
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Full speed ahead
Flemington runs his model-ship company like a warship, shouting nautical orders at staff who throw darts at his portrait.
- The battleship record
At home he plays a naval-battle recording at full volume. Lydia smashes it and tells him she's leaving.
- Drip
Alone in the house, he starts hearing small sounds magnified: a dripping tap, a ticking clock.
Mind over matterSpoiler · tap to reveal
A psychiatrist traces it to his silent childhood. Flemington decides he can simply will the noise away.
Poetic justiceSpoiler · tap to reveal
It works too well: he can't hear anything at all, and ends up begging for noise.
Why it still matters
Serling's opening narration sizes Flemington up as "two hundred and twenty pounds of gristle, lung tissue and sound decibels," and the episode is built like a comeuppance comedy. He bellows naval orders at the staff of his model-ship firm, stands at attention while a recording of the battleship Missouri shakes the house, and treats his wife of twenty years like a deckhand. The fun is watching the volume knob get turned against him.
What lifts it above a one-joke sketch is how it sounds. Richard Donner, who directed "The Jeopardy Room" two weeks later and went on to Superman and Lethal Weapon, makes ordinary noises into an assault: a dripping tap lands like a gunshot, and a clock's tick fills the room. John McGiver keeps Flemington from being a pure cartoon, and a short speech about his silent, strict childhood hints at why he became so loud.
It also has an odd history. A plagiarism suit kept it out of the syndication package, so for twenty years almost nobody saw it after its first broadcast.
What "mind over matter" costs him
The psychiatrist tells Flemington that his mother raised him in a house where silence was the rule, and that the roaring sea captain act grew out of that. The new sensitivity, he suggests, is that old demand for quiet coming back from inside. Flemington takes the diagnosis as an order: it's "simply mind over matter," and he sets out to stop hearing whatever he doesn't want to hear.
When Lydia comes back for her jewelry, he shuts her out, and the world goes silent with her. He puts a record on at full volume and feels only the vibration, then leans out of a window shouting for someone to make a noise. The last scene finds him in a sanitarium, where the staff see a sad breakdown. Serling's narration calls it poetic justice, and the episode is happy to leave it at that.
Behind the scenes
- In May 1961 a script called "The Sound of Silence," about a man who can't hear, was submitted to the show and turned down. Two years later Serling wrote "Sounds and Silences."
- After the episode aired, the writer of the rejected script sued Serling for plagiarism, pointing to similarities in the plot, and was awarded $3,500.
- The case was still going when the syndication package was put together, so the episode was held back. It didn't resurface until a special holiday presentation in 1984.
- Richard Donner directed. He also directed "The Jeopardy Room," which aired two weeks later, and went on to Superman, The Goonies, Scrooged and the Lethal Weapon films.
- Penny Singleton, who plays Lydia, starred in the Blondie film series and was the voice of Jane Jetson on The Jetsons.
- John McGiver was a character actor who made a career of stuffy, balding gentlemen, and later turned up in American Express's "Do you know me?" ads.
The thread
Sound as a punishment, and men who think they can will the world into the shape they want.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Funny and Creepy at Once
For most of its running time this is a sitcom about a blowhard. The jokes land because the sound design is pure horror movie, and a dripping tap is a lot less funny when it hits like a pistol shot.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Twilight Zone S2
"The Mind and the Matter"
If you enjoyed watching Flemington try mind over matter, here's a clerk who tries the same trick on the whole human race.
Watch · Twilight Zone S2
"The Silence"
Noise and quiet again, this time as a wager between two club members who can't stand each other.
Watch · Film
Sound of Metal (2019)
The serious version of where Flemington ends up: a drummer losing his hearing, with sound design that puts you inside his head.
Read · Short story
"The Tell-Tale Heart" by Edgar Allan Poe
Poe's narrator insists he's perfectly sane while one sound gets louder and louder, a problem Flemington would understand.
