is that feeling taken all the way.

Watch · Film

Multiplicity (1996)

Michael Keaton makes copies of himself to free up some time, and the copies turn out to be different people, which is this episode's question played for comedy.

Watch · Deep Space Nine

"Defiant" (1994)

If you wanted to know what Thomas did next, this is where he turns up. Go in knowing nothing else.

Sources