
The story in 5 beats
- A distress call
Nikolai Rozhenko, Worf's foster brother, calls for help from Boraal II. The planet's atmosphere is breaking down and its people will all die.
- Worf in disguise
Surgically altered to pass as a Boraalan, Worf goes down alone and finds Nikolai sheltering a village in a cave behind a force field.
- Picard says no
Nikolai wants to save the village. Picard refuses: the Prime Directive forbids it, and it isn't their place to choose who lives.
The power drainSpoiler · tap to reveal
After the atmosphere goes, the crew traces a power drain to the holodeck. Nikolai has moved the villagers aboard inside a copy of their caves.
VorinSpoiler · tap to reveal
On the way to a new world, the village chronicler Vorin wanders out of the holodeck. He can't live with what he learns.
Why it still matters
This is the Prime Directive at its hardest. Boraal II is losing its atmosphere and everyone on it will soon be dead. Picard's position is that Starfleet can't decide that one group survives while the rest of the planet perishes, so it doesn't interfere at all. Dr. Nikolai Rozhenko, a Federation cultural observer who has been living among the Boraalans, thinks that's a fancy way of watching people die.
Nikolai is also Worf's foster brother, the son of the human couple who raised him. Paul Sorvino plays him as charming, stubborn and entirely sure of himself, and Michael Dorn spends much of the hour surgically disguised as a Boraalan, trying to keep his brother in line and not having much luck.
It's one of the most argued-over episodes of the last season. Tor.com's rewatch gave it 1 out of 10, arguing that the script casts the man trying to save lives as the villain; The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen thought the Prime Directive debate was too one-sided to carry much tension.
A village in Holodeck 5
Nikolai uses the sensor interference from the dying atmosphere as cover and beams the whole village into a holodeck, where a replica of their caves keeps them believing they're still at home. Faced with it, Picard reluctantly agrees to find them a new planet. Crusher and Data pick Vacca VI, nearly two days away at maximum warp, and Geordi warns the program may not last that long. Worf, inside with Nikolai, nearly comes to blows when he learns his brother has fathered a child with a villager, Dobara.
Vorin, the village's chronicler, steps out of the holodeck and into the Enterprise. Boraalan neurology means his memory can't be wiped, so Picard and Troi offer him the choice of staying aboard or going back knowing his world is gone. He can't accept either, and takes his own life. The rest of the village is beamed down to its new home. Nikolai stays with them as their new chronicler, Worf makes his peace with him, and Picard tells Crusher he regrets that Vorin couldn't bridge the two worlds.
Behind the scenes
- The idea is credited to William N. Stape, with the story by Spike Steingasser and the teleplay by Naren Shankar.
- Peter David's earlier novel Worf's First Adventure named Worf's foster brother Simon. Printings after this episode aired renamed him Nikolai.
- Penny Johnson, who plays Dobara, later had a recurring role on Deep Space Nine as Kasidy Yates.
- Star Trek: Insurrection (1998) came back to the holodeck relocation: Wikipedia notes that its plot, like this one's, moves a people with the help of a holodeck.
The thread
The Federation's most famous rule, tested by a man who won't stand by.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
The State Knows Best
The Prime Directive is the Federation's idea of humility: don't play god with other cultures. This episode looks at that humility from the ground, when the culture is about to die. Picard has the rulebook and Nikolai has a plan, and the episode doesn't let either of them off easily.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Novel
Hard to Be a God by Arkady and Boris Strugatsky
If you were on Nikolai's side, meet Rumata, an Earthman undercover on a medieval world who is forbidden to step in, and how badly that sits with him.
Watch · TNG S2
"Pen Pals" (1989)
Data hears a child calling from a planet that is falling apart, and the crew argue about the same rule in a gentler key.
Watch · Enterprise
"Dear Doctor" (2002)
A Starfleet captain and his doctor find a whole species in trouble and have to decide how far to go.
Sources
- “Homeward (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- “Star Trek: The Next Generation season 7,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Homeward",” Reactor (Tor.com), 2013
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "Homeward"/"Sub Rosa",” The A.V. Club, 2011
- “Star Trek: Insurrection,” Wikipedia
- “Hard to Be a God,” Wikipedia