
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Rescue of the Dorian
The Enterprise saves a Federation transport under attack. Aboard is Ambassador Alkar, a mediator headed to end a civil war, and the old woman he calls his mother.
- A hostile mother
Alkar and Troi become friends, while his mother, Sev Maylor, is openly hostile to her.
- Funeral stones
Maylor dies suddenly. Alkar refuses an autopsy, citing custom, and asks Troi to join him in a funeral meditation over a pair of glowing stones.
Troi unravelsSpoiler · tap to reveal
Troi turns erratic, aggressive and seductive, and she's aging fast. When she lashes out with a knife, she ends up in sickbay.
The receptacleSpoiler · tap to reveal
The autopsy shows Maylor was about thirty. Alkar admits he pours his dark emotions into a "receptacle," and Troi is the new one.
Why it still matters
Ambassador Alkar is the kind of diplomat the Federation dreams of, patient and unflappable, on his way to settle a war between two planets. The bitter old woman traveling with him as his mother takes an instant dislike to Troi. After a sudden death and a quiet ritual, Troi starts acting like someone else, and it takes the crew a while to work out why.
The story is a riff on Oscar Wilde's The Picture of Dorian Gray, and the show isn't shy about it: the transport the Enterprise rescues in the opening is called the Dorian. Marina Sirtis gets to play almost the opposite of Troi for most of the hour, and even reviewers who dislike the episode tend to enjoy her. Patrick Stewart's slow-burning anger when Picard confronts Alkar is worth the trip too.
Fans don't rate it. The A.V. Club gave it a C, and Keith DeCandido's Tor.com rewatch gave it a 1 out of 10. The idea underneath is still worth seeing, and it's darker than most of season six.
Where the anger goes
Alkar's calm is borrowed. Through the funeral ritual he channels his anger, envy and fear into another person, which keeps his own mind clear for negotiating. The receptacle ages fast and usually dies within a few years. Sev Maylor wasn't his mother at all but a woman of about thirty, worn out by what he'd put into her. He hadn't expected Troi to go downhill so quickly, and he shows no remorse.
Dr. Crusher's answer is to make Troi appear to die, which breaks the link. Alkar, satisfied, moves on to his next receptacle, Liva, a young woman from his own delegation. Crusher revives Troi and purges her system, Picard has Liva beamed out of Alkar's quarters mid-ritual, and Alkar is left alone with years of his own feelings. He ages to death in moments, and Troi comes back to herself.
Behind the scenes
- According to Tor.com's rewatch, the script was hurried into production when "Relics" was pushed back to fit James Doohan's schedule, and the writing staff all pitched in.
- Frank Abatemarco got sole credit. He was new to the writing staff and didn't last the season.
- The ship the Enterprise rescues is named the Dorian, a nod to the Oscar Wilde novel the plot borrows from.
- Lucy Boryer plays an Ensign Janeway. DeCandido's rewatch adds that she's no relation, probably.
- Screen Rant ranked it the ninth darkest episode in all of Star Trek in 2017, then listed it among the worst TNG episodes in 2019.
The thread
Wilde's portrait that grows old so its owner doesn't, and TNG's long habit of ferrying difficult diplomats.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Memory & Identity
Troi's whole job is understanding other people's feelings. Here she turns into someone the crew barely recognizes, and the episode is at its most unsettling when she can't tell what's happening to her either.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Novel
The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde
Wilde's novel about a young man who stays beautiful while his portrait ages in his place. It's much funnier than you'd expect.
Read · Short story
"The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" by Ursula K. Le Guin
A few pages long and hard to shake. Le Guin asks what a happy city is built on, and what you'd do once you knew.
Watch · TNG S5
"Violations" (1992)
A visiting telepath turns memory into a weapon against the crew. It's a tougher, better episode about the same kind of intrusion.
Watch · TNG S4
"The Host" (1991)
Another diplomat brought aboard to end a war, and a love story that goes somewhere you won't guess.
Sources
- “Man of the People (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- “Star Trek: The Next Generation season 6,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Man of the People",” Reactor (Tor.com), 2012
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "Man Of The People"/"Relics",” The A.V. Club, 2011
