Red Dwarf / Series XI / Episode 3

Give & Take

A deranged medical droid steals Lister's kidneys, and the only spare in reach belongs to Cat, the most selfish being in the universe. Rimmer, meanwhile, has recruited a snack machine.

  • Aired Oct 6, 2016 · Dave
  • Directed by Doug Naylor
  • Written by Doug Naylor
  • Starring Craig Charles, Chris Barrie, Danny John-Jules and Robert Llewellyn
Still from Red Dwarf, "Give & Take"
Still from Red Dwarf, "Give & Take"
Image via TMDB
Red Dwarf, "Give & Take" (Dave, 2016). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Scavenging the station

    The crew find an abandoned facility rich in supplies and split into pairs to strip it.

  2. The wrong robot

    Rimmer and Kryten set out to recruit the station's medical droid, Asclepius, and come back with Snacky, the snack dispenser.

  3. Donor and recipient

    The real Asclepius, now quite mad, knocks out Lister and Cat, taking them for a kidney donor and his patient.

  4. No kidneys at allSpoiler · tap to reveal

    In the escape from an asteroid storm, gunfire destroys the jar holding Lister's kidneys. The crew set about tricking Cat into giving one up.

  5. Borrowing from yourselfSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Snacky knows how the station's stasis booths work. The crew use one to go back a few days and take the kidneys from an earlier Lister.

Why it still matters

Critics couldn't agree on this one. Digital Spy's Tom Eames called it the best Red Dwarf episode since "Gunmen of the Apocalypse" in Series VI, and CultBox's Sophie Davies called it "superlative." Den of Geek's Pete Dillon-Trenchard went the other way: "light on the laughs" with "an overly cruel streak."

Both camps have a point. The setup is properly nasty, a body-horror premise about organs going missing, and Rimmer and Cat are at their most selfish. But it also looks terrific. The abandoned station was shot at the disused Fawley Power Station, and even Dillon-Trenchard called the escape "one of the most cinematic moments the series has ever had to offer."

Then there's Snacky, a cheerful snack dispenser Rimmer and Kryten pick up by mistake. Whether he wins you over or drives you up the wall will probably decide how you feel about the whole half-hour.

Spoilers from here on. This is where Lister loses both kidneys.

A kidney heist through time

While exploring, Lister and Cat find the decomposed remains of Romero G. It looks like a throwaway clue, and the ending turns on it.

After the station is destroyed, Lister has no kidneys at all and Cat is in no mood to share. Snacky admits he isn't Asclepius, but he used to serve Gonzalez and knows how the stasis booths work. So the crew travel back a few days, knock out the earlier Lister and take his kidneys. Kryten fits an "MTK chip" to keep that Lister alive until his own run-in with Asclepius, and the loop closes.

Dillon-Trenchard found the time-travel act interesting but low on stakes, and raised the obvious question of whose kidneys Rimmer actually destroyed, which the episode doesn't stop to answer.

Behind the scenes

  • It was the first episode filmed when Series XI and XII were made back to back, recorded on 13 November 2015 at Pinewood. Dillon-Trenchard wondered whether the harsher tone came from the cast not yet having settled back into their roles.
  • The disused Fawley Power Station stands in for Asclepius's space station.
  • Snacky and Asclepius are each played by two people: Mark Quartley and Oliver Mason voice them, while Tobias Wilson and Jami Reid Quarrell are inside the costumes.
  • Rimmer talks about learning who his real father was, a callback to Series X's "The Beginning."
  • It went up on UKTV Play on 30 September 2016, a week before the Dave broadcast.

The thread

A time-travel caper that pays back old *Red Dwarf* debts, next to a sunnier story about getting help through time.

Came before

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Time Loops & Timelines

The time travel arrives late and does a very practical job: Lister needs kidneys, and the only healthy pair around belongs to Lister a few days ago. It's a closed loop played as a heist, with the crew mugging their own crewmate's past self, and the Gonzalez skeleton early on is a hint of how that might go wrong.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Stasis Leak""Future Echoes"Bill & Ted's Excellent AdventureExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Red Dwarf VI

"Gunmen of the Apocalypse" (1993)

Digital Spy's yardstick for this one, and another case of the crew racing to save one of their own from inside a strange situation.

Watch · Red Dwarf II

"Stasis Leak" (1988)

If the trip back to raid Lister's past self tickled you, here's the crew's first visit to their own past.

Watch · Film

Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure (1989)

The sunniest version of a time machine used for a very practical errand.

Sources