Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 3 / Episode 18

Allegiance

Picard wakes up in a locked cell with three strangers. Back on the Enterprise, a Picard who looks exactly like him is flirting with Dr. Crusher and leading sing-alongs.

  • First aired Mar 26, 1990 · Syndication
  • Directed by Winrich Kolbe
  • Written by Richard Manning and Hans Beimler
  • Guest starring Stephen Markle, Reiner Schöne and Joycelyn O'Brien
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Allegiance"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Allegiance"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Allegiance" (Syndication, 1990). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Taken

    Picard vanishes from his quarters and wakes in a cell with Tholl, a philosopher, and Mitena Haro, a young Starfleet cadet. A third prisoner, Esoqq, arrives soon after.

  2. Rubber food

    The only food is a pile of tasteless discs Esoqq can't eat, and he turns on Tholl. Picard talks him down and gets everyone to work on the door.

  3. The other Picard

    On the Enterprise, a double delays a rendezvous, romances Crusher and leads Ten Forward in "Heart of Oak." Then he takes the ship toward a pulsar.

  4. A wall behind the doorSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The prisoners beat the lock and find a blank wall. Haro knows about a secret mission no cadet could know, and Picard works out they're being studied.

  5. The tables turnSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Riker and the bridge crew refuse the double's orders. Picard comes home and traps his captors in a force field, just long enough to show them how it feels.

Why it still matters

Two episodes run side by side here, and both are fun. In one, Picard is snatched from his quarters and dropped into a bare room with a nervous philosopher, a cadet and a violent alien who can't stomach the food and starts threatening the others. Nobody knows who took them or why, and Picard does what he does best: gets a frightened group working together.

In the other, the crew slowly notices their captain is off. This Picard courts Beverly, leads Ten Forward in an old sea song, and gives orders that make less and less sense. Patrick Stewart clearly enjoys playing a Picard who has never met Picard, and the moment the senior staff have to decide whether to follow him is a neat test of what Starfleet loyalty is supposed to mean.

The locked room is the stronger half. Keith DeCandido called it "half an excellent episode," and the half he meant is the cell.

Spoilers from here on. Here's who built the cell, and what they wanted to learn.

A study in authority

Each prisoner was picked as a type: Tholl the collaborator, Esoqq the anarchist, Haro the cadet sworn to obey, and Picard the leader. Haro is really one of the captors, from a species with no leaders of its own, and the double on the Enterprise is another. They talk by telepathy and wanted to watch how people lead and follow. Once Picard sees through the setup, they send the other prisoners home and bring him back to the Enterprise.

On the bridge Picard tells them the kidnapping was wrong, and they answer that they don't understand morality and will have to study it. So he gives them a lesson. With a few silent signals to his crew, he has them caught in a force field, and they panic at being confined. After a few moments he lets them go, with a warning not to take anyone else. His crew had already passed its own test by refusing to follow a captain who was acting wrong.

Behind the scenes

  • Picard and Haro refer to the events of "Who Watches the Watchers," an earlier script by the same writers, Richard Manning and Hans Beimler. Winrich Kolbe directed.
  • The episode was nominated for an Emmy for Outstanding Achievement in Makeup for a Series.
  • The two alien observers are played by Jerry and Jeff Rector.
  • "Heart of Oak," the song the false Picard leads in Ten Forward, is the official march of the Royal Navy.
  • In 2018 Popular Mechanics named it one of the best Picard episodes to watch before Star Trek: Picard.
  • Marvin Rush was the cinematographer.

The thread

Trek has a long habit of kidnapping its captains for an alien audience, and an even longer one of swapping them for doubles.

Came before

"Heart of Oak"Royal Navy march · song · 18th century · what the fake Picard sings

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Trapped With Strangers

Four people who'd never choose each other share one bare room, and the drama is in who leads, who gives in and who lashes out. The cell turns out to be the experiment, with each stranger picked to play exactly that part. Picard gets out by noticing that one of his cellmates knows too much.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:Cube"The Gamesters of Triskelion"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Cube (1997)

Strangers wake in a room with no memory of how they got there, and their personalities matter as much as the puzzle. Think of the cell scenes at feature length, and much nastier.

Watch · Star Trek S2

"The Gamesters of Triskelion" (1968)

Kirk and two crewmates are snatched off the transporter pad and made to perform for unseen hosts. The original-series version of being someone's test subject.

Watch · Star Trek S1

"The Enemy Within" (1966)

If the false Picard was your favorite part, here a captain is split in two, and the crew has to work out which one to trust.

Read · Novel

Lord of the Flies, William Golding

Put a group with no rules in one place and see who takes charge. Golding's boys have no Picard to keep them in line.

Sources