
The story in 5 beats
- The Vico
The Enterprise finds the research ship Vico wrecked in a dark cluster, its crew dead. Data finds one boy alive under the debris.
- Timothy
Timothy's parents are dead, the ship's records are mostly wiped, and he won't let go of Data, who rescued him.
- Becoming an android
Timothy starts to copy Data in every way. Troi has a name for it and thinks it may help him heal.
What happenedSpoiler · tap to reveal
In the cluster, the Enterprise is hit by mounting shock waves. Timothy finally says he thinks the Vico's loss was his fault.
Lower the shieldsSpoiler · tap to reveal
Timothy's memory of the Vico's last minutes gives Data the answer, and Picard lowers the shields.
Why it still matters
Timothy is the only survivor of the research vessel Vico, and he starts copying Data: the clothes, the hair, the manner, the insistence that he has no feelings. Troi has a word for it, enantiodromia, and thinks it may help him recover. So Data is asked to go along, on the idea that pretending to feel nothing may be how the boy gets through feeling too much.
The A.V. Club gave it a B+ and counted its patience among TNG's greatest strengths: nobody treats Timothy's grief as a problem to be fixed by the end of act four. It's also a good Data episode. In Ten Forward he explains, kindly and honestly, what he can't do and would like to, such as enjoy his food.
Patrick Stewart directed it, as he had "In Theory" the season before. Gene Roddenberry died while it was being filmed, and production stopped when the news reached the set.
It wasn't him
Timothy is sure he caused the disaster. The truth comes out as the Enterprise goes through the same thing: the waves get stronger every time the shields are strengthened, and Timothy remembers the Vico's crew doing exactly that. Data works out that the waves were feeding on the shields, so Picard drops them and the waves die away.
With the guilt gone, Timothy lets go of the android act, though he isn't over his loss, and the episode doesn't pretend he is. In the last scene he sits out a class singalong of "Row, Row, Row Your Boat," and he and Data agree to stay friends.
Behind the scenes
- Gene Roddenberry was no longer involved in day-to-day production when he died during filming. Wikipedia's season article says work stopped when the news reached the set.
- Hilary J. Bader, a third-season writing intern, wrote the story. With "The Loss" and "Dark Page" it was one of her three TNG credits; she went on to write children's animation and comics.
- Geordi's story to Data about a fire in his childhood was first written for the next episode, "Violations," then cut from that script and used here.
- This is the second time the Breen are mentioned, after "The Loss." They were only seen years later, on Deep Space Nine.
- Joshua Harris was reportedly cast mainly for his skill at imitating Brent Spiner's head movements.
The thread
Data's earlier try at raising a child, and stories of children who find comfort in a machine.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Do Machines Dream?
Usually Data wants to be human. Here a human child wants to be Data, because a machine can't be hurt, and Data ends up patiently explaining what he's missing.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S3
"The Offspring" (1990)
Data as a parent before this: he builds a child of his own and tries to teach her how to be a person.
Watch · Film
The Iron Giant (1999)
A lonely boy befriends a machine, and the friendship gets him through something hard. If Timothy and Data got to you, you'll feel at home.
Read · Novel
Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro
It's narrated by an artificial friend who studies the child in her care very closely, with the same gentle mix of machine logic and human hurt.