
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- A call about Carol
Phillip learns that Carol, his girlfriend from long ago, has died, and a company called Eulogy wants his memories of her.
- Inside the photos
With the kit and a Guide at his side, he steps into his old snapshots, frozen people and all.
- The missing face
In every photo he kept, Carol's face is scratched out. He can't remember what she looked like.
LondonSpoiler · tap to reveal
The photos lead back to Carol's move to London, a phone call that went wrong, and a proposal that went worse.
The letterSpoiler · tap to reveal
A forgotten snapshot shows a letter he never read, and the Guide turns out to be someone close to Carol.
Why it still matters
Phillip is a lonely American man with a lot of old grudges. One day he learns that Carol, a girlfriend from decades ago, has died, and a company called Eulogy asks him to contribute memories to her memorial. They send him a kit and a patient, friendly Guide who walks him into his old photographs so he can look around inside them. The trouble is that in every picture he kept, Carol's face has been scribbled out or torn away.
Brooker and Ella Road wanted something "heartbreaking and bittersweet, without a villain," and they kept to it: the company and its technology turn out to be kind, and the trouble is all in one man's memories. Paul Giamatti, who said yes the moment he read it, carries almost every scene, and Patsy Ferran plays the Guide warm and a little mysterious.
Many reviewers called it the best episode of series 7 and one of the best the show has made. It's a small story, and it works best if you go in knowing as little as possible.
What Phillip missed
Carol moved to London to play cello in a West End show. When she called on his birthday, a female colleague answered Phillip's phone, and Carol learned he was cheating. Months later he flew over and proposed at a fancy restaurant, and she walked out. For decades he has blamed her. The Guide is a digital avatar built from the memories of Carol's daughter, Kelly, who was born from a one-night stand Carol had after finding out about the affair, which means Carol was already pregnant when he proposed.
A disposable camera from that trip holds one last photo, of the hotel room Phillip trashed, and in it is a folded letter. He finds the real one: Carol admitted what she'd done, said she still loved him, and asked him to meet her after her show. He never went. Brooker says Phillip "made her into a villain in his head." Then he finds a cassette of a piece Carol wrote, and a photo of himself watching her play it, and at last remembers her face.
He goes to her funeral in London, where Kelly is playing Carol's piece on the cello, and she nods at him. Giamatti called the nod ambiguous: "We know each other, but we don't, but we do."
Behind the scenes
- Brooker and co-writer Ella Road were inspired by Peter Jackson's The Beatles: Get Back, which used technology to bring old footage and audio of the band to life.
- Brooker says the first version was modelled on A Christmas Carol, with Phillip led through his own past, and that's why the character is called Carol. It became, he said, "a lot more high tech, but also simpler."
- Brooker's father died just as post-production finished, and Brooker was asked to give a eulogy at the wake. Gathering photos for it, he noticed how few there are from before smartphones: "if, in a fit of rage, you scrubbed out somebody's face, you've destroyed a precious artifact."
- The script was written for British characters. Giamatti adjusted it to sound American, and Brooker was happy to let him.
- The photo worlds were done practically. Dancers and mimes held still as the people in the pictures, the first one took a long time to shoot because it had to look flat before it came to life, and effects were used only for touches such as the scribbles over Carol's face. The production chose not to de-age Giamatti; Declan Mason plays young Phillip.
- The funeral scene was shot on the last day of filming.
The thread
The ghost story and the documentary that started it, and the other stories about walking back into your own past.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Memory & Identity
Phillip has built his whole idea of himself on one version of a love affair, and the episode takes it apart photo by photo. The technology only makes him look properly, and what he finds changes who he thinks he is.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)
Another man walking through the rooms of an old relationship, finding out what it really was while he still can.
Read · Novel
The Sense of an Ending (2011)
Julian Barnes's short novel about an older man whose memory of a long-ago relationship is undone by a document from the past. Phillip would recognise the feeling.
Watch · Black Mirror
"The Entire History of You" (2011)
The same urge to go back and look again, with a very different result, which makes the two a good pair.
Watch · Twilight Zone S1
"Walking Distance" (1959)
A tired man walks into his childhood town and finds it waiting for him. Rod Serling's gentlest look at going back.
Sources
- “Eulogy (Black Mirror),” Wikipedia
- Keisha Hatchett, “Black Mirror 'Eulogy' Ending Explained: Paul Giamatti, Patsy Ferran,” Netflix Tudum
- “Paul Giamatti and Charlie Brooker Explore Grief and the Future of AI in Haunting 'Black Mirror' Episode,” Rolling Stone
- “Paul Giamatti Wants to Know How You Feel About His Black Mirror Episode,” Television Academy
- Daron James, “'Black Mirror' Creator Charlie Brooker on Remaking Reality,” The Credits (Motion Picture Association)
