
The story in 5 beats
- Distress call
A Romulan science ship has had a warp core accident. Geordi and Ro beam over to help with the repairs.
- Beam-out
A transporter accident on the way home leaves Geordi and Ro aboard the Enterprise, unseen and unheard. They walk straight through people.
- Death certificates
The crew declares them dead. Ro sees the paperwork and believes it. Geordi refuses to, and starts working the problem like an engineer.
Out of phaseSpoiler · tap to reveal
They aren't dead. A Romulan cloaking experiment has put them out of phase, and the Romulans have planted something that will destroy the ship at warp.
The memorialSpoiler · tap to reveal
Geordi and Ro crash their own funeral, a jazz party in Ten Forward, trying to get anyone to notice them before the ship goes to warp.
Why it still matters
It's a ghost story where the ghosts disagree about whether they're ghosts. Geordi La Forge and Ensign Ro Laren beam back from a damaged Romulan ship and arrive nowhere: they can see each other and the crew, walk through bulkheads and people, and nobody notices them. Ro decides they're dead. Geordi, an engineer to the bone, decides there's a technical explanation and goes looking for it.
Ronald D. Moore's script moves briskly from one problem to the next, and David Carson directs it like a thriller with jokes. It's one of the best hours for Michelle Forbes's Ro, scared and very funny at once, especially when she realizes she is still intimidated by her superiors even though they can't hear a word she says.
Keep an eye on Data, too. Put in charge of the memorial service, he has done his research, and his idea of a funeral turns out to be a party.
Not dead, just out of phase
The Romulans were testing a phase inverter, a device for cloaking. The transporter accident put Geordi and Ro out of phase with normal matter, which is why they can pass through it. On the Romulan ship Geordi learns something worse: the Romulans have sabotaged the power transfer so the Enterprise will be destroyed the moment it goes to warp. A Romulan who is also out of phase follows them back, and Geordi ends up throwing him through the hull into space.
Data, meanwhile, notices odd chroniton readings around the ship, and Geordi realizes they are leaving a trail every time they walk through a wall. Data insists on an anyon sweep before warp, which briefly makes the two of them visible. At their own memorial, a New Orleans jazz send-off with Riker on trombone, Ro overloads her disruptor to make the biggest chroniton field she can. Data turns the anyon emitter up to full and they snap back into phase. Geordi warns Engineering in time, and the two of them join the party.
Behind the scenes
- It was planned as a budget-saving bottle episode, but the phasing effects ended up making it expensive.
- It was nominated for the Emmy for sound mixing for a drama series at the 44th Primetime Emmy Awards.
- Colm Meaney wasn't available, so Shelby Leverington plays the transporter chief, Brossmer.
- All three Romulan actors came back to Star Trek. Susanna Thompson later played the Borg Queen in some Voyager episodes, and Thomas Kopache played seven roles in all, among them Kira's father on Deep Space Nine.
- Data researched 5,000 funeral rites before choosing the New Orleans send-off, complete with "When the Saints Go Marching In."
- The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen called it "an atheist's fable," with Geordi as the skeptic and Ro as the believer.
The thread
Ghosts who don't know they're ghosts, and the cloak that came back to haunt Starfleet.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Is Any of This Real?
Geordi and Ro are living through the same impossible situation and reading it two opposite ways. One thinks it's the afterlife, the other thinks it's physics, and the episode lets each of them be right about something, so you get a ghost story that comes with a technical manual.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Ghost (1990)
If the best part was Ro shouting at people who can't hear her, here's a whole film of it, with more pottery.
Read · Novel
Lincoln in the Bardo by George Saunders
A graveyard full of spirits who refuse to believe they're dead, and a lot of comedy about it. Ro would have opinions.
Watch · TNG S7
"The Pegasus" (1994)
A Riker episode from the final season that picks up an idea from this one. Best to go in without reading up on it.