Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 1 / Episode 15

Too Short a Season

An elderly admiral is called back to free hostages on a planet where he once made peace. On the way there he starts getting younger, and he's keeping the reason to himself.

  • First aired Feb 8, 1988 · Syndication
  • Directed by Rob Bowman
  • Story by Michael Michaelian
  • Teleplay by Michael Michaelian and D. C. Fontana
  • Guest starring Clayton Rohner and Michael Pataki
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Too Short a Season"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Too Short a Season"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Too Short a Season" (Syndication, 1988). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. The admiral

    The Enterprise picks up Admiral Jameson and his wife Anne. Karnas, governor of Mordan IV, says dissidents hold Federation hostages and want Jameson.

  2. Younger by the hour

    During the trip Jameson leaves his wheelchair and keeps getting younger. Dr. Crusher finds an unknown substance in his blood.

  3. The drug

    Jameson admits he's taking an alien youth drug meant to be taken over two years. He took it all at once, and it's hurting him.

  4. No dissidentsSpoiler · tap to reveal

    There are no rebels. Karnas took the hostages himself, to get Jameson back for something he did decades ago.

  5. Mordan IVSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Jameson's body gives out in front of Karnas. He dies in Anne's arms, and she asks that he be buried on Mordan IV.

Why it still matters

Admiral Mark Jameson negotiated a hostage release on Mordan IV 45 years ago, and now its governor, Karnas, has asked for him by name. Jameson comes aboard in a wheelchair, with his wife Anne beside him. By the time the Enterprise reaches Mordan he's on his feet and looks decades younger. The de-aging is the hook, and what Jameson isn't saying drives the story.

D. C. Fontana was brought in to overhaul Michael Michaelian's script, ending included. What's left is a story about an old officer and a decision he made decades ago that hasn't stopped mattering.

The execution has problems. The ageing make-up was rushed and widely criticised, and reviewers were hard on Clayton Rohner as Jameson. But Michael Pataki, who played Korax in "The Trouble with Tribbles," makes a strong Karnas, and DeCandido called his return a triumph.

Spoilers from here on. The man holding the hostages is the man Jameson once armed.

Both sides

Jameson finally tells Picard what he did 45 years ago. To get the hostages out that time, he gave Karnas the weapons he asked for. Then, to keep things even, he armed Karnas's enemies too. He called it his interpretation of the Prime Directive. He expected a short war, and Mordan IV got 40 years of one.

So the hostages were bait. Against Picard's advice, Jameson leads a rescue through the tunnels under Karnas's mansion, and it fails when he collapses. Karnas threatens to kill a hostage every 15 minutes unless he sees Jameson, then refuses to believe this young man is the admiral. Jameson shows him a scar from their old bargain.

The drug finishes what it started, and Jameson dies in his wife's arms. Karnas releases the hostages and grants Anne's request that her husband be buried on Mordan IV, the world his deal helped wreck.

Behind the scenes

  • Michael Michaelian first pitched an idea based on andropause, then wrote a treatment and first draft about reverse ageing.
  • D. C. Fontana overhauled the script. In the original ending there were peace talks, and Jameson survived but was reduced to fourteen years old and couldn't remember his wife.
  • Clayton Rohner and director Rob Bowman worked on the character on weekends before filming. Bowman found the script too "sit-and-tell."
  • Jameson's wheelchair cost $10,000, and prop designer Joe Longo called it the "big albatross." A simpler version was later built for Deep Space Nine's "Melora."
  • Westmore and Werner Keppler were the whole make-up team, and Jameson needed four make-up stages, the oldest taking up to four hours to apply. Bowman later called the result substandard; Westmore said that with less than a week to prepare, it turned out reasonably well.
  • Karnas's office is decorated with phasers from the original series and films. It was the last episode to use a built cityscape model until "Birthright."
  • Its Nielsen rating of 10.9 was the series' highest since "The Big Goodbye."

The thread

Youth bought at a price, and an old deal that never stopped costing.

Came before

Shares DNA with

What it left behind

"Melora"Star Trek: Deep Space Nine · a simpler version of Jameson's wheelchair was built for it

DNA strand

Be Careful What You Wish For

Jameson wants enough youth to fix a mistake he made when he was younger, and the drug gives it to him faster than his body can survive. The episode sets his hunger for more years against Karnas's hunger for revenge, and both men get what they asked for.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Kick the Can""Long Live Walter Jameson"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · The Twilight Zone

"Kick the Can"

Old age and the dream of being young again, told gently, with no alien drug involved.

Watch · Star Trek

"A Private Little War"

Kirk weighs the same choice Jameson made, arming one side to balance the other. See whether it looks wiser in 1968.

Read · Novel

No Surrender by Jeff Mariotte

A Star Trek novel in which one of Jameson's old shipmates learns what he did, and leaves Starfleet over it.

Read · Short story

"The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" by F. Scott Fitzgerald

Another man living his life in reverse, imagined back in 1922.

Sources