
The story in 5 beats
- Rimmer's moon
The crew claim a moon rich in Helium-7. Rimmer is very pleased with himself, until a solar storm forces them to leave.
- A ship out of time
A timewave, left by an imploding black hole, has carried an old Earth ship into their path. It's heading for the moon.
- No criticism allowed
On board, criticism is against the law. Nobody can be told they're bad at their job, which explains the steering.
ArrestedSpoiler · tap to reveal
The crew complain about a meal, the Cat insults an officer, and Captain Ziggy orders them drained of criticism.
Rimmer's inner criticSpoiler · tap to reveal
Draining Rimmer pulls his critical side out as a creature of its own, and the crew have to talk it down.
Why it still matters
The idea suits Red Dwarf, a show built on people being rude to each other. Criticism has been outlawed on this ship, and a police force in pink enforces the ban. The people least able to cope are a crew whose friendship runs on insults, and Rimmer, who lives on complaining, is in the most trouble of all.
It's also the episode of Series XII that critics liked least. Den of Geek's Mark Harrison called it "one of the weakest episodes in the show's history," and the wider reaction was negative too, with complaints about its structure and some jarring jokes. Harrison wondered whether it suffered from being written and shot in early 2016, before a year of politics that might have given its satire more bite.
Go in for the guests. Johnny Vegas, a fan, plays the Crit-Cop and called the job "a big old tick off the bucket list," and Harrison picked out Joe Sims as a prisoner jailed for tutting at a dinner lady as one of the funniest bits.
A drawing ruins everything
Rimmer's critical side, freed from him, becomes a being in its own right, and the crew beat it with reasoning and criticism, the very things the ship has banned. Ziggy is persuaded. He admits the law was wrong, puts his staff back into jobs they're actually good at, and the ship steers clear of the moon.
Grateful, Ziggy offers the crew a reward and settles on one of his own drawings, which look like a child's. Lister tells him it isn't very good. Ziggy brings the law straight back, and the crew run for Starbug.
It's a neat sitcom snap-back, and it makes the point the episode has been reaching for: a man can come round to honesty about everything except his own work.
Behind the scenes
- Recorded at Pinewood Studios on 5 February 2016. Robert Llewellyn was ill through rehearsal and pre-record week, and technical trouble with the climactic scene made the studio night run long.
- Johnny Vegas was filming Still Open All Hours next door while Series XI was being made, which made him easy to recruit.
- The Crit-Cop costume Vegas wears was first made for an abandoned Monty Python film.
- Jamie Chapman's Ziggy costume had already been worn by David Walliams in a 1999 episode of Spaced.
- One drawing on the ship's wall is signed "First Lieutenant Edward Moore," a nod to the series' director of photography.
- UKTV Play put it online a week early, on 19 October 2017.
The thread
A satire about a society that can't bear bad news, built on Red Dwarf's long habit of splitting Rimmer into pieces.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Where Series XII went next
DNA strand
The State Knows Best
The Encomium's law is a well-meant rule taken to its end: if criticism hurts, ban it, and send police to make sure. Nobody ends up happier, only worse at their jobs. It's a thin satire, though the shape of it, a state protecting people from honesty, is a classic one.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Nosedive" (2016)
If the idea of compulsory niceness was the best thing here, Black Mirror built a whole episode around it, with a social rating score in place of the Crit-Cops.
Watch · Red Dwarf V
"Demons and Angels" (1992)
For a better-loved take on pulling a person's worst side out into its own body, here's the crew split down the middle.
Read · Novel
The Restaurant at the End of the Universe (1980)
The second Hitchhiker's novel has Douglas Adams' Golgafrincham Ark Fleet Ship B, a whole ship of people badly suited to running it. Good company for the Encomium's misplaced experts.
Read · Short story
"Harrison Bergeron" (1961)
Kurt Vonnegut spends a few pages on a government that legislates fairness to the point of absurdity. It's darker than this episode, and funnier.
Sources
- “Timewave: Complete Guide,” Red Dwarf (official site)
- “Timewave (Red Dwarf),” Wikipedia
- Mark Harrison, “Red Dwarf XII episode 3 review: Timewave,” Den of Geek, 2017
- “Red Dwarf XII Episode 3 Review: Timewave,” Flickering Myth, 2017
- “Series XII: Casting,” Red Dwarf (official site)
- “Series XII: Production,” Red Dwarf (official site)
- “Series XII: Complete Guide,” Red Dwarf (official site)