Red Dwarf / Series XI / Episode 2

Samsara

An escape pod full of ash leads the crew to a wrecked ship on an ocean moon, where a machine once judged every good and bad deed. Meanwhile, Lister and Cat are stuck with each other.

  • Aired Sep 29, 2016 · Dave
  • Directed by Doug Naylor
  • Written by Doug Naylor
  • Starring Craig Charles, Chris Barrie, Danny John-Jules and Robert Llewellyn
Still from Red Dwarf, "Samsara"
Still from Red Dwarf, "Samsara"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 2
Red Dwarf, "Samsara" (Dave, 2016). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Mineopoly

    Lister and Rimmer settle a bet over a board game. Lister has hidden cards, and Rimmer can't stop rolling a two and a one.

  2. The pod of ash

    A cut-off distress call leads to an escape pod. Its two passengers, Barker and Green, are now ash, and their ship, the Samsara, lies wrecked on an ocean moon.

  3. Two teams

    Lister and Cat end up trapped together, and Lister's dreadlocks meet a garbage disposal. Rimmer and Kryten find the ship's karma drive.

  4. Be nastySpoiler · tap to reveal

    When Rimmer insults Kryten, the power comes back. The drive has been rigged to reward bad behaviour, so the crew start being horrible to each other.

  5. One night onlySpoiler · tap to reveal

    Flashbacks show Barker reprogramming the drive so she and Green can have one guilt-free night, and the whole ship turns upside down.

Why it still matters

"Samsara" tells two stories at once. In the present, the crew poke around a crashed ship. Millions of years earlier, two of that ship's officers carry on an affair, and their story is fed to us in pieces as the crew explore. Den of Geek's Pete Dillon-Trenchard thought the break from the usual format "goes a large way towards justifying" the new series, and compared the structure to Lost.

That flashback half is almost unheard of for this show. Apart from a distress message at the start, none of the scenes with the two lovers include the Red Dwarf crew. The official guide counts only two earlier examples of scenes like that: "The Inquisitor" in Series V and "The Beginning" in Series X.

The present-day half is lighter and looser. It opens with Lister cheating Rimmer at a board game called Mineopoly, which Dillon-Trenchard rated the best scene, and it gives Lister and Cat rare time together. His advice for first-timers: the episode "benefits massively from a second viewing."

Spoilers from here on. This is where the karma drive's secret comes out.

Love brought the ship down

The Samsara ran on a karma drive, a system that rewarded good behaviour and punished bad according to its code of conduct. Barker and Green, both married to other people, came aboard to carry on their affair, and the drive made their lives miserable for it. The captain told them it would leave them alone if they stopped.

Instead Barker, a computer specialist, talked Green into giving her access to the drive and reprogrammed it for a single night so that bad deeds were rewarded and good ones punished. The ship tipped into chaos, and the crew's skeletons are what Rimmer and Kryten find. The lovers fled in the escape pod and were later killed trying to warn another ship.

Lister gets the closing thought: two people's love wrecked a whole ship. The crew head back to Red Dwarf as unethically as they can manage. Dillon-Trenchard's one complaint was that the karma drive turns up too late, leaving a "mild anti-climax."

Behind the scenes

  • The working title was "Lift Off," because Doug Naylor's first idea had the characters stuck in malfunctioning lifts.
  • Maggie Service and Dan Tetsell play the lovers, Barker and Green. Den of Geek found Green "a bit greasy and loathsome" but the pair oddly sympathetic all the same.
  • The "ice cream" Lister eats in the bunkroom scene is whipped cream.
  • The episode went up on UKTV Play on 23 September 2016, six days before it aired on Dave.

The thread

A ship run by a morality machine, from a show that had tried machine-made justice before, alongside an older Star Trek story about one licensed night of chaos.

Came before

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Technology Outpaces Ethics

Someone built a machine to keep a crew honest, and it only took one person with the password to flip it. Rimmer points out the snag at the start: moral codes change, but a drive keeps enforcing the one it was given. The comedy comes from the crew working out that the way to survive is to be awful to each other, which they're quite good at.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Justice""The Return of the Archons"The Good PlaceExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Red Dwarf IV

"Justice" (1991)

If the karma drive made you laugh, this is the show's earlier go at a machine that hands out what you deserve.

Watch · TV series

The Good Place (2016)

A whole sitcom built on a points system for good and bad deeds, and on people trying to game it.

Watch · Red Dwarf V

"The Inquisitor" (1992)

Another Red Dwarf story about being judged on how you've lived, with a much scarier judge.

Read · Novel

The Screwtape Letters (1942)

C.S. Lewis writes as a senior devil coaching a junior one, so every virtue is a problem and every vice a win: morality flipped, the way the drive flips it.

Sources